Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by ShadeOfLight | 2010 Sucked: Sexism is to Other M what racism was to RE5Destructoid
LIGHTS:  ON | OFF
surf dtoid with arrow keys

HOT GAMES
REVIEWS VIDEOS COMMUNITY FORUM SHOP

pc PS4 PS3 NEXT XBOX XBOX 360 WII U 3DS PS vita ANDROID APPLE

REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll

click to hide banner header
About


The darkness to every light, the shadow to every shine, the dusk to every dawn, the Luna to every Sol.

And vice versa.

I'm ShadeOfLight.
I'm a Dutch law student who loves to game. I'm a Nintendo-fanboy at heart, but I don't feel that I'm blinded by that, at least not very often. I am also currently on the Cblog Recaps team for Thursdays, so if for some voyeuristic reason you want to know more about me, check out my weekly Shadeisms.

I'm obsessed with the Monolith Soft RPGs Xenoblade Chronicles and the Baten Kaitos series. I will not pass up the opportunity to mention them, ever, and I consider myself Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean's biggest fan. Finally, as is to be expected I'm super excited for the new WiiU "Xeno-" game!



The Wii is one of my favorite systems of all time, and my favorite games on this system include, but are most certainly not limited to;
Xenoblade Chronicles (see also: Baten Kaitos - Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean for GC)
Zelda: Twilight Princess / Skyward Sword
Smash Bros.
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Madworld
Muramasa - The Demon Blade
Wario Land: Shake it!
Sonic Colors
and Metroid Prime Trilogy.

I love my WiiU as well, and even though there aren't that many games out for it right now, I'm having tons of fun with:
New Super Mario Bros. U
Darksiders II
Mighty Switch Force: Hyper Drive Edition
Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate

Apart from Nintendo, I'm a huge indie game enthousiast. Give me a game like Trine, VVVVVV, Sequence or Recettear, and you've made me a happy camper for sure. You can keep your shooters to yourself.

Favorite indie game round-up:
Trine (+ Trine 2)
Super Meat Boy
The Binding of Isaac
Dungeons of Dredmor
Mark of the Ninja
VVVVVV
Sequence
Cthulhu Saves the World
Recettear - An Item Shop's Tale
Bastion
To The Moon
Cave Story
LIMBO
Dustforce
Orcs Must Die! 2
Machinarium
Botanicula
The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom
and many, many more!

Besides gaming itself, I like reading up on gaming-related news on my favorite website in the whole wide world: Destructoid. I love all the people here, and I'm glad that I get to be a part of this. Wouldn't know what to do without you!
Player Profile
Steam ID:http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198005145371/
Wii U code:ShadeOfLight
Follow me:
ShadeOfLight's sites
Badges
Following (24)  




Remember back when the first trailer for Resident Evil 5 was released? All of a sudden the 'unwashed masses' started to cry about the racism in that game, because it was about a white man shooting black men. That was stupid wasn't it? After all, the game took place in Africa, and there are in fact black people over there (or so I've been told). It made sense within the premise of the game, so those cries of racism were obviously completely unfounded.

(this blog will contain spoilers for Metroid: Other M from here, although probably none you haven't read about already anyway)
And then came Metroid: Other M. If you haven't played this game, you probably only know one thing about it: this game set Samus and feminism back a couple of decades, and it completely destroyed all independence and strength Samus ever had. Mostly because Samus (who, spoilers, is a woman) takes orders from Adam, a man.

That reasoning was completely lost on me, as I will explain in detail in this blog. Let me first say that I liked Other M, although not nearly as much as the Primes. This game certainly had its flaws, some of them storywise, and I will quickly discuss those as well. I can understand that some might not like this game, for personal and completely legitimate reasons, and they are very much allowed to dislike it. What I will fight however, are those who blindly cry sexism, because I think that is unfounded and frankly...somewhat sexist. They are the ones who made 2010 suck to me. So grab a lighter and some gasoline, lit all those flames and have at me back in the comments!


