games  anime  |  toys
This is a Destructoid readers's blog. For staff blogs click here. Confused? read this Create you own Dtoid blog, it's free!  |   Returning members: Login now


[ Y0j1mb0's blog ]



The Glut of Gaming Websites & How Everybody is a Game Expert.
Y0j1mb0 | 3:14 PM on 11.06.2008 18 comments




It seems that everywhere you turn, there's yet another game site ready to give you their expertise criticism and review. Can't get what you want from one? Aren't being fed your particular brand of "Game X" product? No worries mate, just a Google away I'm quite sure you will find what you are looking for. From game blogs/sites catering to a particular console of choice, to anecdotal ones catering to your funny bone, to others focusing on your gaming frugality it's out there ready for you. As a matter of fact there's a ton of it. So much so that it is getting to the point that anybody with DSL and an opinion is an instant expert on games and are ready to roll out their gaming site to the masses. If Joe Blow from Kokomo likes games, has time on his hands and wants to make a name for himself, enter another new game related site to the picture.

Why really all you need to have for a semi decent launch of one is a gimmicky name, a bit of controversy via flame inducing pieces or nonsensical reviews used to highlight an extreme opposite view of the norm for vacuuming hits from the game fanatics and you're getting there. Hell, it's just as easy to write for a gaming site nowadays as it is doing amateur porn. While I don't begrudge anybody from making either a stab at what they love or from making a living, is having so many gaming sites, so many so called "experts" hurting the gaming scene overall? Should there be a universal litmus test that be required before the creation of these new gaming ventures? And are the glut of them, with a large percentage being of the amateur variety, hurting the legitimacy of real gaming sites and blogs?

From a layman's point of view I'll try to tackle these questions. First, for the purposes of this post I will refrain from distinguishing between journalistic and blogging sites. The point of this is not whether one is better than the other, because both types offer a needed voice for gamers and both can be just as informative as well. No, this is a look at the differences between game sites/blogs done right and those that are just lazy affairs and offer nothing more than a platform for fanboys to rally against each other or worse... echos of pieces posted elsewhere with just enough words changed that accusations of plagiarism can be held at bay.

It is actually pretty funny, when you think about it, how people in general with not a lick of experience in the game industry think unto themselves that they indeed are legitimate writers or editors because they got some facsimile of a game site up. That's like me touting off a title for myself, on my gmail and everywhere I post something, below my name akin to: Francisco Rodriguez, Feature Editor of the Cblogs of Destructoid. Everybody seems to be an expert nowadays so it's only fitting they create the illusion of legitimacy with a title but just because I can cook a mean omelet doesn't mean I'm a chef. That same analogy should be applicable here with people and their gamesites/blogs.

In my humble opinion I believe the glut of gaming sites are definitely hurting the gaming scene overall. Why? Because the majority of it is of the sophomoric kind. Offering nothing to the table that somewhere else is not being done, except that there it's of better quality and infused with a sincere passion. I mean look at the Metacritc user score buffoonery for a snapshot of why some people just don't need to have an open portal to the masses. Hell, take a look at N4G and peruse the titles of the sites/blogs' pieces highlighted there. About a third if not more, are of the flamebaiting kind. Drivel that even in our own Cblogs would be pounced on as fail and if done enough might get you a closer look at Hamza's banhammer, yet there it is, out in abundance... thriving.

In large part not because they are so good but because we here in the land of the Internets love us a fanboy fight, or a nice heaping of fabricated controversy to get the focus of most ADD gamers' attention. Should there be a universal litmus test that be required before the creation of these new gaming ventures? Boy, in a perfect world a video game SAT should be taken by all before even thinking of starting something but that's just not going to happen. In that same imagined perfect world, people should pay their dues in the industry or in the very craft of writing itself before they can stand toe to toe with the creme of the crop.

