Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by TheManchild | Jim Sterling Is The Antichrist...apparently.Destructoid
LIGHTS:  ON | OFF
surf dtoid with arrow keys

HOT GAMES
REVIEWS VIDEOS COMMUNITY FORUM SHOP

pc PS4 PS3 NEXT XBOX XBOX 360 WII U 3DS PS vita ANDROID APPLE

REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll

click to hide banner header
About
I'm TheManchild, though I go by many names. Two, actually. Although it's only really one, because TheManchild is not a real name. So um, well, sorry for wasting your time.

I guess I kind of like video games. It's the only thing I'm really interested in apart from occasionally farting. I believe that might is right, that survival of the fittest is our only calling. I guess that makes me something of a paradox since I'm located somewhere between pond scum and bong water in the proverbial food chain.

My favorite games are the ones that make me feel superior to you for having played them. Games like Larry's Quantum Physics Adventure, which I just made up now. But if you question me on the subject matter and probe my understanding of it, I won't respond. I'm just kind of a dick that way.

Here is a non-exhaustive list of some of my favorite things to waste time on.

You know, in between farts.

Ecco the Dolphin
Dem Sega Mickey Mouse Games
Tetris
Civilization
Sonic the Hedgehog
Super Meat Boy
Minecraft
Dwarf Fortress
DOOM
Star Control 2
Galactic Civilizations 2
Alpha Centauri
Dark Souls
Dragon Quest
Earthbound
Professor Layton
Mario
Alien Motherfucking Soldier
Farts
Player Profile
Follow me:
TheManchild's sites
Badges
Following (17)  


Jim Sterling embodies everything that is evil about the industry of video game journalism. He is the antithesis to video game journalists.

Honestly, how dare he actually be objective in his reviews, even if it means recognizing the positive qualities of one of the most mainstream (and therefore, obviously totally awful) franchises in video game history? If a game wasn't developed by a basement dwelling man with lip piercings who wears wool scarves in the summer time, it clearly can't be anything more than a useless piece of played out fast-food Hollywood Michael Bay garbage. If everyone likes something, it is clearly flawed.

But seriously, the controversy surrounding Jim giving MW3 a positive review is astoundingly boring. Everyone is great at criticizing critics, but almost none of these social lepers have the talent or the ingenuity to themselves become better reviewers; and especially not enough to become a reviewer with the popularity or in this case, infamy of Jim Sterling.

I once thought I wanted to be a video game critic, or a journalist, or something. But if gaming all my life has taught me one thing, it is this:

Although there are some very cool gamers out there who have insightful and interesting stories and opinions relating to their hobby, the majority of them are a bunch of ignorant, over-opinionated windbags with no tact or social skills to speak of who spend their days whining about worthless junk - instead of actual spending their time playing games.

The response to Jim's review proves this in spades. Everyone wanted a shitstorm; they wanted him to rip apart the juggernaut of the industry, not because it is a particularly poorly made game, but because they hate its popularity. I'll admit to having no interest in any new CoD game, but the fact is, I'd rather play Call of Duty than Wii Music, Onechanbara, or one of the many millions of shovelware bullshit titles that get pumped out into a saturated market on a regular basis. What people are willing to call "a bad game" has become absolutely obscene, and even though I don't really like the Modern Warfare games, I can be at least objective enough to recognize that if anything, they are well produced.

Jim recognizes that too apparently, and despite his reputation as being edgy, and kicking the pegs from beneath poorly made games that are raved about for other reasons, he is not actually required to hate a game JUST because all known knowledge about Jim would dictate that he MUST.

The people getting angry about a review are people I hope never, ever, ever, ever get legitimate jobs as journalists themselves. Because it is exactly that kind of asshole who WOULD crush the life out of a decent game just to build up his own Jim Sterling-like reputation, whether it was warranted or not.

Everytime I hear someone argue about how Xbox is so much better than this, how X game is so much better than that "awful Call of Duty", I can only come to one reasonable conclusion; that person is an asshole with way too much time on their hands. For the few hours I get in a week to play video games, I get very little other time outside of that to drone endlessly about my favorite games, and why they are so much better than yours. And what do you know, I even write reviews myself for a game website.

