Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by Stephanie K | Big Bang BustDestructoid
LIGHTS:  ON | OFF
surf dtoid with arrow keys

HOT GAMES
REVIEWS VIDEOS COMMUNITY FORUM SHOP

pc PS4 PS3 NEXT XBOX XBOX 360 WII U 3DS PS vita ANDROID APPLE

REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll

click to hide banner header
About

Twitter
Boondoggle - Personal Blog

Sites I Contribute To:
Project GForum
Royal Flush Magazine

C-Blog Interview

Promoted Articles

Aaamaazzing: It Hurts
E for Effort: Resident Evil 4
Have a Nice Day
My Expertise - Resident Evil


Name: Stephanie (Steph)
Birthday: Oct. 16, 1989

Retail assistant manager by day.
Internet-suave superhero by night.
Player Profile
Xbox LIVE:Trapped Artist
PSN ID:Trapped_Artist
Steam ID:Kumko122
BattleNET:Trilby_
Follow me:
Stephanie K's sites
Badges
Following (11)  

Stephanie K
12:50 AM on 03.16.2012

The Big Bang Theory has been a tolerate/hate relationship with me. Like eating Taco Bell at two in the morning, it is something that is best avoided but for one reason or another I give into its delicious, crusty siren calls. I originally started watching it sometime after season two started after being told to give it a try. I am one of those people that I do not feel like I can build a proper opinion regarding something unless I've experienced it. So I gave it a shot. The first two seasons were nauseating to sit through. Overwhelming stereotypes were forced down viewers' throats tainting any possibility of it being enjoyable. However, going into season three the characters started to develop slightly better personalities; acting more like actual people with conflicting complexities instead of just being the "awkward, nerdy" guy or the "super smart but stupid" guy. Even though the geeky jokes are very forced and mainstreamed, the science humor added a slight bit of charm that started to appear which led me to watch through it the fourth season until it went downhill again. Nonetheless, I had invested enough time into it to keep going. It soon became the thing I watched when bored and sleep deprived.

Normally it takes quite a bit to offend me, but the latest episode of Big Bang Theory rubbed me the wrong way. In "The Weekend Vortex", Raj suggests that the men partake in an forty-eight hour gaming marathon playing The Old Republic. The idea of an 'all guys' weekend mixed with Star Wars instantly catches everyone's attention but drama develops when everyone's relationships begin to clash with their plans. The weekend is turned into a girls vs guy battle after Sheldon bails on his commitment to Amy to accompany her to her aunt's birthday party. She spreads her hurt feelings to Penny who helps her crash the guys' weekend as revenge and to set Sheldon straight.



On top of that, Bernadette invades the guys game by tagging along with Howard. She comes over with him with a bright pink laptop and begins to fill the "cute but clueless girl gamer" role. (Clip) While playing the game, we see her making gun shapes with her hands and going pewpewpew before being corrected to use your mouse and keyboard. She banters Howard into dressing like her character so they match to display that they're together in the game and refuses to heal the other members of the party except for him. Ultimately she begins to frustrate the guys by disturbing their questing due to failure. Tension rises as neither Raj, Sheldon, or Leonard want to speak up against her lovey-dovey attitude towards her fiancé nor want to risk hurting her feelings but the irritation is clearly seen on their faces and in their silence.

"The Weekend Vortex" was an eye opener. It made me realize that a demographic being overlooked - the average nerdy girl. Let's take a closer look at the three main female characters in the show, shall we?

Penny is the "hot chick"; this is something that cannot be denied. She's your average person scrapping by to make a living. Not really intelligent or into nerdy hobbies like the rest of the cast, her role is add a bit of sexy spice to the mix and make up for everyone else's lack of social skills. Bernadette is the "attractive, smart chick" whose character pushes borderline-feminist ideals without being overly bold about them. Throughout the series, she obtains her doctrine in microbiology yet has a healthy sex life as well as being pretty. Her career becomes very successful, leading to the development of the strong, modern day woman archetype. She expresses a disliking for children and fears losing her career to becoming a house wife before proposing that Howard takes care of the children as she works; after all, she already makes more money than he does. Her character becomes an example of how a woman can be both smart and beautiful while also keeping a sense of independence. Then we have Amy who is the "bland, smart chick". With a doctrine in neurobiology, she is the least attractive of the three main female characters and is portrayed to be the most pathetic of the bunch. Having very little physical relationships in her life and bullied while growing up, she's the quiet shy girl that no one really talked to who becomes overly clinging and sensitive towards those around her. Personality wise, she's just as socially awkward and strange as Sheldon, thus balancing out the attractive factor that the other two already established in the show.

