Quantcast
Destructoid - Tony Ponce's Community Blog




About Me
EMAIL
tony@destructoid.com
megastryke@gmail.com



Many video games build upon the concepts and mechanics of their forerunners. Off-Brand Games examines those that draw just a little too much... inspiration.

00 Introduction
01 Power Blazer
02 Commando: Steel Disaster
03 Snood
04 Midnight Resistance
05 8 Eyes
06 Onimusha Blade Warriors
07 The Krion Conquest
08 Scurge: Hive
09 3-D WorldRunner
10 Alundra
11 Chex Quest
12 Giana Sisters DS
13 Run Saber
14 Crusader of Centy
15 DuLuDuBi Star
16 Fighter's History
17 Robopon
18 The Simpsons Road Rage
19 Neutopia
20 Ruff Trigger: The Vanocore Conspiracy
21 Soul of Darkness *Official Review*
22 High Seas Havoc
23 Tube Slider
24 Tales of Elastic Boy - Mission 1 *Official Review*

MONTHLY MUSINGS

A Time to Build: Fangames
A Time to Destroy: The games that destroy us
Playing With Others: Let's play a game, dad!
Playing With Yourself: Travel, Game Boy, and you
Expanded Universes: Learning Japanese culture with Mega Man
Those About to Die: Mega Man and the burden of fratricide
Other Worlds Than These: Inconstancy in the Mario universe
Regarding E3: Reactionary motion
Untapped Potential: A true family computer
I Suck at Games: The blame game
The Forgotten: Battletoads on the go and in the arcades
Nothing Is Sacred: Kill the controller
Love/Hate: The NES was great... no, it wasn't!
The Future: Death

SPECIAL SAUCE

Too much vision: Stop concerning yourself with game potential
'Immersion' is a nonsense buzzword
Style Savvy: The review no one needs for the game no one wants
Why Mega Man 6 is the best of the Mega Mans
Wii Fit and Heavy Rain are not that different
Gamer Profile
3DS friend code:
Steam:
Battle:
PSN:
Mii:
Gamertag:
Following (14)
Ashley Davis
Bob Muir
BulletMagnet
Darren Nakamura
DtoidOrlando
GamingGoddess
Jonathan Holmes
Josh Tolentino
NukaCola
Qalamari
Tascar
Tubatic
VGMari
Y0j1mb0
Off-Brand Games: Giana Sisters DS
Tony Ponce | 6:09 PM on 11.25.2009 25 comments




The Great Giana Sisters is the gold-plated standard of video game clones. It's the most famous case of digital plagiarism thanks to its choice of source material. It just didn't copy any game, it copied Super Mario Bros., the biggest game of all time.

Nintendo was being a big doodie-head by not wanting to port its cash cows to personal computers, so Time Warp Productions from Germany went ahead and developed their answer to the Italian duo for the Commodore 64 in 1987. It wasn't long before Nintendo unchained the legal hounds and forced publisher Rainbow Arts to withdraw The Great Giana Sisters from the market.

That should have been the end of the story. The game gathered a cult following mostly consisting of poor suckers who didn't grow up with an NES. Despite that, there was no reason to believe that a rerelease of the original or a new chapter in the franchise would ever appear as long as Nintendo was still kicking.

Then the unthinkable happened.



OFFENDER: Giana Sisters DS
DEVELOPED BY: Spellbound Entertainment
RELEASED ON: DS, 2009
TASTES LIKE: Super Mario Bros.

The work of the original's creator, Giana Sisters DS is the biggest anomaly in gaming since Sonic and Mario started playing nice with one another. The Great Giana Sisters was blocked at retail by a court injunction, a stern warning to all who would wish to step on Nintendo's shoes, yet not only was a remake allowed to be made but also it was licensed by its former oppressor for play on the DS handheld. That's like visiting The World of Coca-Cola and discovering that Chek soda is served in the cafeteria. Mind blowing.

For most people, this game still doesn't exist. It received a veeeeeery limited release early this year in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland as well as one a few months later in Australia. Future releases such as in the UK or the US are not looking rosy. Skimming through the site of publisher dtp entertainment AG, you can tell that these guys aren't exactly on the ball.