But that's just my point; I'm busy with those things. I play games and am expected to review them in a reasonable time frame. In between that, I basically play my DS on the toilet. The rest of the time, I have other things occupying my life, like a family, responsibilities.

You know what? I know what the problem is; I am jealous of you bastards. I am writing this while my daughter is asleep, and right before I have to do laundry, dishes, and put the finishing touches on an article. I would love to be able to sit here all day and be able to have enough free time that I could actually burn it away by bitching about Jim's review. I could argue with other people about how their perspective is wrong. I could spend all day in a forum or chat backing up my opinion.

Yeah, that's why I'm venting right now. That kind of life sounds like an absolute dream, being able to sit there and judge other folks all day long rather than trying to actually accomplish anything myself. You people are such lucky jerks, I hope you are enjoying it.

I only got to do it for about five minutes today, and that was just long enough to write this blog.



Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!




Those who have come:



Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


Everyone wanted a shitstorm; they wanted him to rip apart the juggernaut of the industry, not because it is a particularly poorly made game, but because they hate its popularity

YES.

I don't really like the Modern Warfare games, I can be at least objective enough to recognize that if anything, they are well produced.

YES. YES. YES

The people getting angry about a review are people I hope never, ever, ever, ever get legitimate jobs as journalists themselves. Because it is exactly that kind of asshole who WOULD crush the life out of a decent game just to build up his own Jim Sterling-like reputation, whether it was warranted or not.

OH GOD YES.

Everytime I hear someone argue about how Xbox is so much better than this, how X game is so much better than that "awful Call of Duty", I can only come to one reasonable conclusion; that person is an asshole with way too much time on their hands.

IVE READ ENOUGH! WELCOME TO FUCKING DESTRUCTOID. TOPSAUUUUSSSSEEE!!!!!!!
"I only got to do it for about five minutes today, and that was just long enough to write this blog."
And I am jealous of you because you can write this fast.

Also, I want to hug you.

@Epic-Kx
Welcome to Dtoid? No, he's been here for quite a while.
@Nic128
I f i haven't seen him, he's new to me!

<3
I haven't read the comments on the review because I value my time, but really? People are upset that he didn't totally hate a game?

Maybe it's because I'm not 12, but I never understood why people got so upset about a number at the end of some text. It's like these people are legitimately baffled that someone's opinion could be different from their own.
Bravo, my man.
Yeah I agree. I think this community has gotten quite toxic. Between the regular trolls like JimmyX derailing threads on the front page, Savino constantly trolling the c-blogs and the contingency of outraged lurkers and mainstreamers who make a "I hate Jim and his review" account for nothing else but wasting account space, this place has been quite sad.

Still, I stay because I love this place. Hopefully it will get better soon. Either that or I'll retreat to the forums.
Well said good Sir. Very well said.
Here Here!!
At the end of the day you'll still dislike the Modern Warfare series, but your daughter will be comfortably sleeping in her bed, your article will be finished, and hopefully, you'll have enjoyed some downtime with a game you do like.

At the end of the day my daughter and I will have housework done, dishes washed, bills paid, and will be sitting down to enjoy some MW3 multiplayer.

Jim Sterling will still have his job, and hopefully be getting the Skyrim review up soon. He'll lose no sleep tonight - unless of his own free will.

The people who bitch and complain, trying to make their point and sway the rest to their views? They'll sit back and wonder where the day went, why they can't be successful in life, and then bitch and moan because there are too many new releases that they don't have the time to play.



Good to see you back here, and proving that 5 minutes can be quality time. :)
excellent blog! I think that most of the uproar came from people that don't like or even play FPS games and are of the usual "they're ruining gaming" mindset - basically what Epic-Kx so nicely said.

