I'm kind of sorry I missed the discussion in
the original article about Medal of Honor's portrayal of Al Queda. I have been thinking about this issue with Medal of Honor a lot, and frankly, I'm surprised there hasn't been more talk about it.
I don't have any desire to play Medal of Honor. Not that I don't like to play shooters, or military shooters (quite the contrary) but this seems like the video game version of John Wayne's craptacular propaganda-fest,
The Green Berets. Afghanistan is a real, bloody, disgusting war where real human beings are suffering and dying. Why is this becoming bombastic entertainment? There's no appearance, so far, of this game being something as introspective and anti-war as
The Hurt Locker.
A company as big and old as EA probably never really had any scruples to begin with, and obviously a boycott of the game is just fucking stupid. I choose to not play Medal of Honor because it is exploitive and does nothing to contradict the official, propaganda line about this ugly war.
Human society imperatively needs introspection, and now more than ever. America has descended to the level of skirting brutal torture of enemy combatants, and even non-combatants. Reports and leaks from Afghanistan indicate cover-ups of civilian deaths at the hands of the very "Tier 1 operators" as Medal of Honor glorifies.
Games are advanced enough to partake in societal discussion. Look at Bioshock. Look at Uncharted 2's portrayal of an ugly war from the perspective of journalists. Look at that famous nuke scene from Call of Duty 4. The fact that Medal of Honor is not making any attempt at social discourse is driven by marketing concerns, and I understand that. But Medal of Honor, ironically, demonstrates no attempt at honorable behavior at all.