I now present to you ADVENTURES IN IMPORTING! I like my game cases without big, honkin' warning labels obscuring nearly a third of the cover, so there was no way I was ordering the German version. Instead, I hunted down an Australian copy on eBay and paid the God-awful international shipping charges. Would you look at the crazy exchange rate! Aussie gamers, you gotta get your ass out of that penal colony, pronto.



I had never physically seen an Australian video game case. For reasons beyond comprehension, there are a number of variations from the cases used in the rest of the world. As you can see above, Aussie DS games travel in transparent boxes. Is this to prevent drug smuggling? Is this the lazy man's way of noting if you are carrying contraband without going through the trouble of opening the damn thing?



It's thick, too. Compared to a standard DS case, an Aussie case is a full quarter-inch wider. The game cards and manuals aren't any bulkier. Maybe the extra material used in the packaging process increases the manufacturing costs. That's probably why prices in the country are so outrageous.



On a more pleasant note, look what's on the back! The Nintendo Seal of Quality! There it was all along! The sneaky devil! See, guys? No need to worry anymore over lack of quality assurance! The next time someone bitches about how Nintendo should bring back the seal, you can reply, "It didn't go away! It just moved Down Under! I guess it must really love Vegemite!"

As one adventure ends, another one begins, so let's psych ourselves up with a little backstory. As young Giana, you are admiring your treasure chest of blue gems one night before crawling into bed. You stir awake a short while later to find your gems being sucked into a vortex. You must jump in after them and reclaim your lost treasure while traipsing through a mysterious new land.

Pulitzer material.



HOW SHAMELESS IS IT?

Giana Sisters, how misleading. Both the title and the box art imply a sisterly companion who doesn't exist. The adorable blond is Giana and the fiery redhead is her punk alter ego. You'd think there would be a two-player option, but no. The Mario games never stooped to such deception.

But I can't stay mad for too long. Look at that art! Check out the clean, simple sprites! This game is a treat to gawk at. It is so adorable, filled with bright colors and skimping on excessive detail. What a stark improvement over the nipple-tastic original.

One thing that the original could claim as its own was its soundtrack, widely hailed as one of the greatest chiptune scores of all time. The DS remake features remixed jams from the original, and after listening to them I would have to admit that the music is pretty darn good. I personally wouldn't call it some of the best music... with the exception of the intro theme. My Lord, listen to it! So rich and complex! I swear, the first time I popped the game in, I let this shit loop for several minutes!

Beautiful art. Beautiful music. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful. I've got a real treat in store, don't I?

...

...



...

...

Okay. What the hell, guys.

This game is way too retro. I never played the original game, so I can only imagine how simple it must have been for this bare-bones update to be considered an enhancement. Everything is just so... bland.

It's obvious why Nintendo got so pissed in the eighties. Coin blocks? Check. Bricks that you can only open once you've transformed? Check. Hidden coin blocks posing as bricks? Check. Underground and castle levels? Double check. Where it differs is in what it lacks, such as pipe-looking structures that you think you can enter only to find you cannot. Longtime Mario players who are conditioned to inspect tubing for secret passageways will certainly feel confused and annoyed.

The punk transformation I mentioned earlier is activated by picking up these little pink balls that pop out of coin blocks. Punk Giana is this game's Fire Mario, bestowing upon thee the gift of pyrokinesis while skipping the intermediary "super" form entirely. Other than punk balls and coins (gems, in this game's case), you get nothing. There are no 1-ups, no invincibility items, nada.



Scratch that. There are two extra items that can only be used within the levels you acquire them. There's bubble gum which allows you to float in the air by pressing the jump button or blowing into the mic and soda pop which can break through bricks that are not directly overhead. As in New Super Mario Bros., these items are activated by touch. Why? You only use two fucking buttons! There was nothing else these things could have been assigned to? Really? Really? Those shoulder buttons are looking mighty lonely! In addition, every menu in the game gives you the choice of navigating by touch or D-pad with the exception of the map. If you want to return to previous levels, you are required to physically tap the level marker. Retarded.

There are eight worlds consisting of nine normal levels plus a bonus stage unlocked by collecting all the red gems in a world. These gems are not hidden. They are not even slightly out of reach. They are right there, in your path, waiting to be walked over. Not until much, much later do you have to work for your prize, and that's what this game feels like: WORK.