I appreciate that Chuck Lorre and Bill Prady have managed to steer away from just having eye candy on the show, but I cannot shake the feeling that both are horrible at writing and developing female characters. The scene of Bernadette playing Old Republic with the guys left a distasteful flavor in my mouth. It fed into the negative stereotypes that women who do play games either start to play to bond with their boyfriends or are impractical players. The floral, pink laptop was cringe worth enough but her actions throughout the scene only made it worse. As a woman who has faced some harassment for liking nerdy things, having a show promote stereotypes like this isn't helping to improve the female community's image while empowering the male half.

I understand that the premise of the episode was to display the consequences that can follow contradictions that rise when trying to balance a romantic life with a social life. However, like the promo for the episode says, "There's just one problem...The girlfriend." Again, while this is the episodes theme, there have been quite a few occasions throughout the series where "the girlfriend" has come between the man and what he wants. Such as how Bernadette opposed against Howard working on the space station despite it being his life long dream to go to space or constant interferences from Penny with Leonard's other relationships. The show may focus mainly on the main four guys and Penny, but the other two female leads have grown to take bigger parts in the plot. However, the is little to no individuality to them.

It also does not help that none of the women hold any interest in geek-like hobbies. They three always get together to partake in drinking, gossip, and shopping despite having some knowledge about video games, comic books, and science fiction media. In fact, they all seem pretty disgusted by it.

For awhile in the earlier season, we saw Penny become addicted to Age of Conan and beat one of the guys in a game of Halo 3, but her accepting/liking of video games quickly vanishes from the series. She tries to learn a bit about the things Leonard enjoys to be appealing and interested to him, and at times, will make a nerdy reference but she still shows plenty of confusion regarding it. Neither Bernadette or Amy really express interest either, often getting things like Star Trek and Star Wars mixed up or being displeased with their boyfriends' "childish" hobbies and behaviors. For a show that tries to glorify science and make nerds look cool, I find it incredibly hard to believe that that is no female character that likes video games, comics, and science fiction. A few minor characters have popped up here and there but none have been well written or reoccurring.

I do not understand why some geeky traits have not been sprinkled on any of the main female cast. Especially with Penny already having a small background in technological entertainment, they could easily write it in that she picks up gaming as a side hobby even if she played alone. She is a bit of a tomboy so the concept would be rather fitting for her without risking taking her out of character. Plus, with her already displaying some level of skill in earlier episodes, we could see a positive, female geek over the shameful character they have created with Bernadette. Now, it could be argued that maybe they will eventually include a girl who is more like "one of the guys" later in the series. One that Raj could eventually grow comfortable enough around to speak to due to her nerdy habits but at this point, I do not have faith in Lorre or Prady to be that clever and write her all.



Because have you noticed the other reoccurring pattern regarding the female characters...?

All of them are "girlfriends". Each and every lead character that has been a woman was introduced to the show for the sole purpose of being matched up to another character, even if their relationship spanned over a few episodes. I do not mean to write the show off as being sexist because I do not exactly see it in such a way. Relationships always add more to the plot and naturally do occur when people who share similar interests, life styles, and ideals mix. It adds a sense of realism to the storyline but the way The Big Bang Theory has done it has been poor character development. In the very first episode, Leonard had already established a hollow infatuation with Penny to the point of offering to help her retrieve some properly from her ex just based on speaking to her for a few minutes. Bernadette was introduced to the show by being a selected friend of Penny's to go on a date with Howard due to the girlfriend pact: an agreement Penny would set him up with one of his friends. This eventually blooms into their relationship leading up to their engagement. Finally, Amy is introduced by flat out being matched up to Sheldon after Raj and Howard make a fake profile for him on a dating site.

Though of course the train does not stop there. A few other reoccurring women in the series were also implemented into the plot for little reason other than to complicate relationships and add sexual tension. Leslie Winkle (a rival of Sheldon's at the university) only appeared in a total of eight episodes and grew notorious for casual sex between Leonard and Howard before being written off from the show. Priya Koothrappali (Raj's sister) is yet another character whose traits center around an active relationship with another. Filling the shoes as the "uppity, rich bitch", she seems to hold little value to her relationship with Leonard as she hides it from her family and cheats on him after relocating back to India. Finally, there was Dr. Stephanie Barnette; a surgical doctor that Leonard had a brief, semi-serious relationship with. She was written as a date Howard was trying to impress but felt a stronger connection to his friend instead. In an interview, Prady admits that she was "a chance for Leonard to learn that just because someone loves you, doesn't mean you'll love them back" but nothing more.

