With Watchmen set to debut in just a few days it is not surprising that the game has just made its debut on the XBLA. PS3 fans will get a chance to enjoy the game on the PSN network very soon as well. I read the review provided by the Destructoid crew and I must admit that I am in complete disagreement with them. While I feel the game is a typical brawler it also offers some quick and smooth game play. And, for just $20.00 the Watchmen game is a great deal when compared with the crap found on the XBLA system.
Pros: The game has decent graphics for its $20 value. If you take the time to look at Rorschach's face you will even see it melt and change. I was plesently surprised about the detail in the levels as well. The fire actually resembles fire and the mood of the graphic novel is captured perfectly by the setting, voice over, and comic book cut screens. If you are a fan of the graphic novel or merely looking for a decent arcade game to destract you until something else comes out then I wholly recommend this game. The brawling mechanics are decent as well and I felt as if my characters had weight to them. The "oh cool" moments are definitly plenty in this game and watching Rorschach snap someone's arm or pummel them in the crouch is worth it.
Cons: The game is repitious and hordes or nameless villains constantly attach without provication. However, if you know the storyline of book or even grasp the setting of the game then you realize that these nameless villains very much fit. At the same time I do think putting a decent named villain from the book would not have been to difficult here and there. I will also say that though I like the combo system it does not seem all that necessary. Often times combos take to long to use when I could just as easily throw an enemy or rip their face off, metaphroically of course.
So in short I think the game has some high replay value but is not meant to be taken as the usual game. The game is $20 for a reason and will wet the appetite of a fan or again give the XBLA system a decent game until something else is available.
Your blog needs grammatical/spelling help ASAP.
As for your review, your very own cons make me not want to purchase a game that is twenty dollars and its length is a mere three hours.
Yojimbo: Movies cost $20 and they're barely 2 hours.
pwned
@Vexed Alex:
That is true but I expect more from videogames @ that price point.
Example: I can get Shadow of Colossus for that price. Why would I even entertain the thought of getting a rather short and mediocre game for the same price?
@Y0J1MB0: Because it's Watchmen?
@Yojimbo: Because Shadow of the Colossus came out years ago. That's what happens with old shit. It devalues. You can wait a few years to buy games if that's your fancy.
If that's your argument, then when do you ever buy downloadable games? They're all around the $10 to $20 price point. I was able to buy Bioshock for $5 during Steam's deals. Did that stop me from buying the Lost and the Damned at $20?
@Yojimbo
You know Assassin's Creed originally cost $60 yet people still bought it and complained about the repition. Also, those same people enjoyed the game. Every game has some repition. Take Gears of War: hide behind object shoot gun, rinse and repeat. Or Shadow of the Colossus where all you do is scale giant monsters for the entire game basically doing the same thing over and over again. My point, games are still fun even with repition. Oh yeah and its Watchmen.