How many times have you heard such and such site said this or gave this review score yet here in Destructoid is different? Just because the sum of participants in Metacritic shell out a rating percentage on a game that doesn't gel with what's on tap here doesn't mean they're off base here, and I'm not even talking about a true 1-10 rating system, it could be the growing collective of Metacritic may not have a clue. The new fad of" I don't like it... therefore it sucks" mentality of these so called experts who honestly don't know better, are taking root and conceivably diluting not just the quality of game reviews but of gaming websites overall. We could take it the other way as well. Maybe these new game sites are not wanting to buck the norm. They may want to fall in line with the rest out there which is just as bad. If you have to read somebody else's review before you post your own, there's something wrong with that.

Lookit, I'm getting sidetracked here, this isn't about reviews. This is about a shitload of sloppy gaming sites making real ones look bad, or just lost in the sea of stupidity. Like a big tower of Jenga pieces that people keep piling on to, the only question to ask now is this.

Just how many more of these garage made gaming sites will we stack before it all comes tumbling down?



  related blogs:
 

Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

0


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

18 comments | showing # 1 to 18

prev next

MrSadistic's Destructoid Blog
I'm pretty sure you're wrong. I should know, I'm an expert at these sorts of things.
SilverDragon1979's Destructoid Blog
Why look at that. Yojimbo finally stopped playing SOCOM and LittleBigPlanet long enough to write a blog. Well it was about damn time and it's good to have you back.

I personally only stick to a few gaming sites myself. The list includes ...

1) Destructoid
2) Giantbomb
3) Joystiq
4) Kotaku
5) Gametrailers

Honestly of those 5 I really only pay major attention to Destructoid and Giantbomb. Those are the best two websites out there in my opinion, with opinions on games and game related issues I respect the most.

On a side note, I only recently stopped reading IGN because their site it to fucking hard to navigate since the layout change.
shipero's Destructoid Blog
Please, old man, you just don't understand the nouveau game journalism scene. People are tired of facts and rational opinions, the public now demands hyperbole and cynicism. Get with the times grandpa, the age of the angry, sarcastic, malcontent is upon us and it is good.

Shipero - Feature Editior: Shipero's Blog
brainderailment's Destructoid Blog
I have noticed that you can find hundreds or maybe thousands of gaming sites. They are just redundant and many times full of old news or just flamebait. I don't know what could go wrong having so many sites, I guess it just makes it harder to get away from flamers and shitty rumors.
mix's Destructoid Blog
So are YOU telling me that there is, as well as gaming sites, too much amature porn...*GASP* lol

I really only check out Dtoid.com and I post the odd post on Gamefaqs.com and yea the odd time I go to gamespot.com and other than that I dont post ot chat with anyone on any other sites nor do I check them out or look for them.

I could care less what rating a game gets and I will not create an account on a new site to defend a game becuase someone gave it 1/10. I play games and rent them and create my own opinions.This is not the case with millions of people though as they feel that if they like something everyone else in the world should like it as much as them. This also applies to people who find something to be crappy and everyone should agree with them as well....big 'ol circle of assholes.

So yeah I think there will always be a bucket load of various internet sites/porn/clothes as not everyone can, or ever will, agree on the same thing so they will sort through until they find something that suits them best.
VWGTI's Destructoid Blog
Yojimbo, I want to thank you for writing this piece and expressing how I feel exactly. Too many people think they can create their own web site and find a niche, when in fact they offer nothing unique or original.

IGN and Gamestop offer corporate news and nobody is going to compete with them anytime soon. Gametrailers focuses on videos and videos alone. Screwattack focuses on retro gaming and provides an interesting video game news segment every day of the week.

If you plan on creating a web site, be sure to break away from the mold or your web site will be lost in the sea of mediocre gaming sites. It doesn't take a genius to write a few paragraphs about a video game.
Josh Tolentino's Destructoid Blog
I don't think that the growing abundance of schlock sites will have a significant impact on the quality of discourse, or at least not kill it.

For every self-proclaimed expert there's a great site like Dtoid, The Escapist, Kotaku, GiantBomb, Rock Paper Shotgun or Crispy Gamer.

What we're seeing is growing diversity in voices, and part and parcel with that is a growing proportion of schlock. Opinions. What really matters is whether the game site in question really speaks with its own voice, and there's no harm in letting as many people as possible try, even if what results is mostly a keening screech.
Daxelman's Destructoid Blog
I don't think I can call any other Gaming site trash, least for GameFAQs, where they burn churches for lulz over there.

