Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by meteorscrap | Catherine boxart change: An interesting dilemmaDestructoid
LIGHTS:  ON | OFF
surf dtoid with arrow keys



REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll

click to hide banner header
About
My name is meteorscrap.

Occasionally I'll post random thoughts and musings here which are too long, too detailed, or otherwise don't fit in the comments section. Given the length of some of the stuff I've left as a comment, you can well imagine what I consider long.

Do you like words? 'cause I got a lot for you.

Promoted Articles
I've written a couple really good pieces which no longer show up on this blog. Check them out below.

02/11 MM Groundhog Day: Final Fantasy Tactics
04/11 MM AaMaazing: Final Fantasy II
05/11 MM P2 Press Start: A torrid co-op love affair
Digital Distribution: Developers are poisoning the well
Downloadables: Sequence
Reveling In The Joy Of Movement

Destructoid owes me a six-pack! Woo!
Player Profile
Follow me:
meteorscrap's sites
Badges
Following (12)  


Well folks, I was on Amazon today and I was looking at Catherine for my Xbox 360, figuring I should just go ahead and pre-order it. From what I've read of the game, it's basically a platforming puzzler meets Alpha Protocol/Bioware Game choice system, which is something I heartily approve of.

Anything which gives me complex choices is nothing but a good thing, is something I've always thought. Yet I found that decision coming to bite me in the ass a little bit right about now.

With the upcoming release of Catherine, I found myself facing an interesting dilemma of my own, name thus:



Atlus is providing two versions of box art for each release. The original cover art, and an alternative meant for easier consumption by the less open-minded folk. Normally boxart doesn't really matter one way or the other to me.

Now admittedly, there are a couple of games with excessive fanservice cover art which I keep tucked out of sight when family comes over. X-Blades and games of its ilk come to mind quite readily. Now, Catherine follows the same suit, at least as far as the original cover art is concerned. In fact, aside from the anime roots, it's actually a little more fanservicey than most: Instead of featuring outlandish characters, it's something a little more commonplace with a few freakish elements juxtaposed on the cover.

Now, I know which one I'm ordering. I decided to go for the original, because most of my family and friends know I'm an irredeemable lech anyway. It's not like this would be anything new. However I did give brief thought of ordering the alternate box art, so I'm wondering...

If you're interested in Catherine, are you picking up the edited box art, the original, or does it simply not matter to you?
Photo



Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!




Those who have come:



Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


It does not matter, but if I could choose, I would go for the original. It is not the first game that receive this treatment, as Hyperdimension Neptunia also has a different cover than the original japanese one. This just shows how many retailers still see videogames as toys and therefore they must think of the 'children'.
I'm going with the original, The alt covers aren't bad, but I think it's kind of ridiculous that you have to do this for American games. They raised the leggings for DOA, they photo shopped less cleavage onto Samurai Warriors 3, and for some reason our covers tend to have angrier characters.
I like the original 360 cover.

Not because I'm a butt guy, but because it just looks better.

Also because I'm a little bit of a butt guy.
Since Law talked about it, why Atlus just do not put both versions, the Xbox 360 and PS3, in the package? You would just need to flip the cover you like most, the butt one or the boobies one.
Definitely going with the original, PS3. I don't like the new ones, they're lazily cropped and sort of ugly in my opinion.
I actually like the new 360 one, only because I like prim and proper Kathrine.

I actually like the crop jobs. Makes it look like they where special editions with extra stuff in them.

Don't know if they'll have extra stuff in them, but it would be cool.
Everyone, quick, jump to conclusions!

Could be a mock-up, could be a change. Not the RP on the cover. You KNOW this game is going to garner some media attention just because of the attention its getting from the non-Atlus crowd, so Atlus might be trying to not draw that attention from the media - then again, the media has let the Shin Megami Tensei series with its occultish and violent themes.

If you follow Atlus at all, though, they're kinda known to do reversible cover art at times, which they've done with various PSP and DS releases over the last couple of years.

So if you have that much of a hard-on for the original covers, ask for reversible covers as a pre-order bonus at Atlus USA's forums, though be careful what you ask for as that may affect how Atlus manages the spoils. I dunno, I'd rather have a soundtrack CD than some sexier box art.
"then again, the media has let the Shin Megami Tensei series with its occultish and violent themes fly under the radar entirely.

There, I had to fill in the blank.

Seriously, though, SMT Nocturne was a much riskier title than this. You fought topless demons - which even showed up in Devil Survivor, I might add - and bondage-geared angels there. And you could make a deal with Lucifer to take on the heavens, among other things.
Options are always nice though I'll be passing on this game. It's waaay too Japanese for my tastes.
If I do get it, unless the PS3 version is somehow superior, it'll probably be 360 without cover censorship. I don't see why anyone would WANT the censorship, unless they're worried about other people seeing the cover; family and the like.
Well, since I'm picking it up for the 360, I'd prefer the original, since I think Vincent in his tighty-whities attempting to climb to the top of Kat's ass is rather hilarious. However, it doesn't really matter to me-the new covers look fine. And it's the same game on the inside, of course. I approve of what Atlus is doing, to be honest-not every wal-mart will want to stock a game with an anime-style girls boobies out there in the open, so they're making a change [for some, not all boxes!] so they can get it into more stores. I'm fine with that-let's sell more Catherine. ;p
@The Silent Protagonist

Actually, according to Amazon, there are two versions of Catherine for each console. A regular and a "alternate box art" which has the cropped versions shown. It's not exactly jumping to conclusions here.

Especially since, according to Siloncera, it's official from Atlus that the cropped versions are variant art which are "more considerate of certain retailers’ broader customer demographic."

*shrug*

Back to Top
DLC   |   BEST Games of 2012   |   Best PC Games   |   Best PS3 Games   |   Best Xbox 360 Games   |   Best Wii U Games   |   Best 3DS Games




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more