Returning Dtoiders: Login now      New to Dtoid?   Create a username and join our massive gaming community -- you might even win stuff. Its all free and only takes like 2.49 seconds. No, seriously!
     The Wrath's Blog
GTA IV Reviewed: PS3 - 10 min mandatory install, 360 - No split screen, pop-in, framerate and tearing issues
 by The Wrath on 04.06.2008      58 comments




The web. My...final...frontier. While perusing my regular web surfing search of porn sites and gaming sites looking for a porn gaming site, I stumbled across an interesting read regarding a review of GTA IV. Apparently CGreview.com was able to get PT with both the 360 and PS3 versions of the family friendly hit, Grand Theft Auto Quatro! With a release date of 4/29 and not a single review available, I'm sure Rockstar and Take Two (along with their lawyers) set out to make CGreview as happy as Hitler during Hanukkah. No sooner than it was posted, it was taken down. All hope is not lost, as GameRevolver.com has posted "clips of the highlights". For your viewing pleasure I have copy pasta'd clips of the clips of highlights.

Xbox360 version

"On the 360, this installation is optional if you have a hard drive. I advise to proceed with installation—it reduces the already minimal frame rate issues on the 360." Sucks to be an Arcade owner. Not because of this, it just sucks to be one. That is all.

"The 360 is bright. Boy is it bright. Based on discussion history, this one will be claimed to look better, but it’ll really be preference. The texture quality is the same on both systems, but the 360 has a more cartoon-like look. This isn’t a bad thing. It just depends on preference. I’d compare the difference to that of Oblivion on each system. The 360 also suffers from some frame rate drops that are almost non-existent on the PS3. Installing the 360 version on your system’s hard drive, however, will bring performance almost up to par with the PS3." Damn you Gametrailers.com and your comparison vids!! Just a warm up folks, just a warm up.

"I can’t conclude one way or the other why the split-screen mode was not available on 360, but I assume by the drop in on-screen objects on the PS3 that the 360 just couldn’t handle it. If you own a 360, don’t worry. You have Xbox Live…so you’re set." Yes, but will XBL be working? ZIIIING!!

PS3 version

"When popping the disc into the PS3 for the first time, you’ll have a brief installation. Don’t worry, it only takes ten minutes or so, and there’s a pleasant bit of GTA history trivia to keep you occupied. So, unlike with Devil May Cry, you’ll be able to eat your sandwich prior to playing the game." Give me a fucking mini game instead of a history lesson. Or trivia. Let alone history trivia. Christ.

"The PS3 has a more relaxed color pallet, but this gives everything a more realistic look. If you don’t like the realistic look, and you have a HDMI connection, you can fiddle with your PS3 display settings and get it looking much more saturated. The textures are just as sharp as the 360 version, and there’s little to no pop-in or screen tearing. The PS3 takes longer to load than the 360, but I took several different head counts in game at different locations, and I always found the PS3 to be more populated than the 360. This could be attributed to the dynamic nature of the world, but it’s hard to tell. Either way, the difference was never more than five to seven pedestrians or three to four cars—it’s not really much of an advantage." I'm not sure I even care about this one. I get it, they look the same.

"I know, you want details, but all I can confirm is split-screen on PS3 only. I was alone, so I didn’t actually get to have any matches, but I could tell that the split-screen worked really well. There was a significant decrease in the amount of traffic and pedestrians, but it didn’t ruin anything. This is understandable. Rendering two instances of Liberty City is a chore for any machine." I've always, always, always hated split screen. Too much screen real estate lost. Oh well, I guess having an option I'll never use is nice. Kinda like XNA.

And there you have it. Fact or Fiction? Life or Death? Cocoa Krispies or Cocoa Pebbles? It's your call.

There are 58 comments about this post:
MrSadistic's Destructoid Blog
Wow. I always thought the 360 would be the leading system for this game.
GrayFox's Destructoid Blog
You forgot to mention that once you do the hard drive install on the 360 the two versions are said to be nearly identical...

And I am a big proponent for optional hard drive installs. I will always opt for them because I have lots of unused HD space, but it's always great to have the option.
MrSadistic's Destructoid Blog
Um, he did mention it.
Y0j1mb0's Destructoid Blog
I imagine if this is true there are going to be some butt hurt people going off soon.
GrayFox's Destructoid Blog
Yeah... but in the title it seems to insinuate that the 360 version is inferior. Which it apparently isn't.