All sites have at least something I'd read, comment about, and link to, save for GameFAQs, where they burn churches for lulz over there.

With me, the more people try, as long as it ain't the blatant fanwanking of another site, I'm welcome to it.

Except for GameFAQs, where they burn churches for lulz over there.
liam2015's Destructoid Blog
I don't worry about those sites. And honestly, I don't care that anyone can create their own crappy website and try to talk about something. I just try to find the good ones (like ol' Dtoid here), and stick to them.

The others aren't bothering anyone.
BFeld13's Destructoid Blog
One of the reasons a lot of people think that they can start up their own gaming site is that game publishers and PR Reps support it. I used to write for one of these hacked-together sites (emphasis on 'used to') and despite having virtually no readership, we were able to get review copies for games as well as press release emails and FTP access.

The fact is that some people who set up these sites may not consider themselves 'experts' but may just simply want free stuff and a piece of the swag action.
RonBurgandy2010's Destructoid Blog
I can't come up with a snarky comment right now. Give me a little more time.

Also, what do you care Jimbo? You're rich! You can just buy every game.
Steel Squirrel's Destructoid Blog
What? Destructoid was a sort of "garage" site to begin with. It has completely transformed into something much more official since, but who's to say one of these other random places won't be the next Destructoid or Kotaku? Given the right circumstances, anything like that seems to be possible, that is why people even bother to start their own sites. It is just a new era in journalism.

It's like getting upset because garbage like National Enquirer and The Sun exists amongst highly regarded periodicals.

Ultimately it is up to the individual to sort out what information is relevant to them. If you can't decipher what is quality information and what is shit, that's your problem.

As for it all "tumbling down", that was a tad melodramatic for video game websites don't you think?
Atlas's Destructoid Blog
I is a good thing a gaming expert like Yojimbo came out and told us this. We need more experts like him crowding the scene and telling us what is what.
Danmartigan's Destructoid Blog
swiftly's Destructoid Blog
I totally agree with you Y0j1mb0 sir. I'm a huge music fan and read a lot of music blogs and the general standard of writing and objectivity in them is so far above the level of the average games site that it's scary.
Ali D's Destructoid Blog
I think this is just what the internet promised: everyone get's a voice, even if they are a fucking douche. I mean I write a music blog (only I haven't bothered updating it in over a month)in which I just mainly talk about the music I like and in a fairly easy going manner. But if someone thought I was an expert I think I'd be fairly embarressed.

I think some of the crappy gaming sites won't be able to sustain themselves, if all they're doing is giving people a place to vent and spew bullshit. Eventually they'll tire of it and leave.
Touch's Destructoid Blog
As the last couple of posts have said, this is, unfortunately, a problem with the net as a whole - not just gaming sites. Disingenuousness is rife, people in chat rooms feel no compunction to back up their statements with verifiable facts, and they all claim to be in high-paying positions which they offer as proof of their knowledge in a particular field. As Chief Researcher for Sony, I find this very irritating!
swiftly's Destructoid Blog
Touch wins word of the day with Disingenuousness!


prev next


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

 about me



Veni, vidi, vici.

Name: Francisco *AKA* Y0j1mb0

Age: 38. I'm the residential Old Geezer of Destructoid & You Tube Superstar.



Likes: Poker, Roast Beef Sandwiches, unsolicited sex, video games of all genres.

Dislikes: Elitist Pricks, Hippies, People who use the words "But I digress" and "n00bz"

Consoles I Own: PS3, Wii, Xbox 360, PSP Slim, DS Lite.
[ PSN:k0wb0y-b33b0p - Friend Code: 0774-3918-3804 - LIVE: y0j1mb0 ]

Game I'm DYING to get my grubby hands on next!!



Destructoid is a haven for truly fantastic artists. Below are but a few examples of their work I was lucky enough to receive from them. Behold my bearded samurai depictions. See if you can guess which talented Dtoider did them.