I cannot help but feel somewhat insulted by all of this. Not only does my niche in the community not seem to be noticeable, but apparently woman are only good for making our male counterparts not lonely. While I do not feel that show is intentionally sexist, I do feel that there is plenty of room for the women of The Big Bang Theory to grow, especially in the geeky department. Poor writing choices have led to rather disappointing evolution of the characters. I do understand that not all scientists or doctors enjoy technology and science fiction hobbies, but this is a sitcom about scientists who do enjoy those things. Why can't we have a woman be like that, too?
Photo Photo



Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!




Those who have come:



Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


Great points Stephanie, I very much agree with you that the females of the show has room to grow quite a bit. Sadly though I don't think thats going to happen when the majority (my guess) are guys who want or does view women in the way they are presented in this show so changing that would confuse the shows main demographic. But hey! Here's hoping for better shows with better more relatable characers!
I've never seen the show, and after watching that clip I may never. I did see a couple of clips, but it doesn't look appealing to me. It can't be that hard to write a female that likes sci-fi, fantasy, and video games. If they can write how guys like it, why not females?
Came here thinking this was about Big Bang Beat, left remembering why I stopped watching this show. I watched a good amount of episodes and I don't ever remember them introducing a normal female who plays games, as a minor or main character.
I came here because I thought this was about Bernadette's bust.I am disappointed this article has no pictures of her humungous rack.
How... how are you able to sit through 4 seasons of that? I couldn't even do 4 episodes. I wanted to punch every single friend that swore I'd love it because of all the geek jokes.

I have so many better shows on Netflix that I can recommend. None of which are flat out insulting to their supposed target audience.
I've watched the show with my wife, and while I can appreciate their conversations in quantum physics, I usually cringe at the choices of games they play and broad generalizations regarding the subculture of geeks and nerds. Also, the female co-scientist of Leonard's that served as a love interest for a couple episodes was so radically geeky and devoid of emotion that it makes me think that nothing but stereotypes are portrayed in the show. There are plenty of girls who aren't nerdy or have geeky interests, and Penny's representation of that group is probably the most accurate portrayal in the show. As a chemical engineer, even when working in a research and development firm, I don't have the level of nerd that the main characters show, and I'm just as interested in their hobbies as them!
Because, Scotty, I'm a masochist

Anyway, thank you everyone who has commented so far. I just hope I was capable of portraying my idea well enough; that I don't take it has the show being sexist or saying "this is how women arr". I just noticed a few observations that came off slightly insult but they're the product of poor writing and nothing more. So, I figured I'd share my view and see what others thought.
Because, Scotty, I'm a masochist

Anyway, thank you everyone who has commented so far. I just hope I was capable of portraying my idea well enough; that I don't take it has the show being sexist or saying "this is how women arr". I just noticed a few observations that came off slightly insult but they're the product of poor writing and nothing more. So, I figured I'd share my view and see what others thought.
My biggest problem with Big Bang Theory is that David left Darlene to become a nerd.

I've only watched the show a few times, but it definitely seems to be a "guy" show. It seemed to mock stereotypes of men, so I'm not surprised that the females on the show are also somewhat stereotypical.

It reminds me a lot of Sony's advertising campaigns... which often seem to place females into the "girlfriend" role (thinking that Uncharted is a movie) or worst... those stupid PSP ads where the entire theme was "girls don't game" and Romeo tells Juliet he's too busy gaming for that "love" shit (or the Dustballs/rats/whatever they were and they're "picking up chicks" cheap jokes).

Women are much more obvious in online gaming and in gaming culture... but it doesn't seem that the general population and media has looked around and caught on to this fact yet. :(
I think the problem with expecting more from the female characters on The Big Bang Theory is that...it's The Big Bang Theory. It's one of those lowest common denominator shows like Two and a Half Men. I would love to see better female characters on it, including the ones you described in your post, but TV execs operate under the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" model. BBT is doing well for them as is, so things aren't going to change.
They can't be like that because the show is basically nerd blackface and generally ridiculing women is considered sexist. I have watched remarkably little of it due to the former.

As for the latter issue: that's just the way things are. Society says it's acceptable to make men the butt of jokes that would be considered offensive were a woman in their place. It's because there's no (or at least much less) stigma for anyone not "getting" video games, but making fun of a woman for liking "nerdy guy stuff" is very thin ice, risking people thinking they were being mocked for being involved rather than for being nerds (though I think both are wrong.)