I don't really get all the hate. A new Mario game of some sort seems to come out most every year and generally sells well and gets positive reviews... but nobody screams about this. There are tons of other types of games available on the market... so nobody is forced to play COD. Other games like Uncharted 3, Skyrim and the Assassin's Creed series seem to get pretty decent hype, sales and review scores... yet few seem to jump on the hate wagon.

Still... it inspired you to write this blog... so all that hate can't be a totally bad thing! :)
Thanks for your opinions, guys.

@Jaded - It's been awhile! Been really busy with other projects, blogs, websites - all of that nonsense that keeps me from playing video games. ;) But I felt a bit heated this morning at all of this negative backlash, and figured it had been awhile since I posted here.

@Elsa - Again, people are so worried about objectivity, but that's the irony; the games the general public chooses to praise and the ones they choose to punish is extremely subjective. I see no reason to hold a game like Mario over something like Call of Duty; both are considered doing the best at what they do, so what is the problem exactly? Another user essentially labeled CoD as pre-packaged DLC, and I find that mentality to be extremely cynical. These games are still HUGE projects requiring thousands of man hours, time, effort, and care. Nobody realizes that the individuals programming and doing art and sound design for games like CoD are NO DIFFERENT than any other developer out there, of ANY game. It is their trade, their bread and butter. So for some asshole to just dismiss a huge undertaking as "Meh, it's just a minor upgrade...game sucks." Is extremely cynical and unfair.

I would love to see a construction worker, or an accountant, or whoever else is behind these opinions get flocked online by a thousand critical game developers bashing their work. "Oh, his house is a piece of shit. They painted it red, LOL, no different than any other house, just repackaged!" It's only with artistic endeavors that people feel the right to be insanely critical and hurtful. If any of those twerps were to go down to a construction site and start running their mouth about what a crappy job they were doing, there would be a fist in someones mouth.

And not in the good way, either.
If I could fap more...I would.
people needs to shut the fuck up about someone doesn't like the game and do something for a living, or at least play the game. Also nice rant bro.
Jim Sterling has sold out now like most game journalists. He was always one to be swayed by free stuff but he's definitely gone into full on payed for 'journalism'.
Either that or he's gone into full-on 'I don't care any more' Troll Mode. If you should state that outright if he has. Definately something up with 'im.
By and large I agree with your point, but I disagree heartily with this particular piece: What people are willing to call "a bad game" has become absolutely obscene, and even though I don't really like the Modern Warfare games, I can be at least objective enough to recognize that if anything, they are well produced.

I can understand people actually enjoying MW, even though I don't. And I'm totally behind Jim going the distance to give it a fair review, its bloated scores from less reputable sites be damned, because giving it an artificially low score to bolster your popularity is almost as bad as giving it an artificially high one because you're in the dev's pocket. But I won't abide for people not calling it a "bad game" because it is "well produced". I will not lower my standards and say 'well at least it's not shovelware'. Competently produced is not enough. A game needs to break new ground - to do something memorable - to capture my heart and mind - to show me what I thought I knew the way I didn't - before I will call it 'good'. And it needs to do all that and more before I'll call it great.

The word 'mediocre' ethymologically means 'average' and to me they remain synonyms.

Disclaimer: I don't actually think that about the MW games, since I haven't played any since the first MW, so I'm not defending or attacking them; merely your approach.
Ah, yes. Jim has "sold out" because he gave a very highly hyped game and franchise a good review.

Where the hell does this impression come from of Jim's reviews being swayed by money and/or free stuff? Wild conjecture and conspiracy, or actual witnessed events where an instance of bribery led to him giving a good review?

Honestly, I think some people here might be delusional. Activision doesn't need to pay a fucking dime to any reviewer in order to pick up more sales. They could have sneezed this game out without a single advert, and it still would have collected like no other game ever could.
If only the same amount of concern were to be given to games like Shadows of the damned
and Child of Eden or indie games at least. All this enthusiasm wasted on dumb FPS games.
Around here there is plenty of enthusiasm about "indie games". The mindset that "ALL FPS games are crap!" and in your case in particular, that a game being "Japanese" instantly qualifies it above other games is the exact some kind of simple minded mentality I was commenting upon.