See? Even Samus disliked those people

Why is it that Samus taking orders from a man is such a big issue to some? Aren't women allowed to do that?
One thing I can say for sure: I did not find it unreasonable within the premise of the game. My main argument for that is that Samus has no authority to be a part of the particular mission at the Bottleship at all. Based on one part SOS and one part intuition, she decided to go and check out what was wrong. Once there, she found that not only was the Bottleship a Galactic Federation (the interplanetary government) ship, there was already a Galactic Federation mission present. As such, as an independent party she has no basis to be there, despite her skills. Would you let Jackie Chan join a police raid just like that? No, you wouldn't.
Adam (the commander of the GF mission) had every right to send her away, lest she get into major trouble with the government. He goes on to request her help, but requires her to follow his orders, as he is still the commander of the mission.

And there we have it, Samus is now following the orders of a man...and I fail to see the issue. What troubles me is that some people immediately cried sexism at the thought of a man ordering a woman around. It's not degrading her in any way, she's not required to do a sexy dance for the amusement of the men, she just has to follow orders. Isn't this common in the military, or even the workplace on a smaller scale? Some people outrank other people and are therefore allowed to give orders. Sex and gender has no influence on any of that. If the roles were reversed, the situation would still be exactly the same. The fact that Samus has personal respect for this particular superior (as expanded upon in the backstory) only makes it more logical that she would follow his orders for this particular mission.


Yeah, I wouldn't like them saying such things behind my back either

The second major degrading thing of Samus is her fear of Ridley.
Apparently, Samus is not allowed to fear a giant space dragon who killed her parents right in front of her when she was little. To me though, this fear also made perfect sense within the premise of the game.
Yes, it's true that she fought and beat him before several times, but still. The first couple of times, she killed Ridley, and that was it. He was then rebuild with machine parts, and she killed him again. In Super Metroid however, the previous mission in the timeline, not only did she kill him and saw him explode...she literally blew up the planet that his remains were on. If there was ever a time when Ridley simply could not still be alive, it was then. Yet, on the Bottleship, where Ridley has to Samus' knowledge no reason to be even if he was still alive, there he is out of nowhere. Is it really so strange for her to be in shock at that moment? Really?

And finally, what many seem to forget is that after the initial shock...she proceeds to kick his ass so much that the giant space dragon flees in terror.


This is more or less what she had in store for him

There are things against this game and its story. The authorization of suit upgrades made sense for the weapons that could be dangerous to other members of the team, but there was no good reason to hold out on the defensive ones. This is a bit of gameplay and story mixing...not too well, I can fully admit that. The first person pixel hunts made the game come to a screeching halt and the game had some other issues as well.

However, calling the game sexist and degrading of Samus seems unfair to me. Apparently there are some people who like to think that a woman taking orders in any setting whatsoever to be degrading of her and decreases her independence. Samus showing any sort of fear is somehow beneath her. As a strong, independent woman, she is not allowed to fear anything, since that will make her more vulnerable and therefore more 'stereotypically female'. In my opinion however, confronting such fears head-on seems exactly what a strong woman (or man, for that matter) would do. Taking part in an important mission solely to protect others, even while taking orders from a respected superior, is exactly what a strong woman would do. A woman having some emotional baggage and trying to deal with it is not disrespectful, and neither is her looking up to someone.

No, Samus running away at the first sight of danger, crying on the shoulder of the first man in sight, and then taking her gunship as far as it would go, that would've been sexist.

I am not attacking everyone who considers Other M bad, or even everyone who considers the game sexist in some way. You might have perfectly good reasons for that, and that's okay, although I will strongly disagree with you.
But to everyone who cried sexism in Metroid: Other M for such simple reasons as Samus following orders or having fears: you sucked in 2010.
Photo Photo Photo



Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!




Those who have come:



Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


Awesome and well-reasoned blog.