Side-scrolling platformers are known as jump 'n' runs in other countries. Break them down to their basics and you've got jumping and running. The most highly revered games are the ones that find the right balance between the two. Giana Sisters DS only requires the bare minimum. You just run left to right, left to right, left to right, breezing through in manner of seconds. Why bother with checkpoints that are literally ten seconds apart from one another! You jump on some blocks, hop on a baddie's head, clear a pool of water, and then you are finished! Next stage!



Levels only start becoming longer, challenging, and maze-like by around the sixth world. That means that more than half the game is spent running one long, bullshit tutorial. I wouldn't mind so much if there was some level variety, if there was a play style shake-up now and then. World one has grasslands and undergrounds, world two has the same grasslands and undergrounds with no change to the tile sets, and so on. I finally hit the snow zone and thought, "Hot shit! Now we are talking!" It's a superficial change. There are no environmental hazards or level-specific gimmicks, just jack all. It's barren! The game is a wasteland!

The art direction is so amazing! I have been deceived! Surprise, it's not just high-concept, next-gen pap that feeds off style over substance.

What's your motivation? Greed. Pure, unadulterated greed. Blue gems are scattered everywhere, ripe for the gathering. Pick them all up! Every hundred nets an extra life! Collect, collect, collect! Why? Because you can! The only gems that matter are the red ones, but the blue ones are just so plentiful! Coins are littered about in Mario games, but that has never been an excuse to skimp on level design. In Giana Sisters DS, the only way to glean any satisfaction is to follow the money. Some levels are just so brazen as to literally plant the goal flag right next to the entrance. The game knows you can't resist some cheap self-gratification.



Baddies have no names as admitted by the developers. There is only one boss, a fire-breathing dragon akin to Bowser only fatter and goofier, who appears at the end of every castle. His attack pattern never changes. The only variation in the encounters is the number of jumps required to defeat him. Who is he? What does he want with you? Did he suck you into this dimension? Is he the one hoarding your gems? He looks like a douchebag.

The game isn't bad, it's just stale. How is this a grand revival of a beloved classic? Well, good news, nostalgia buffs! After completing the eighth world, you can play a recreation of all 32 levels of the C64 classic! These levels are even shorter. I wasn't even trying and blazed through all of them in just over ten minutes. As a comparison, the current Super Mario Bros. 100% speed run record is 19 minutes, 40 seconds.

This was the original game? Are you kidding? From what I've heard, the original had more items than is available here, but even with the extra toys I can't see how The Great Giana Sisters could have stood on equal footing with Super Mario Bros. The game was dated before it even hit store shelves. I suppose when your parents punish you by buying a fucking Commodore, you take whatever scraps you can find and make a banquet.



Giana Sisters DS was an opportunity to revitalize a property that suffered from a bevy of shortcomings. This game could have been so much more, could have distanced itself from Super Mario Bros. to a greater degree. As it stands, it will never crawl out of the shadows of the mighty plumbers. Not even kickass music can save it now.

*sigh*

God damn Germans.

THE CHEK SODA SCALE OF SUMMERTIME REFRESHMENT:



Attached photos:

Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo Photo

Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

20

Those who have fapped:  MkShiranui  


Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

23 comments | showing # 1 to 23
prev next

Jon B's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 18:56
Jon B
Why do you do this to yourself...
Monodi's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 19:55
Monodi
Oh i didn't know the Giana Sisters were not really sisters! I feel like all my life... or the end of October which Ashley Davis taught me about them, was a lie!

Seriously, finding this is curious. there are many platforming games that tried to get on the shine of Mario, this one tried, stayed but did not harm or caught that much attention, and the remake doesnt seem to be in good shape.
Tony Ponce's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 20:20
Tony Ponce
In the original game, you do have a sister named Mario. In the sequel, Maria is tossed out and never mentioned.
Tony Ponce's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 20:20
Tony Ponce
Maria. Named Maria.
Elsa's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 20:29
Elsa
Fabulous review... though you seem to have a knack for picking... odd... games! :)
Jack Maverick's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 20:34
Jack Maverick
With the main motivation being greed, you'd think they would have made this a Wario Land clone of some sort. Hell, that dragon dude bears a vague resemblance to Wario.
Excel-2011's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 21:18
Excel-2011
Don't be so hard on the Commodore. I'm sure there's a very good reason thousands of European gamers have such fond memories of it.
phantomile's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 21:58
phantomile
@megaStryke: Hahaha, Freudian slip?
Das Inchworm's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 22:25
Das Inchworm
man i couldn't beat either 8-2 or 8-3 with all of the red diamonds so i quit. Shit was rage inducingly hard.