Considering the last ten or so of your contributions on this website had the words "FPS games suck" in there somewhere, it's pretty clear where you stand on the matter.
And i'm glad there's a few other community members and people like Jonathan Holmes
that share how i feel about FPS games.
Also calling "anybody who likes shooters" a "frat boy moron" instantly classes you in that brand of arrogant, self-righteous assholes. The logic you present implies that, out of the millions who will purchase CoD, 100 percent of them are less intelligent and sophisticated then you are.

I have called people dumb before...in fact, I am basically doing that right now. But to call millions of people "bros" because they like a shooting game, and to say that they are all a bunch of idiots is something really special indeed.

I have personally never watched a game of football, I don't drink beer, I watch UFC, and I don't have a bunch of lamewad "buddies." But I do happen to like the odd first person shooter. Hm.

Something is missing here, I think...
Er...DON'T watch UFC.

Your daily tirade about FPS's and your unrequited romantic inclinations towards Jonathan Holmes are quite apparent simply by clicking on your profile. Considering how many times you share your feelings per second on this website, you might want to consider blogging about your deep sensual love for other FPS bashers in your own personal blog, rather than flooding any blog that has the letters "f" "p" or "s" with your rambling, biased nonsense.
Considering the people who play Military shooters tend to be bigoted, homophobic jerkwards.
Hell even the people who buys COD or BF games tend to be Steve Mcdouchebro
who think making sexist jokes and gay slurs are highbrow comedy.
I've seen these people personally so I know i'm better than them.
No, you're not.

You're an even worse type of bigoted jerkwad. Because like those other "bigoted jerkwads", you have decided to judge a very large group of people as being below you based simply on a genre of video game that they enjoy.

I deduce that you are no different or any more unique than the others like you. You are somebody who is bored enough to take the time focusing your negative energy on a group of people who alienated and ostracized you while growing up, and based on your assertion of them, you stay on the constant offensive by attacking anybody who shares even the slightest qualities with them.

You are not in a position to be judging anybody. Your blanket statements and completely unfair assertions of a broad range of people make you, in my opinion, more irritating, abrasive, and intrusive than any sports loving "douchebro" could ever be...and for the record, I was in a constant state of ridicule from these people growing up as well.

Maybe when you "grow up", you'll realize not only how unfair it is to make the statements you have been making, but how much of a waste of time and energy it is as well.
Hey buddy why do you think I was just talking about MW3. I've been on Destructoid for a couple years and I'm guessing you're fairly new right? You need to go years back and study the enigma that is Jimbo closely to get inside that nutters head.
That's why I phrased it as a question, because I don't actually know.
Ah yes, using "The Jim Sterling Effect" I see!
Glad to see you writing again :]
I can imagine steam coming out of this thing! Well said!
I'm beginning to think that Coincidental Irony really is just a troll or has honestly never even tried an online game. His perception of who plays these games is totally twisted and seems more like a joke.

I'm a 49 year old woman... I play online FPS games with my 54 year old husband, with a person who has his master's degree in philosophy (or doctorate? I can't remember)... with a man who stays at home and raises his two kids while his wife works, with a younger kid in a small town where he can talk about the Japanese games he adores with other gamers while we play a shooter game, with someone starting a career in the military.... I've met "grandmakilledu" - a lady older than myself who has grandchildren and is retired so she plays shooter games... then there's that guy on home dialysis waiting on his kidney transplant who plays shooter games so he can talk to people and while away the hours while exercising his brain...

This is just a minute handful of the people who play shooter games that I've met - and none are homophobic bigoted jerkwads, nor are they frat boy morons. In fact that reputation for FPS gamers likely comes from that small percentage of dickheads like yourself that troll the games looking for attention, though in your case you seem to be trolling the internet.

Coincidental, If you truly don't like FPS games then write a blog. Give us an argument containing FACTS (rather than ramblings from your imagination).
ELSA'S 49?!
@Coincidental Irony

"Considering the people who play Military shooters tend to be bigoted, homophobic jerkwards. Hell even the people who buys COD or BF games tend to be Steve Mcdouchebro who think making sexist jokes and gay slurs are highbrow comedy. I've seen these people personally so I know i'm better than them."

