Quantcast
Destructoid - Toneman's Community Blog




About Me
I used to have a big long description about myself here but that was years ago. probably before you were here. Just know this, I'm awesome and I love my Destructoid. I've been with her for since the beginning and I don't plan on leaving.

Also, www.bowtiecat.com.
Gamer Profile
3DS friend code:
Steam: gween_awien
Battle:
PSN: lol
Mii: 7651 0814 9752 5933
Gamertag: Bowtie Cat
Following (28)
Aaron Linde
ArrestedDeveloper
BluDesign
Bob Muir
charliesuh
Colette Bennett
Copyright 2008 Agent Chieftain
Cutie Honey
DestructoidFNF
DJMegaMatX
Dr. Boa
DtoidPortland
FAILCAST
Faith
Hamza CTZ Aziz
Jim Sterling
Jordan Devore
king3vbo
Koobert
LostCrichton
Nick Chester
Niero
shipero
Snaileb
Toneman
Topher Cantler
Wedge
Yashoki
The GH3 controller fails.
Toneman | 2:08 AM on 10.24.2007 27 comments


I'm just gonna throw this out there. The controller that comes with the Xbox 360 version of Guitar Hero 3 sucks. It doesn't suck as in, "The buttons aren't working!" it sucks as in, "Wow, this thing's a real step down in terms of design." It's horrible. Whoever decided to make the corners 90 degrees is an idiot. Everytime I play I feel like I'm cutting my wrists. This may not be a problem for some of you but when I play, my wrist sits on the edge of the guitar which, as I said, isn't rounded off at all. Fucking OUCH. I submit to you, my fellow Destructoid readers, this piece of advice. If you already have the controller that came with the 360 version of Guitar Hero 2 then there is no need to buy the bundle. It will work prefectly fine and save you some cash. With this cash you'll be able to purchase the Rock Band bundle, which actually comes with a good guitar. The best guitar infact. Not only is the Rock band guitar better than the GH3 one in every way, it actually looks damn cool. (See image above.)
Of course, I'm not going to sway all of you readers out there as some of you probably love the idea of changeable faceplates and detachable necks. Fine by me. They're good features willing of your praise, but if you want to save some valuable money that you'll need come the holidays then don't buy the Guitar Hero 3 bundle.



Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

0



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

26 comments | showing # 1 to 26
prev next

Knivy's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:30
Knivy
My GH2 guitar has a broken whammy =(, if it wasn't i wouldn't buy the bundle.
Toneman's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:35
Toneman
Broken whammy bars are the downfall of man.
SLiFE's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:35
SLiFE
I've said since Day One that I'll be playing GH3 on my Rock Band Strat.
But you wanna talk about taking a step backwards? The GH2 X-plorer was ASS. They nailed it perfectly the 1st time with the SG.
Toneman's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:38
Toneman
I agree completely, SLiFE.
SG>Xplorer>Les Paul
TwinkieFGR's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:47
TwinkieFGR
That's a very good point, never thought of that.
tsunamikitsune's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:55
tsunamikitsune
I just wish the Rock Band guitar was wireless. Hell, I wish all of the Rock Band equipment was wireless. My 360 is on top of my TV and it sucks enough just having my X-plorer plugged in, much less three other USB controllers.
vexed alex's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:57
vexed alex
I feel that your complaints are....lame? Like, do you lean on the guitar hardcore?
vexed alex's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 02:59
vexed alex
P.S.

I don't have an old 360 guitar and the Rock Band song list is lame in comparison with Guitar Hero. My choice still sticks with GH3.
Toneman's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 03:14
Toneman
Yeah, the wireless thing kinda sucks but I'm fine with wires. Like I said, my suggestion isn't for everyone.
stevephoenix's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 03:24
stevephoenix
i get what you mean in terms of the look and feel of it, but the 90 degree corner thing...it is based on a Gibson Les Paul...have you ever played one? that's exactly what they are like.
tsunamikitsune's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 03:27
tsunamikitsune
Meh, I guess I can deal with the wires. My friends and even my mom seem to be pretty into Rock Band, so they'll all be pitching in for it. I can pick up GH3 later.
BFeld13's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 05:51
BFeld13
I've actually heard that this is one of the best controllers yet. One of the guys on 1UP Yours said that HO/POs are much easier and that it was better than the Rock Band gutar.
Toneman's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 06:41
Toneman
I noticed that HOs and POs are easier but it's because of the game not the guitar. To quote the great Olmec, "The choice is yours and yours alone!" I'm just offering some money saving advice.
BS3 Owner's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 07:01
BS3 Owner
GH3 Guitar looks like a violin... Kinda?
Maurice Tan's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 07:05
Maurice Tan
Now that you mentioned it, those GH3 controller buttons do indeed look like they'd kill my fingers. Especially since I'm used to sliding the index finger from the green to the red :(

