games  anime  |  toys
This is a Dtoid readers's blog. For staff blogs click here. Confused? read this Create you own!  |   Members: Login now





Thoughts on Piracy, or Why My Eyelid is Twitching
Josh Tolentino | 10:34 AM on 07.16.2008 17 comments




Now that the biggest loads of this year's E3 have been shot off, I'm gonna talk about piracy. Then again, this is probably relevant to E3, considering so many developers' and publishers' worries. Piracy and the perceived (perceived!) decline of the PC gaming market is one of the reasons PC gaming seems to have such a light presence at E3 this week.

CryTek and Bioware, both big-time PC devs, famously sounded off on the issue. Piracy is a major force driving sales of the PSP (hurr, no gaems), and EA tried poking at the problem and ended up STABBING ABSOLUTELY EVERYONE

Anyway, Ryan Sumo wrote a good article in The Escapist just the other day.

Entitled "Piracy and the Underground Economy" it offers viewpoints that many gamers in richer countries might not have considered, describing realities on the ground and the environment he (and I) grew up in.

The pirated games trade is a matter of course in the developing world, and for some, a matter of livelihood. It's created an underground economy, with its own network and infrastructure, filling a space that legitimate distributors have been unable or unwilling to enter.

Keep in mind that it's not about the cracking, torrenting, and downloading of a game, which is what comes to mind when most western gamers think about (or perform) piracy. It's about the market stalls and shopping malls, the hawkers and shopkeepers that furtively hand you an expanding folder filled with xeroxes of game box art.



In the end the article implied that game companies might do well to treat pirates an opportunity, tapping the existing underground economy and selling no-frills copies of games at relative pricing, "relative" being a proportional price based on economic and social realities in the region. For example, a $60 game in the US might be sold for $5-10 in Manila, reflecting economic differences and bringing equity into the equation.

This kind of pricing differentiation already happens with schoolbooks. A $45 dollar college textbook goes for less than $5 in the Philippines, but is printed on newspaper stock and lacks a cover or pictures (for the most part).

In fact, this kind of strategy is exactly why the dreaded region-coding system exists, the one that enrages so many PAL and Asian gamers with delayed releases and other indignities.

There are obviously some concerns with this plan. Is it not unfair to richer gamers to buy the same game for much more where poor people get it for much less? Maybe, but it's what happens with movie tickets (Manila = $3, San Francisco = $13.50 + food).

Won't rich gamers just import the cheapo poor-country games and screw publishers even more? Perhaps. It really comes down to the cost-benefit analysis, and I'm no CFO, as I'm terrible at math (4th grade-level according to a recent neuropsyche test).



It's a sensitive topic, for sure, but what I didn't really didn't expect was the color of some bile sputtered in reaction:

If you cannot afford a game, you are not meant to play it. Just like if you cannot afford a BMW, then you are not meant to drive one.

and:

Perhaps gamers in developing nations should spend some time getting an education and bettering themselves instead of playing video games. All the time wasted playing video games you could have probably learned something useful in the meantime and picked themselves up out of poverty.

What fucking arrogance. We're talking about BUSINESS, and how companies can make more bucks by maybe bending down a bit to let a few of the great unwashed onto the wagon. This isn't an issue of morality or of entitlement, but of economics and the differences in market geographies.

The thought that all this is merely some kind of a rationalization for theft, that developing nations should just up and "develop" themselves up to where they can afford luxuries at your prices is bigoted, elitist, narrow-minded, shortsighted, and frankly quite offensive.

I'd hate to see that same argument used if fucking HEALTH INSURANCE were somehow considered a "luxury". And given some of the discussions going on in America, that may well be the tragic case.



Games are a commodity, not a privilege or a right. Nobody, at any level of income or social status, in any country, "deserves" to own a video game or a video game system. I think everyone understands that fact. Piracy IS a problem and its pervasiveness in the developing world exacts its own costs on society and the development landscape. MMOs are so big and "traditional" games so small in Asia for this reason.

All that's being said is that economic and social realities in the region suggest a different, regionally-oriented business model that allows game providers to, well, PROVIDE.



Edited and reposted for length, added pictures for you tl;dr types.



Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

0


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

17 comments | showing # 1 to 17

prev next

Josh Tolentino's Destructoid Blog
To the 4 handsome and attractive Destructoid members who commented earlier, my apologies, I did some major editing (don't rant while in an epileptic seizure) and added some afterthoughts re: relevance to E3/PC gaming.