I realize that's a really black and white interpretation, but I just watched an episode of Bones where Hodgins is called out for an inappropriate generalization for asking "don't women like that?" and just stands there looking guilty and then a few scenes later, Angela (the resident free spirit speshul snowflake) says, in regard to dog fighting, "No, MEN do it." and then (the always right, prettier than everyone) Brennan chimes in with a "Yeah, MEN." while the male intern of the week... stands there and takes it, looking guilty. And they're never faulted for it. As someone that gets choked up whenever the Sarah McLaughlin sad puppies commercial comes on TV and gets that sympathetic, skin-crawling feeling seeing someone's scraped knee, I was disgusted that they would suggest I, being part of "men", like to watch two animals tear each other apart by any stretch of association. I'm really not feeling tolerant to double standards right now.

Back to Big Bang Theory though! It exists to exploit "nerd" stuff for cheap laughs, but it has to exploit the people which do those things. I don't watch BBT because I hate it, but I can understand why you want a more relateable character there. There shouldn't be a problem with a female character that's a normal gamer, and it can't be difficult to write one just as a person (but that wouldn't be as exploitable). It's probably the same feeling I had watching Supernatural where the two lead characters are both so bro-ful that they had a several season streak where their only emotions were obligation and anger.

In addition to that, I'm bothered by them portraying men self-segregating, even temporarily, as something that must be invaded by women and by the idea that a man must be ridiculed by the group the moment he agrees to a woman's suggestion, complete with sound effects and multiple laugh track plays.

...I think I've just reaffirmed my hatred of Big Bang Theory.
Wonderful blog. I don't watch the show (because it looks terrible), but you bring up some great points. For your sake (and the sake of the other masochists out there) I hope they start taking their female characters more seriously going forward!
I'm still not sure what to say about this blog. It's good.
That's probably good enough.
Well, it's a show with a laughtrack. What did you expect?
Very good blog. I use to analyze sitcoms like this too, it lead me to stop watching them completely. Most sitcoms seem to share this theme of a female character that's always nagging (usually a wife) or a feminst-eqsuq character this is really bossy. The male character is usually some selfish jerk that has the sole redemming qualities of lifting heavy things, or it's some nice guy character that's a coward.

As with StealthMaster I never watched this show, and after watching those clips and reading this blog I never will.
The most offensive part is that they were enjoying the Old Republic. Bioware paid for this episode, didn't they?
BBT has very mainstream-friendly references; Mario Bros., Superman etc.
@Trev

'Nerd Blackface' is pretty much how I'd say the show is. Look at the characters: the nerd who can't speak to women, the sex-obsessed nerd with mommy issues, Leonard, who has a little anxiety and confidence issues but generally is probably the most grounded and realistic character, and Sheldon, who's the worst. A complete social failure and a disaster with women.

I don't think I have to explain that most nerds in real life, or at least most scientists, gamers, comic book fans etc are not like this. Yet people seem to think this is some sort of cross-section of nerd life. I'm astounded by how many people I know who love the show, yet don't think for a second to question how close (or far) it is to reality.

I thought that at the start of the series Penny would eventually adopt more nerdish tendencies and start becoming her own nerd, rather than an unwilling participant in the nerd activity du jour that Leonard drags her into. For a while it seemed like it was heading in this direction. And honestly I would have found that interesting because it would have subverted the still-widely held view of nerds as social pariahs who can't get a girlfriend. But instead all we got was 'they're watching babylon 5 lolz that is so funny coz they are nerds. Look at the nerds. Funny'. Penny, as an outsider to the nerd community could have been the perfect conduit to show the viewer that nerd's ain't so bad, once you get to know them. But instead of any meaningful exploration we got a nerd zoo.

They could have been nerdom's Will and Grace. Without Grace, it's just a show about how weird gay people are - another shallow stereotype. But with her the viewer can relate to the show.

Another big missed opportunity would be to subvert Penny's high opinion of herself. At the beginning, she clearly thinks she is too good for Leonard, who seems like a genuinely nice guy. The thing is, yeah she's a lot more hot than he is but he is smart and has a stable job, she is still thinking of herself as an actor out of work, which shows her delusion about her own place (she's only ever worked a couple of commercials). If not for Leonard being a nerd, which holds him back considerably in the romantic department, he would almost be too good for her. Being a nerd doesn't automatically make you a worse person, and someone should have shown Penny this - and in doing so shown the audience.

Back to Top
DLC   |   BEST Games of 2012   |   Best PC Games   |   Best PS3 Games   |   Best Xbox 360 Games   |   Best Wii U Games   |   Best 3DS Games




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more