There is so much wrong with everything you say -- both here and in your other posts -- that you're not even worth arguing with.
@Elsa and mrandydixon
Are you a gay male gamer who has lived his life going through
prejudice and name calling? Do you think i've never played online shooters
only to be verbally assaulted by mindless homophobic rants? By gamers no less.
Ridiculed for not standing within the norm and proudly living outside of it?
If you aren't, take your accusing finger away from my face.
Just because you are established users here does not mean you have the right
to pour scorn on people who thinks differently than yourselves.
Especially you Elsa. Being a mature aged woman, you should know better.
But I will take the brunt of your insults. As i have done so all my life.
Save your "woe is me" self-victimization for another thread where you haven't already pointed your own accusatory finger at an entire demographic.

Nobody here was trying to insult you, and any of the comments pointed at you were because of your own ignorant, idiotic statements. Sorry to disappoint you, but nobody here was assaulting you based on the irrelevant fact that you are a "gay male gamer".

"Gay male gamer", "straight male gamer", I think we were looking past those inconsequential qualities to see the troll behind the label.

It's infuriating to me that you are now singling out Elsa, one of the nicest most well-read members of the community, simply because you backed yourself into a corner and are trying to deflect. You should be ashamed of yourself, but as a whiny teenager, nobody expects YOU to know better.

Elsa of all people doesn't need a lesson from a smarmy little jerk like you.
@coincidental irony... actually I have a rather deep voice, but apparently a "feminine" turn of phrase and I am mistaken for a gay male gamer all the time in online gaming... yes, there are some aholes who will be abusive - and then there are the other people in your squad who stand up for you and vote to kick the homophobe out of the game.

I actually did a blog about it! I think that the most important lesson I've learned from online gaming is that there will always be that one dickhead. He or she is that person that will single you out because you are gay, because you're female... or because you're a kid, or have a funny user name... or some other invented reason for them to pick on someone and behave like a bully. This is a SMALL percentage of the wonderful people you will meet in online play and you just have to learn to not take anything personally. It's not because you are gay... it's simply because you have become their target de jour. Most of the people who play online aren't like that... though that small percentage does try their damnedest to ruin it for everyone else.

Frankly if you want to play online, join in on Dtoid's Friday Night Fights... it's a casual fun way to play online and there are females, homosexuals... and well... just plain odd balls that play - so nobody picks on anybody and everyone just tries to have a lot of fun.

You can say "especially me"... but I am WELL aware of online prejudice both from the times I am mistaken for a gay male, and for the times I am recognized as a female... and for those "granny" moments when they learn how old I am.

... I just grew a sense of humour and don't tend to take it personally any more.

(oh and for the record, I was also in a Warhawk tourney as a clan leader and one of the other clan leaders was a very proud gay male who's PSN nick was "gay parade" ... not once did anyone make any homophobic comments towards him... he was a respected clan leader, a respected forum member... and a damn good player!... so not all gay males are ridiculed... some become respected leaders in that game).
Oh... and for the record, here's a link to that post from a few years ago:
http://www.destructoid.com/blogs/Elsa/shut-up-you-faggy-homo-guy--163485.phtml
(just as proof that it actually did happen... and still occasionally does!)

... and sorry for hijacking your blog Manchild!
Not at all. I should have probably ignored this fella but it was really, really hard to. His arrogance shines through in his victimization, in the fact that he seems to feel he is the only person on earth who has ever been ridiculed for being different, and that anybody who is not a homosexual male (and him, specifically) would be unable to relate to this.

I have a hard time tolerating that kind of egotistical self importance, and to see him slag you off for it? A crime, I tells ya.

Back to Top
DLC   |   BEST Games of 2012   |   Best PC Games   |   Best PS3 Games   |   Best Xbox 360 Games   |   Best Wii U Games   |   Best 3DS Games




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more