I think much of the problem comes from playrs having invented their own ideas about Samus, but did so without playing some of the games leading up to Other M, Zero Mission and Fusion in particular.

Samus was part of a military unit, Adam Malkovitch wasn't someone she simply respected but the closest thing she ever had to a human father figure (the Chozo were also this, but not human).

This respect was established way back in 2002's Metroid Fusion. Anyone who followed that story knew of the mutual respect, their falling out and a suggested end Malkovich met.

Samus entered the Bottle Ship with no sanction and no contract, but Adam had suspicious about the Bottle Ship and if he authorized her presence, he would have a very capable witness.

Also, Samus left the unit over Adam's decision to let his brother, Ian, die. She thought he was being cold and cruel and yet that decision saved countless lives. She was being a child and, in retrospect, she knows that now. While hasty decisions wouldn't change her status as a bounty hunter of some reknown, the very least she could do to show she had changed and grown up quite a bit was take orders from Adam.

And the being afraid of Ridley bit was also totally appropriate. Yeah, she had killed him a a few times before, or so she thought, but the asskicking she handed him in Super Metroid - even at the time of that game's release - seemed to bear a sense of finality.

Seriously, back in '94, Metroid felt like it was over as a series.

Plus how do you explain Ridley's frozen remains in Fusion if he didn't appear again? Other M suggests exactly how that happens. And Nightmare's clean-up is notable, too. And that of the Queen.
Anyone who hasn't given Other M a chance because of the lousy, and undeserved review scores should check out your blog here. You pretty much smacked that nail over the head with a sledgehammer. I thought those complaints were completely ridiculous, and when you read most of the reviews you'd swear that it was just one idiot who was somehow offended, and everyone else jumped on the bandwagon.

Changed Samus's personality?? Since when has Samus had a personality. For all we know she may have pee'd her suit the first time she bumped into Ridley. It just couldn't be expressed on screen back in the days of 8 bit 2D Metroid.

"Whaaa the man has to unlock your equipment....whaaaaa." Who cares? So instead of finding equipment for your suit stored in an air conditioning vent it gets unlocked. It fits into the game. The way people bitch you'd think they had completely removed any and all of the exploration elements from past Metroid games. There's plenty of crap to look around the map for.

Anyways I'm rambling. I loved this game, and I'm hoping they'll make another like this.
Three comments and no flames yet. I'm almost disappointed, internet :P

@Karutomaru

I know, I have that problem more often. My previous Musing (which was my very first) was also just barely related to the topic. Writing itself seems to go over well enough, but finding a subject is more difficult. I have the problem that 1) I want to write a Musing, and 2) I have a different specific topic that I personally find interesting and want to write about.

In the end, the two just get mixed together rather crudely. I'm still looking for a solution that works for me.
I never thought of Other M as sexist. I saw it more as the pussification of a bad-ass professional bounty hunter. Like if you took Kratos or Master Chief and turned them into Cloud... or, I suppose any male JRPG protagonist.

Even in Fusion she was a consummate professional who didn't turn into an whining scardey-cat when there was pressure put on her. I'm sure there was tension, fear and stress, but being such a successful bounty hunter means she sucks it up and gets the job done.

I don't see it as sexism, I just see it as ruining a good (if shallow) character. Sure it was probably time to explore her character in ways that don't involve seeing how often you can get her to show her Zero Suit, but I think the game did a terrible job of it... funnily enough mostly focusing on how often they can get her to show her Zero Suit.
Truthfully, I doubt people would be screaming "SEXISM!" if the story was written better.
@Scotty - I'm glad you're here to tell us what being a bounty hunter means.
I bought this game because of this blog. Didn't read it all because of the spoilers though!

Back to Top
DLC   |   BEST Games of 2012   |   Best PC Games   |   Best PS3 Games   |   Best Xbox 360 Games   |   Best Wii U Games   |   Best 3DS Games




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more