Sounds like everything i thought from the reviews and fan reaction, as for your question: "The biggest issue, is the bi-polar reactions of the fan base - what exactly DO the fans want? Do we want classic Resident Evil, or do we want third person shooter run and guns? "
Honestly? listening to fans is near useless, one day they love the style and the other they crap over it, and if this post is to be believed critics are the worse part of the fandom:
"The problem isn't with the game but with the critics who have gone soft and lost good judgment. And if I sound bitter, it's because of those critics that Capcom won't make another title in the style of this classic survival horror adventure."
At the end of the day what people say is irrelevant, its what they do afterwards what matters and as sales numbers shows as big as the outcry about the original RE being dumped in favor of action RE might be, fact is ever since RE2 they sales have declined constantly and only picked up when RE4 came out. Do i say that there are no fans out there that really want old school RE? no, but i'd bet they're a vocal minority when it comes to the sales and sad as it may be, it's the people still buying the games despite the complains that causes things like this, on disc day one DLC, Complete Editions instead of whole games on day one, etc.
To those fans i say, forget RE and wait for other options, I've already said that the best 3 are Amnesia, Nintendo's take on Fatal Frame and Kojima's take on Silent Hill.
Also I have an objection:
"One cool aspect to the 5th installment was the inclusion of co-op gameplay - something very new to the main series of games."
No, hell no!, forced co-op was the worst idea RE5 gave to the industry, the fact is that not only it forced us solo players to deal with a moronic AI that tars the whole experience but that it created a trend where several others devs thought it was a good idea while not fixing the AI issue. The fact that it took nearly 4 years for someone to notice the issue and fix it (or at least attempt to, i'll hold my judgement until the release of Dead Space 3) only makes it hurt more.
P.S. Before some genius pops up to criticize me on "saying" Action RE is better than Survival Horror RE, let me say: no, i've never said that, i like both in fact but as much as they would want to deny it, reality is that Action RE sells better.
Honestly? listening to fans is near useless, one day they love the style and the other they crap over it, and if this post is to be believed critics are the worse part of the fandom:
"The problem isn't with the game but with the critics who have gone soft and lost good judgment. And if I sound bitter, it's because of those critics that Capcom won't make another title in the style of this classic survival horror adventure."
At the end of the day what people say is irrelevant, its what they do afterwards what matters and as sales numbers shows as big as the outcry about the original RE being dumped in favor of action RE might be, fact is ever since RE2 they sales have declined constantly and only picked up when RE4 came out. Do i say that there are no fans out there that really want old school RE? no, but i'd bet they're a vocal minority when it comes to the sales and sad as it may be, it's the people still buying the games despite the complains that causes things like this, on disc day one DLC, Complete Editions instead of whole games on day one, etc.
To those fans i say, forget RE and wait for other options, I've already said that the best 3 are Amnesia, Nintendo's take on Fatal Frame and Kojima's take on Silent Hill.
Also I have an objection:
"One cool aspect to the 5th installment was the inclusion of co-op gameplay - something very new to the main series of games."
No, hell no!, forced co-op was the worst idea RE5 gave to the industry, the fact is that not only it forced us solo players to deal with a moronic AI that tars the whole experience but that it created a trend where several others devs thought it was a good idea while not fixing the AI issue. The fact that it took nearly 4 years for someone to notice the issue and fix it (or at least attempt to, i'll hold my judgement until the release of Dead Space 3) only makes it hurt more.
P.S. Before some genius pops up to criticize me on "saying" Action RE is better than Survival Horror RE, let me say: no, i've never said that, i like both in fact but as much as they would want to deny it, reality is that Action RE sells better.

surf dtoid with 






Rising (10+)
People you follow













send message
follow
followers