Just pointing that out.
Alex Maw's Destructoid Blog
The answer is Coco Pops.

I am deliberating if I am going to go for a 360 or a PS3 in the near future. If GTA looks a little better on PS3 but has DLC on the 360, I think that's to the 360's advantage for the time being.
TrailerParkJesus's Destructoid Blog
Cocoa pebbles plz
Simmons 2pt0's Destructoid Blog
Installations on consoles ftl.
the GAMEGOBLIN's Destructoid Blog
What a fucking joke. How can you even compare the two? What a fucking fanboy we got here. Cocoa Pebbles are CLEARLY better than Krispies.
the GAMEGOBLIN's Destructoid Blog
Jeez.
liam2015's Destructoid Blog
Ouch. Thank god I'm getting this for the PS3. And I don't mind not having split-screen, but it's good to know we have it.
Y0j1mb0's Destructoid Blog
I didn't think this would happen but I have to agree with Gamegoblin.. Cocoa Pebbles are fucking better than Krispies. I've just exposed myself for the fanboy I really am.

*scuttles off in shame*
MrSadistic's Destructoid Blog
Fuck you all.

Cap'n Crunch bitches.
DrNutt's Destructoid Blog
I'll be getting this for the 360, but only because it's what I already own. I'll be really happy when this console generation is over because the wankery is becoming unbearable.

Also, lol at Yojimbo trying to sound like he's above fanboy bullshit.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
Sorry just got back from buying a chore boy. Not for cleaning anything, but the crack rock just doesn't sit in the pipe right with out a chore boy!

On topic: GrayFox, what if you don't have a HDD for your 360? Wouldn't you be playing an inferior version? Just a thought.
Gamegoblin: Pebbles don't snap, krackle, nor pop. Nuff said.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
And nothing bloodies a mouth better than Cap N Crunch. That shit is like eating a bowl of razors.
Clockwork's Destructoid Blog
No offense, but it looks like this was taken off of PS3fanboy or some shit.
liam2015's Destructoid Blog
@the wrath
I agree, cap'n crunch hurts my mouth

Also, fucking cocoa pebbles. Hell yeah.
GrayFox's Destructoid Blog
Yeah, you're right, but you're talking about maybe 5% the people who own xbox's. The title is just a little bit misleading is all, not a big deal.
GrayFox's Destructoid Blog
As an aside, I wish Microsoft would have optional HD installs for every game possible. I've used like only 20% of my hard drive, and most of that is videos and demos. I would go for it every time. I personally never got the big deal about HD installs on the PStriplez, I thought it was a great idea.
Takeshi's Destructoid Blog
Guess what? I'm not going to buy this game at all. If I would, I'd go for the PS3. I like the soft smooth looks.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
I agree GrayFox, but 5% of 17 million people is substantial.
Revolt in Colour's Destructoid Blog
Gamerevolver.com.... isn't that a Playstation fan site?

I will wait for a more objective review, thank you very much.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
And I enjoy istalls on my PS3. The waiting, not so much.
NotAZombie's Destructoid Blog
Lucky Charms mother fuckers.
RAB's Destructoid Blog
I hope that "no split-screen for 360" is bullshit. i was pretty stoked have that option for when my brudda comes over

also, bowl of razorblades ftw
bmdubya's Destructoid Blog
Cocoa Pebbles....oh yeah GTA IV. I think it all comes down to which console you own. And if you own both, it sounds like the PS3 might be the one to go for if you are going for performance, but come on, its not like the Xbox 360 is going to be a unplayable. I think with this game it is all about which console you prefer.
RAB's Destructoid Blog
but oversides images ftl...
Heretic's Destructoid Blog
@Revolt

Kotaku is that way ->
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
The info came from CGreview Revolt. It was taken down and reposted by GameRevolver, then I posted here. You're welcome very much.
BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
Boo Berries, Count Chocula, & Franken Mellows.