Games I love in no particular order:

Borderlands
Persona 3 :FES
Persona 4
Valkyria Chronicles.
Indigo Prophecy.
Sacred 2: Fallen Angel
Dead Space
Zack & Wiki: Quest for Barbaro's Treasure
Killzone 2.
Street Fighter IV.
SOCOM:Confrontation.
Flower.
Left4Dead.
Shadowrun.
Ico.
Shadow of Colossus.
Crimson Skies.
Crackdown.
Gunvalkyre.
Jet Force Gemini.
Pikmin Series.
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night.
Metal Gear Solid Series.
NFL 2k5.
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker.
Otogi.
Front Mission 3.
Panzar Dragoon Orta.
Marvel vs. Capcom 2.
Metal Slug Series.
Virtua Fighter 5.
Dig Dug.
Mario Kart DS.
Advance Wars Series.
Tobal #2.
Animal Crossing.
Tecmo's Deception.
Manhunt.
Deathrow.
Deus Ex.
Street Fighter 2.
Half Life 2.
Dead Rising.


Founding Member of The Official Destructoid Beard Club and once Proud Reserve Recap Cblogger.

Proprietor of PS3 Friday Night Fights and PS3's Poker Nights ( Mondays @ 10pm EST. )

Things off the Blog I do. Once every month I review two movies. Generally obscure, cult classics or off the radar flicks that need to be seen by all.



The New Movie Reviews are in the works as soon as I get off my procrastinating ass and do them.

Past Movie Recommendations:

Gangster No 1
Zatoichi The Blindswordsman
Glengarry Glenn Ross
Oldboy
A History of Violence
Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer
The Seven Samurai
High Tension
Brazil
Jacob's Ladder
Frailty
Unbreakable
Man Bites Dog
City of God


Epic Card Courtesy of The Ghost.