I don't see why anyone would want to play with the bottom bass buttons on the RB guitar tho. Why hold your hand down there when the top frets are easier to access for a videogame?
GuitarAtomik's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 07:07
GuitarAtomik
I still need it..

A] Because I don't have one for the 360 yet and..
B] I want a second guitar for Rock band later.

I admit, the face plate thing sounds cool to me as well since I work at a sign place that could print awesome stuff for it.
Savant's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 07:29
Savant
I have heard nothing but praise for the 360 Les Paul. I don't own a guitar for the 360 yet, so I'm picking up the bundle without question.
Phist's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 07:54
Phist
I had no problems with the new GH3 controller. I tried both the Rock Band and GH3 controllers. I really don't have a favorite right now, but a lot of people prefer the button layout on the Strat. A side-by-side comparison will definitely be the judge. I will end up getting both games anyway, but I'll probably end up getting the GH3 bundle because it's launching earlier (and I don't have GH2). I might end up getting a second controller for RB anyway. I wish you would give more specific reasons why the RB version is more superior.
VWGTI's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 08:03
VWGTI
The Rock Band guitar looks less like a toy, has buttons at the bottom of the neck to use for solos, and has a silent strum bar (no click = yes please). It'll definately be the superior of the two, but I'm sure the GH3 guitar works just fine.
galagabug 's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 08:14
galagabug
that rock band fender is soo much sexier.
Toneman's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 09:18
Toneman
Sound reasoning all around.
balth's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 09:54
balth
I want to have the Fender's children and make little stratocasters all around.
king3vbo's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 10:19
king3vbo
I like the Rock Band one personally
Bob Muir's Avatar - Comment posted on 10/24/2007 18:10
Bob Muir
Wow, the Les Paul is worse than the X-plorer? That's surprising. I'm wondering if, once it's out, the Stratocaster can be made to work with GH3. That'd be my optimum way.
funboy42's Avatar - Comment posted on 01/25/2008 20:41
funboy42
Here guys I took my guitar apart and this is what I found. Made a thread and stuck pictures of it at anandtech.
Enjoy.
PLEASE pass this onto all other sites you know!