Also, does anyone know how to add a "jump" to my blog posts? Whenever I look at it I want to tl;dr myself.
garrfunkel's Destructoid Blog
Thank you for the pictures it made it easier for the likes of me.
Josh Tolentino's Destructoid Blog
I have to say I only thought of adding Mr. Moneybags and Scrooge McDuck very late and it worked out. Better than the low-res bill stacks, at least.
dephect's Destructoid Blog
TLDR.

Piracy is a crime, dont steal ships.
Merry Ho's Destructoid Blog
I'm tired of blogs against piracy, they are pointless, the people who pirate video games arn't going to stop if they read this, they know what they are doing is wring and they don't care. And the people who do agree with you, well that's about all they can do is agree with you. so I'm sorry if i fail to see the point of any blog that says piracy is bad, its like telling teenage boys not to masturbate, like that would ever happen.
HawtPawkitHero's Destructoid Blog
TLDR
I'll still do it.
Josh Tolentino's Destructoid Blog
Indeed, it seems to STILL be TLDR, because the post isn't against piracy.
Senisan82's Destructoid Blog
eye lid twitching is due to stress or loss of sleep.

bbrigg1's Destructoid Blog
or homosexuality
bbrigg1's Destructoid Blog
by the way, so as not to seem like a dipshit who posts on articles he doesn't read:
agreed, those comments in bold are pretty stupid.
Merry Ho's Destructoid Blog
either way, im still tired of posts about piracy, i read most of it and it came off as anti piracy, maybe not sleeping for the last 16 hours is affecting my brain, i might read it again after i sleep, but i most likely wont remember even writing this.
RAB's Destructoid Blog
money money muuhhney---



monayyy
robestyles's Destructoid Blog
Commie
Josh Tolentino's Destructoid Blog
Hardly. What's being proposed here is equity. What commies want is equality.
falinter's Destructoid Blog
I can't wait till technology advances to the point where I can pirate physical objects.

What a day that will be.
zaqu's Destructoid Blog
the BMW statement is kinda true im not gonna pirate every game on the planet because i can

i pirate when i debating whether or not to buy review system is broken so theres no assurence relying on those
Josh Tolentino's Destructoid Blog
@zaqu

I think you've missed the point here. The article (and my post) deals primarily with the purchase of pirated copies by poorer countries from pirate distribution rings in a kind of underground retail network, NOT the downloading of games.

And that BMW statement is terribly wrong. If it's out of your price range, you may not be in the target market, but you are in NO way undeserving of same.

BMW are free to make cheaper BMWs for the masses, and they do, but no one, NO ONE, is ever "not meant" to own anything. It's business, not the formation of social ladders.


prev next


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

 about me

I'm Josh "unangbangkay" Tolentino, and this is my cry for attention.

I also write for Japanator. Come visit, and see me gush about things not directly related to video games. Or not. But hey, diversifying interest in me is definitely something I wouldn't mind.

My Portfolio Blog: Death by Eroge!

Features:

-Resident Evil 5 isn't racist, just ignorant and unambitious
- Dude, be cool! Don't hate on Final Fantasy so much!
-Don't Blame the Genre, Blame the Game: Why JRPGs Don't Intrinsically Suck
-Thoughts on The Escapist's Piracy Issue
-Sorry Doomsayers, Japan Isn't In (much) Development Danger.
-Can Critics Be Trusted When They Don't Trust Themselves?
-The Colorless Mask: Insult or Insight?
-Your Fate is in the Cards: "The Fool's Journey" in Persona 3
-Persona 3: The Rest of The Fool's Journey
-Thoughts on Piracy: Why My Eyelid is Twitching
-Persona should be called "Pimp-sona" and its heroes are enviable pimptastic jerks
-Truth and Reconciliation: Why Persona 4's ending is super awesome
-You wanna buy some goddamn eroge. DO IT DO IT DO IT

Promoted Musings:

-Playing With Others: Playing Alone, Together
-A Time to Destroy: To Hell With Your Rules, I'm Cheating
-Feel the Hatred: The Quick Time Event
-The Start of the Affair: My Own Mute, My Own Heartstrings
-Good Idea, Bad Idea: Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment
-For Those About To Die: A Letter To The Combine Overwatch
-Other Worlds than These: I Left My Heart in Inaba
-Untapped Potential: Talk to us dirty, Mr. Developer
-The Forgotten: A Storm of Romance Under the Banner of Love

Reviews:

-Overlord 2
-Red Faction: Guerrilla
-inFAMOUS
-Dynasty Warriors Gundam 2
-Demon's Souls
-Valkyria Chronicles
-Spider-Man: Web of Shadows
-Innocent Life: A Futuristic Harvest Moon
-Rune Factory: A Fantasy Harvest Moon
-Multiwinia
-Crysis Warhead
-The Experiment


Contact Info!

