Life is short and there's games to be played. So quickly to the thick of things.
Kotaku in this
article right here has pointed out that "Sambo", an old derogatory racial term for black people in America, appears in Scribblenauts. And it spawns a watermelon.
I'll give you a minute to freak out, knee-jerk, breakout your stock race card rhetoric and cool things to say like "I'm black and I don't have a problem with this" "Negro is the spanish term for black" "This again? Really?" "Would you rather it spawn a black person?" or, my personal favorite "Why are they pulling the race card?"
You done?
OK good. So, with that out of your system, I do encourage you to check out
Kotaku's article and what they do right . Instead of leaving it "We found this, no one has been reached for clarification. We'll have more on this later", the fine gents at Kotaku have laid down some sick JOURNALISM, and done a few, in my opinion, very good things.
For one, they got the word on this from Jeremiah Slackza, the creative director for Scribblenauts. He notes that the inclusion is appropriate, because of the fruit that bears that name in Latin America, which looks pretty close to the watermelon. Well, aside from being spotted. And white on the inside...
Further, Kotaku goes on to kindly explain the racial term's origins and connotations. This, I feel, is above and beyond the status quo for gaming blogs that will touch on this subject, and really does a great service to its readers. I'm surprised, impressed, and actually very appreciative of the effort they put into explaining facts surrounding the issue, essentially equipping the gamers in their readership with knowledge about the subject, should someone outside of this rational gamer circle question the situation. Certainly, there's a risk of informing gamers of cute new phrase throw around Xbox Live. But, truly,
you can't not sell eggs because some punk kid is probably going to egg somebody's house.
The comments, naturally, turned into more or less the same ruffled feather scuttlebutt that bubbles out of most gamers in reaction to the threat of slight against their hobby and the incredulous reactions of people that just don't want to consider the blessing that is having unique cultures in the world. I don't want to go off on a rant here, but, I think Kotaku's been doing some interesting and responsible things so far as covering controversy and "touchy" subjects. I'm hoping that going the extra step to inform readers on a factual leve is a trend that gets picked up by most gamey newsy sites out there.
I can believe its generally no easy task! Kotaku's article came from the efforts of three members of the staff, including the chief editors in their crew! Considering all the factors you mentioned, their effort here is really impressive.
Seriously, thanks for the post Tubatic: because, "I don't get it!" :D
Before we start performing more fellatio on Kotaku further lets point out they put up a post about a perceived racist terminology in a friggin' DS game. Seriously, was that post even necessary? I mean aside from a sensational title to generate controversy and additionally more hits to their site. Are the developers of Scribblenauts a bunch of white supremacists subliminally inserting racist propaganda in their games?
The short answer to that is no. I'm sure as hell not going to give them an attaboy because they're thorough in creating a legitimate backstory to their bullshit post. Fuck Kotaku and everybody else who try to sift and mine for the latest hook to net an audience.
"Are the developers of Scribblenauts a bunch of white supremacists subliminally inserting racist propaganda in their games? " Whoa there samurai: nobody from Kotaku is saying that, and any reasonable person that knows the term can't jump to that conclusion with any certainty. Someone that uses a racial term isn't necessarily a racist, right? Instead of marginalizing the experience of someone that knows the history of the word they address it, without that sort of hyperbole.
I get where you guys are coming from: Kotaku does in fact do the "controversial title, not really a big deal short story" thing pretty regularly, or have, at least. But, I think this one was more straight and evocative. "Racial Term in DS' Scribblenauts?" (The original title), puts the topic out there and questions the situation while delivering facts, in the hope that people will be informed.
Since last night, they've happened to update the title to "Racial Term in DS' Scribblenauts? Unintentional, Developer Explains". For whatever that's worth.
@Monodi
I'd heard of the term before, as well as my sisters, some of my friends, my parents, other members of my family, and some of their friends. That's alot of nobody. :)
So, I think that's what's important here, actually. While the internet-culture at large/ gamers at large are not aware of the term, gamers and the internet exist in a real world with people that are aware of the term, and would be off put, if offended, if that word were said/used casually. The result, the person saying that would be caught of guard, and of course, react confused and defensively. Nobody's a "bad' person here: There's just an ignorance (<-- not used negatively) that makes for a tough conversation or hurt feelings.
Armed with a knowledge about that term, one can, at the least, be prepared to have that conversation about the term, if its ever necessary.
That said, good article, and good on Kotaku for going above and beyond what many would consider a gaming blog should, and also for updating the article/title as more facts became apparent.
If you really want to know, the guy actually mispelled "samba" and got "sambo" as a suggested word!