 xbox 360 gamertag
 mii friend code:
0774-3918-3804

 friends' updates
Anus Mcphanus's Profile Anus Mcphanus
Are Music Games like Rock Band/Guitar Hero Ruining Music?
Arttemis's Profile Arttemis
Why I love Destructoid
atheistium's Profile atheistium
I'm in Canada for a Ubisoft Montreal Event
BahamutZero's Profile BahamutZero
Pachter's dumber than a bag of rocks, buy Borderlands.
Ballistic's Profile Ballistic
Other Worlds Than These: City 17
Banj's Profile Banj
A death on XBOX Live...
bhive01's Profile bhive01
Destructoid crashes Safari/ Spam on the Increase
blehman's Profile blehman
Dear Diary, I've Met Someone Else
BluDesign's Profile BluDesign
A More Positive Katamari Forever Review...
BluFire's Profile BluFire
I Love Ubiquity.
brainderailment's Profile brainderailment
Review: Rocket Fish PS3 Rapid Fire Wireless Controller
BS3 Owner's Profile BS3 Owner
RE5:Alternate Edition... 1st (VIDEO) Footage of NEW Chapters from TGS'09!
CblogRecaps's Profile CblogRecaps
Cblogs of 11/7/09 and 11/8/09 + SilverDragonisms
ceark's Profile ceark
I can't figure some things out and it's driving me nuts.
Colette Bennett's Profile Colette Bennett
Reminder: Win a new PS3 courtesy of FEARnet!
Conrad Zimmerman's Profile Conrad Zimmerman
Amazon has Dissidia as Deal of the Day
Corak's Profile Corak
PS3 Controller Add-On, A Must Have!
CountingConflict's Profile CountingConflict
Extra Life
CronosBlade's Profile CronosBlade
360 Paradise Wednesday Week 2 - 10PM EST
decoyb's Profile decoyb
Fails at blogging.
Electro Lemon's Profile Electro Lemon
Ahh, Sony Marketing Strikes Again
Elsa's Profile Elsa
Unauthorized Passion.
Eschatos's Profile Eschatos
It's my birthday!
EternalDeathSlayer's Profile EternalDeathSlayer
I think I'm becoming dumber. Or stupider. Whatever it is.
Excremento's Profile Excremento
A Weird Kid's Top 10 -- NES Games That You Had To Leave on All-Night To Beat
Gameboi's Profile Gameboi
Zelda Marathon in progress, do your part to help a good cause
GoS-CPT-Stewart's Profile GoS-CPT-Stewart
Up and Atom - A Molecular Puzzle Game
Ha-Puken's Profile Ha-Puken
The 12 minute life changing experience
Haxan's Profile Haxan
Where the Wild Things Are photo shoot got Dugg (also, new photos) [nvgr]
IronPikeman's Profile IronPikeman
PS3 Friday Night Fights: Pikeman Take-Over Edition
Jim Sterling's Profile Jim Sterling
Killzone 3 'confirmed' on Dutch TV, Guerrilla denies all
kaciesaurus's Profile kaciesaurus
Holy amazing awesome craft
king3vbo's Profile king3vbo
Why I Love Destructoid
Kryptinite's Profile Kryptinite
People in the gaming industry: Is your passion still strong?
liam2015's Profile liam2015
10 things you or may not know Liam, but probably won't.
MaxVest's Profile MaxVest
My New Job As A Chicken Sexer -- Not What I Thought It Would Be
Mikey's Profile Mikey
The Destructoid Comic: Power up!
MrSadistic's Profile MrSadistic
There's only one thing you need to know about me:
naib's Profile naib
Fails at blogging.
Necros's Profile Necros
Cheesy Double Down (fixed!)
Niero's Profile Niero
Have a microphone? Want to participate in a Destructoid video?
Ocified-Xboxer's Profile Ocified-Xboxer
When 12 & 200 Just Isn't Enough
PwnyBownz's Profile PwnyBownz
BREAKING NEWS: Fallout 3 Confirmed for PS2
RiotMonster's Profile RiotMonster
Aborto's Ultimate Tag Team Contest: Relentless Annihilation and Violent Rape Edition
Samit Sarkar's Profile Samit Sarkar
Infinity Ward pulls MW2 Hamels video after Internet furor
SantanaClaus89's Profile SantanaClaus89
PS3 Friday Night Fights: What Can I Do For You Edition
Serpentish's Profile Serpentish
ShadokatRegn's Profile ShadokatRegn
My Recovered Gaming Rig, Let Me Show It To You
shipero's Profile shipero
PS3 Friday Night Fights: Here Ya Go
SilverDragon1979's Profile SilverDragon1979
So I apparently gave Borderlands its lowest PC review score on Metacritic
Skribble's Profile Skribble
Left4Dead2 Australian gore fix :)
Solgrim's Profile Solgrim
Here Is A Look At Netflix On The PS3
superflossy's Profile superflossy
Happy Birthday Christian Bale!!!
Takeshi's Profile Takeshi
PS3 Friday Night Fights: Nothing but awesomenessnessness Edition
tazarthayoot's Profile tazarthayoot
Top 10 reasons it's Samit's birthday
Teta's Profile Teta
Teta draws some destructoid... OH SHIT IS A SHARK
the GAMEGOBLIN's Profile the GAMEGOBLIN
My bestest buddy, UnstoppableJuggernaut
The GHost's Profile The GHost
Why I Love Destructoid
thefil's Profile thefil
The Modern Warfare 2 Dedicated Server Complaint is Legitimate
Topher Cantler's Profile Topher Cantler
Trailer for SSFIV's new modes, now in English
Trev's Profile Trev
It's been a busy month, Dtoid
vexed alex's Profile vexed alex
Beneath the Pixels: Wind Waker Part One
Video Cognito's Profile Video Cognito
SHORT BLOG: Extra Uncharted 2 Beta Codes
VWGTI's Profile VWGTI
Go out and buy Borderlands. Right now.
wardrox's Profile wardrox
A Short Film By Wardrox
Y0j1mb0's Profile Y0j1mb0
Happy 30th Birthday SilverDragon!!
Yashoki's Profile Yashoki
Destructoid look-a-like contest! (where you win nothing)
youkilledmyguy's Profile youkilledmyguy
Autistic Kid Plays WoW And Thinks Cops Are Maniacs.


 

 
  get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
contribute a news tip
suggest a feature
be a guest editor
support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?
keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meetup+play online
seriously

about Destructoid
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap
our network

Tomopop
Japanator
Despingation?




Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
living the dream since March 16, 2006