Also, awesome rating as usual.
Davoidbot's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 22:40
Davoidbot
http://games.adultswim.com/worst-game-ever-twitchy-online-game.html

From the sound of it, this looks like it's less bland.
Tony Ponce's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/25/2009 23:48
Tony Ponce
@The-Excel

Euro trash.

@phantomile

Ha ha! You betcha!
Birdman the Friendly's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/26/2009 02:08
Birdman the Friendly
Funnily enough, not all Aussie DS boxes are thick like that, which really annoys me. I have 13 DS games, and 7 of them are in those thick boxes and the rest are in the thin ones- all are Aussie games. It doesn't make any sense. The spines don't line up! ALL I ASK FOR IS CONSISTENCY ; _ ;
Projectexodus's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/26/2009 11:47
Projectexodus
Hehe, I considered finding a copy of this game once, but I'll change my mind now.

@Birdman the Friendly

In Europe, all the boxes are thick and transparent.
Mike Moran's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/26/2009 16:29
Mike Moran
There was actually a homebrew sequel before this in development called Giana's Return, which I thought was an enjoyable little game.
Perry Simm's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/27/2009 03:52
Perry Simm
Great review!

You wouldn't believe how many people, especially in Germany, actually think of the original Giana Sisters as "way better than Super Mario Bros." and "a milestone in video game history". That's what blind nostalgia does for you...!

That said: Duuuuude, don't diss the C64. It was basically the home computer equivalent to the NES and had tons of really great games.
Krian's Avatar - Comment posted on 11/28/2009 01:37
Krian
Where it differs is in what it lacks, such as pipe-looking structures that you think you can enter only to find you cannot.


Check out the last picture... those pipe-thingies were in the original, too. You could actually get a powerup that let you walk through flames.
Ubersuntzu's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/09/2009 00:09
Ubersuntzu
I realllllllllly want this game.
zebu's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/11/2009 06:05
zebu
Giana Sisters on the C64 WAS better than SMB. It had better graphics, spritework, colors, more lively music, and more variety in gameplay. It was a tremendous fun, and not because of nostalgia. I still find it an excellent game.

Of course we are comparing it to SMB (NES), and not SMB All-Stars, SMB3 etc. which all have been created years later.

The DS version is great too. Beautiful artwork and music to start with, means even the lesser, earlier stages are good enough if for nothing else, but collecting the gems and relax. It's a very relaxing game, and this is the real charm of it.

I agree, there are some shortcomings: more block items would have been better, more level/gameplay variety, more challenge, less checkpoints, more hidden red gems, more secret levels would have been great too. I miss a hard mode and a two player mode (MARIA, where are you?).

But these flaws can be forgiven, and the game can turn out very replayable, if you really got what it's made for. Collecting all the gems in such levels like 3-10, or X-2 are darn great fun!
FatherChesz's Avatar - Comment posted on 12/16/2009 14:10
FatherChesz
I ordered a copy of Electroplankton that came in a transparent box. Didn't even consider that it could have been the norm in other countries, but then again, it's got an ESRB rating on the front, bad print quality, and an obviously 'shopped Official Nintendo Seal on the back. Fucking scammers on eBay.
Nathaniel607's Avatar - Comment posted on 05/08/2010 16:30
Nathaniel607
Dude, the DS cases are like that in the UK too.
Carla Moldoveanu's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/18/2010 03:30
Carla Moldoveanu
Actually, Australian game cases are like the American ones, except for some games which came from Europe.
Bracey's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/24/2010 20:48
Bracey
I had the Giana Sisters on the Amiga and it was miles better than SMB's!!!

While I breathe the word Amiga, I automatically think of Moonstone, please God make someone make a remake of Moonstone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Conrad Zimmerman's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/10/2011 20:57
Conrad Zimmerman
How dare you suggest that my Commodore was a punishment.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!