FTW!
RAB's Destructoid Blog
oversized?
BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
The Wii Version will RAWK!
Genfuyung's Destructoid Blog
http://www.video-poke.com/videos/Cartoons/_Family_Guy/Captain_Crunch_on_Family_Guy

That video ends the captain crunch debate.
TrailerParkJesus's Destructoid Blog
Is this the first time an optional install is implemented on the 360? I think this might be the first I've heard of anything like this.

And the only thing I hate about cocoa pebbles is when you accidentally inhale one because those things are tiny.
weedgan's Destructoid Blog
NO NO NO,

first off this whole fuckin thing was confirmed to be FAKE by rockstar a couple of days ago. ANd it is fake, anybody that has a copy of the game by now i guarnateeis underoath by form of an NDA.



And also, fuck cereal.

Captn crunch

maltomeal.
MrSadistic's Destructoid Blog
HONEY GRAHAMS
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
I can't find the Rockstar confirmation weedgan, link?
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
Anyone remember Mr. T cereal? And the Saturday morning cartoon? I looked for years trying to find a bulldog with a mohawk. Settled for a goldfish that was dead. Less care, ya know?
Clockwork's Destructoid Blog
Apple Jacks ftw. I honestly think there's heroin in it.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
A is for Apple, J is for Jonesin for heroin
Pedro Blandino's Destructoid Blog
whats your source that your quoting from. I don't believe that you have to install the game on xbox 360.
Samit Sarkar's Destructoid Blog
@Pedro: He said that you’re given the option to install it on 360, but there’s a mandatory 10-minute installation on PS3.
DarkTravesty's Destructoid Blog
to answer : faction! death and Cocoa Pebbles lulz
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
@ Pedro

Here: Source
Samit Sarkar's Destructoid Blog
Also, FRUITY PEBBLES MOTHERFUCKERS
Sarin's Destructoid Blog
Phew. I was getting worried that the ps3 version would be worse.

Also Cocoa Pops
Corak's Destructoid Blog
"Also, FRUITY PEBBLES MOTHERFUCKERS"

Agrees with Sammit, fruity pebbles RULES THEM ALL.

I'll wait for a real honest to god review, this just reeks of being fake.
007's Destructoid Blog
You guys are idiots if you think this is legit. I'm pretty sure that R* had worked hard to make the game look, feel, and play the same on both systems. The "reviewer" is just some PS3 fanboy.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
All this talk about it being fake, but no one has posted anything offical stating it's fake. Hmmmm. You'd think there would be some sort of officla statement made by someone.
The Wrath's Destructoid Blog
And by "officla", I meant "Tuesday".
Kent's Destructoid Blog
Damn Wrath I thought i was gonna be clever and post a pic of Mr. T's cereal. then I read a little further down. :(



pic anyways since I was in the neighborhood:
Crunshii's Destructoid Blog
"So your getting it for the PS3 or 360?"
"I... I don't know... I don't play video games"

"Fanboy... ill kill you now if you don't eat that bowl of razors!"
Steel Squirrel's Destructoid Blog
Yeah the new Red Faction is going to rock on both consoles, I agree.
brainderailment's Destructoid Blog
Looks slanted, but we'll know for sure when the games drop, then everyone can get at eachother's throats about which version is better while I will actually be playing it.
brainderailment's Destructoid Blog
FRUITY MOTHER-RAPING PEBBLES!
Snaileb 's Destructoid Blog
I was quite content enjoying my 360 till people felt they needed to tell me otherwise.
Elandarex's Destructoid Blog
When you say that R* worked "hard" to get it to play the same on both systems that doesn't necessarily mean they succeeded. Hardware limitations can simply be insurmountable given the time available most of the time and usually wishing and working really hard just can't make up the difference.

Still, I hope the 360's issues (mainly the split-screen or lack thereof) aren't true because I had been intending to pick up that version. It would also be nice to have some in-game video options for tweaking things like the saturation as well; it would simply make my life easier.

- P O S T    A    C O M M E N T -

Hey newb, want to join in this conversation?
Create a Destructoid account and discuss games with us. It takes 5 seconds! Do it! PEER PRESSURE!!!

Already jacked into Dtoid?
Login now, honorable robot

Be Famous! Sort of. Submit a news tip to Dtoid  |  Advertising  |  Privacy Policy  |  Powered by Elephant


dt1.destructoid.com