http://forums.anandtech.com/messageview.aspx?catid=30&threadid=2146678&STARTPAGE=1
taumpytears's Avatar - Comment posted on 02/21/2008 20:46
taumpytears
[color=ffa8f5]**[/color]
[color=ffa8f5].[/color][color=fca5f4]-[/color][color=faa2f4]:[/color][color=f89ff3]*[/color][color=f69df3]'[/color][color=f49af2]*[/color][color=f297f2]:[/color][color=ef94f1]-[/color][color=ed92f1].[/color][color=eb8ff0].[/color][color=e98cf0]-[/color][color=e78aef]:[/color][color=e587ef]*[/color][color=e284ee]'[/color][color=e081ee]*[/color][color=de7fed]:[/color][color=dc7ced]-[/color][color=da79ec].[/color][color=d877ec].[/color][color=d574eb]-[/color][color=d371eb]:[/color][color=d16eea]*[/color][color=cf6cea]'[/color][color=cd69e9]*[/color][color=cb66e9]:[/color][color=c863e8]-[/color][color=c661e8].[/color][color=c45ee7].[/color][color=c25be7]-[/color][color=c059e6]:[/color][color=be56e6]*'*[/color][color=c059e6]:[/color][color=c25be7]-[/color][color=c45ee7].[/color][color=c661e8].[/color][color=c863e8]-[/color][color=cb66e9]:[/color][color=cd69e9]*[/color][color=cf6cea]'[/color][color=d16eea]*[/color][color=d371eb]:[/color][color=d574eb]-[/color][color=d877ec].[/color][color=da79ec].[/color][color=dc7ced]-[/color][color=de7fed]:[/color][color=e081ee]*[/color][color=e284ee]'[/color][color=e587ef]*[/color][color=e78aef]:[/color][color=e98cf0]-[/color][color=eb8ff0].[/color][color=ed92f1].[/color][color=ef94f1]-[/color][color=f297f2]:[/color][color=f49af2]*[/color][color=f69df3]'[/color][color=f89ff3]*[/color][color=faa2f4]:[/color][color=fca5f4]-[/color][color=ffa8f5].[/color]
*
* [color=ffa8f5]O[/color][color=fba3f4]h [/color][color=f59bf2]m[/color][color=f297f2]y [/color][color=eb8ff0]g[/color][color=e88bef]o[/color][color=e587ef]s[/color][color=e283ee]h[/color][color=de7fed], [/color][color=d877ec]t[/color][color=d573eb]h[/color][color=d16fea]a[/color][color=ce6bea]t [/color][color=c863e8]h[/color][color=c55fe7]a[/color][color=c15be7]s g[/color][color=be57e6]o[/color][color=c15be7]t [/color][color=c863e8]t[/color][color=cb67e9]o [/color][color=d16fea]b[/color][color=d573eb]e [/color][color=db7bec]t[/color][color=de7fed]h[/color][color=e283ee]e [/color][color=e88bef]f[/color][color=eb8ff0]u[/color][color=ee93f1]n[/color][color=f297f2]n[/color][color=f59bf2]i[/color][color=f89ff3]e[/color][color=fba3f4]s[/color][color=ffa8f5]t[/color]
* [color=ffa8f5]t[/color][color=fba3f4]h[/color][color=f89ff3]i[/color][color=f59bf2]n[/color][color=f297f2]g [/color][color=eb8ff0]I [/color][color=e587ef]r[/color][color=e283ee]e[/color][color=de7fed]a[/color][color=db7bec]d [/color][color=d573eb]a[/color][color=d16fea]l[/color][color=ce6bea]l [/color][color=c863e8]d[/color][color=c55fe7]a[/color][color=c15be7]y[/color][color=be57e6]. T[/color][color=c15be7]h[/color][color=c55fe7]a[/color][color=c863e8]n[/color][color=cb67e9]k [/color][color=d16fea]y[/color][color=d573eb]o[/color][color=d877ec]u [/color][color=de7fed]f[/color][color=e283ee]o[/color][color=e587ef]r [/color][color=eb8ff0]s[/color][color=ee93f1]h[/color][color=f297f2]a[/color][color=f59bf2]r[/color][color=f89ff3]i[/color][color=fba3f4]n[/color][color=ffa8f5]g[/color]
*
[color=ffa8f5].[/color][color=fca5f4]-[/color][color=faa2f4]:[/color][color=f89ff3]*[/color][color=f69df3]'[/color][color=f49af2]*[/color][color=f297f2]:[/color][color=ef94f1]-[/color][color=ed92f1].[/color][color=eb8ff0].[/color][color=e98cf0]-[/color][color=e78aef]:[/color][color=e587ef]*[/color][color=e284ee]'[/color][color=e081ee]*[/color][color=de7fed]:[/color][color=dc7ced]-[/color][color=da79ec].[/color][color=d877ec].[/color][color=d574eb]-[/color][color=d371eb]:[/color][color=d16eea]*[/color][color=cf6cea]'[/color][color=cd69e9]*[/color][color=cb66e9]:[/color][color=c863e8]-[/color][color=c661e8].[/color][color=c45ee7].[/color][color=c25be7]-[/color][color=c059e6]:[/color][color=be56e6]*'*[/color][color=c059e6]:[/color][color=c25be7]-[/color][color=c45ee7].[/color][color=c661e8].[/color][color=c863e8]-[/color][color=cb66e9]:[/color][color=cd69e9]*[/color][color=cf6cea]'[/color][color=d16eea]*[/color][color=d371eb]:[/color][color=d574eb]-[/color][color=d877ec].[/color][color=da79ec].[/color][color=dc7ced]-[/color][color=de7fed]:[/color][color=e081ee]*[/color][color=e284ee]'[/color][color=e587ef]*[/color][color=e78aef]:[/color][color=e98cf0]-[/color][color=eb8ff0].[/color][color=ed92f1].[/color][color=ef94f1]-[/color][color=f297f2]:[/color][color=f49af2]*[/color][color=f69df3]'[/color][color=f89ff3]*[/color][color=faa2f4]:[/color][color=fca5f4]-[/color][color=ffa8f5].[/color]
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!