Twitter: unangbangkay

Facebook


 xbox 360 gamertag
 mii friend code:
6258-3610-4242-3684

 friends' updates
Brad Nicholson's Profile Brad Nicholson
Killzone almost a year older, K2 double XP weekend coming
BulletMagnet's Profile BulletMagnet
The Obscurer Tribune # 21
CblogRecaps's Profile CblogRecaps
C-blogs of 11-23-09 and Qalamarisms
Chad Concelmo's Profile Chad Concelmo
The Memory Card .76: Brotherly love
Ckarasu's Profile Ckarasu
A gift to the community: Demon's Souls PS3 theme (Sexy Update with a new theme)
Clayton S Chan's Profile Clayton S Chan
How to Win a Raffle Drawing: A Public Service Announcement.
Colette Bennett's Profile Colette Bennett
The Whispered World gets lucky at German Game Dev Awards
Dale North's Profile Dale North
Square Enix remix CD Love SQ now up on iTunes
DtoidSanFrancisco's Profile DtoidSanFrancisco
NARP recap (w/ pictures!!!)
garison's Profile garison
I've been on Dtoid for a year and 26 days, and I want to make love to all of you
Gen Eric Gui's Profile Gen Eric Gui
Public Service Announcement: How to control your allies' actions in battle in Persona 3
Hamza CTZ Aziz's Profile Hamza CTZ Aziz
The Daily Hotness: More Heroes
Jim Sterling's Profile Jim Sterling
UK Charts: Modern Warfare 2 beats Mario, Assassins Creed
Jonathan Holmes's Profile Jonathan Holmes
You will not survive this: Super Meat Boy boss reveal
Jordan Devore's Profile Jordan Devore
Wait, what? Mercs Inc. wasn't actually canceled
king3vbo's Profile king3vbo
Why I Love Destructoid
Magnalon's Profile Magnalon
The New Kid in Town: An Aion FAQ
Mikey's Profile Mikey
The Destructoid Comic: Power up!
Necros's Profile Necros
Cheesy Double Down (fixed!)
Nick Chester's Profile Nick Chester
Agent, are you ready for a ton of Crackdown 2 images?
Niero's Profile Niero
Join Destructoid at the University of Miami's Launchpad
pedrovay2003's Profile pedrovay2003
HOLY CRAP, THE FATAL FRAME IV TRANSLATION IS ALMOST DONE.
pendelton21's Profile pendelton21
The Gaming Gourmand: Video Game Foods I'd Never Eat
Primo's Profile Primo
My Pixeljunk Eden Painting
RAB's Profile RAB
"SSF4 roster was decided a long time ago" Also a video walkthough of SSF4 so far
Samit Sarkar's Profile Samit Sarkar
Survey suggests Evan Longoria will be MLB 2K10 coverboy
Scrixx's Profile Scrixx
I hugged Scrixx..
Shin Oni's Profile Shin Oni
SSF4 Spectulations stop! Metro City Making that way in
SilverDragon1979's Profile SilverDragon1979
I celebrated my 30th birthday with beer, DJ Hero, and 600 balloons
SurplusGamer's Profile SurplusGamer
I can't defend what Tim Schafer said, but...
sylphx's Profile sylphx
Persona Movie Trailer Finished!
Tactix's Profile Tactix
Dtoid Community Discusses pt 19: Digital Distribution
Tehmtnlion's Profile Tehmtnlion
I used up all my quarters and couldn't play (NVGR shortblog)
The Incredible Edible Egg's Profile The Incredible Edible Egg
Late Dreamcast love!
TheCleaningGuy's Profile TheCleaningGuy
Yakuza 3 Confirmed for the West?
thefil's Profile thefil
The Modern Warfare 2 Dedicated Server Complaint is Legitimate
Topher Cantler's Profile Topher Cantler
Podtoid 126 records tonight: Butts, butts, butts
walkyourpath's Profile walkyourpath
Thanks, You Guys! (Header Image Unrelated)
Y0j1mb0's Profile Y0j1mb0
A Destructoid Thanksgiving.


 

 
  get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
contribute a news tip
suggest a feature
be a guest editor
support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?
keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meetup+play online
seriously

about Destructoid
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap
our network

Tomopop
Japanator
Despingation?




Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
living the dream since March 16, 2006