Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by Rhuno | Uncharted 3: Good, but not great. Anyone else?Destructoid
LIGHTS:  ON | OFF
surf dtoid with arrow keys



REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll

click to hide banner header
About
The first console I played was the NES in the mid to late 80's - great times! I've been gaming ever since. Some of my favorite games of all time include:

-Chrono Trigger
-The Guardian Legend
-The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
-Fatal Frame 2
-Final Fantasy X
-Halo

What do I think of the current generation (so far)?

Best console: Xbox 360
Best new IP: Uncharted
Best game: Uncharted 2
Best under-appreciated game: Enslaved: Odyssey to the West
Best innovation: Achievements!

My iPhone Game: CherryPicker_ios
Player Profile
Follow me:
Rhuno's sites
Badges
Following (5)  


If you know me, then you probably know I'm largely a 360 gamer. I don't play games nearly as much as I did in years gone by, but when I do, I usually reach for the Xbox controller. It may surprise you then to learn that the Uncharted series is my favorite new IP of this generation. Uncharted 2 was absolutely fantastic and I couldn't wait to get my paws on the third installment in the franchise. So here we are; the Uncharted 3 release has come and gone. Having finished the campaign in just under 9.5 hours, I find myself somewhat disappointed with the overall experience.

Note that I tried to keep this blog relatively vague to avoid ruining the Uncharted 3 story for those that haven't finished it yet, but you may want to bail here anyway to be safe.



Don't get me wrong, Uncharted 3 is a good game. The lovable cast of characters is back and in fine form. The storyline is a pleasant mix of historic facts and myth. So what exactly is the problem? It's twofold for me. For one, the gunplay in the game is lacking. I found the controls and aiming in combat to be slightly frustrating; they just don't feel very accurate. I love the characters and story so much that I often found myself feeling annoyed when yet another wave enemies swarmed the screen.

In addition to the great characters and storyline; a couple other favorite features from the series includes exploring the environments and solving puzzles. The environments are always gorgeous in the series and the puzzles are clever; not overly difficult, but not always that simple either. The frequent gun combat in the game serves only to interrupt an otherwise enjoyable experience.

Another problem was that the game just didn't grab me the way 2 did. In Uncharted 2, there were several moments that just blew me away. The truck that comes crashing through the wreckage, attempting to run Nathan down; finding Marco Polo's crew underground; the helicopter that shoots out the building's supports, sending it toppling over with Nathan and Chloe still inside. Those kinds of scenes stick with you; in fact, I get chills just thinking about them.



I only felt that way about one scene in Uncharted 3: the plane scene. Many others; such as the burning mansion and cruise ship, just didn't have the same impact. I felt like the developers were trying to capture the intensity of the aforementioned scenes in Uncharted 2, but just couldn't quite pull it off.

Plus, you know what? I'm all Team Chloe here. I don't really care for Elena; she's boring. Drake needs to drop her already. Ha!



Maybe I just expected too much from Uncharted 3. Perhaps the fact that I already knew what I was getting into with the game just made it less exciting for me. Whatever the reason, it is still Uncharted 2 that I call my favorite game of this generation and certainly the best in this series.

Anyone else feel the same way? Or heck, even if you disagree; feel free to say why. I'd be interested to see what others think of the game and series as a whole.
Photo Photo Photo



Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!




Those who have come:



Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


I have to agree, and I'm happy to find someone else who liked the second one better hearing so many people say it's better than the 2nd is making me scratch my head.

I'm team Elena, but I am disappointed by the lack of Chloe too, she didn't have much to do with the story this time. I felt the story was too serious, one of my favorite things about the series was that it's light-hearted nature. Uncharted 2 had me laughing every minute, the dialogue was top-noth. There was only a handful of laughs in the 3rd game, their was too much of an emphasis on drama, and I felt the drama parts to be a bit predictable.

The gunplay in this game wasn't as good because the aiming was off, and you were forced to stay behind cover too often. One of the things I liked about the 2nd game was that I could run around like crazy and not die. In this game if you tried to do that you'd die because their was usually two snipers, two rocket launchers, and a couple of guys trying to sneak up on you with shotguns.

The puzzles in this game were almost non-existant. Their was only a few and most of them were obvious how to solve. The "oh crap" moments weren't as genuine this time around, because you could tell when they were going to happen. I felt the villains weren't too intersting, and I was disappointed when the final boss fight was just a quick time event.

It wasn't a bad game, but I'm pretty disappointed in it. I'm hoping that playing some local Co-op will make up for my disappointment in the single player.
I think Uncharted 3 is a great game, but Uncharted 2 is a much better game.I missed the two girls, the puzzles weren't as good or memorable as UC2, there wasn't as many jaw dropping moments, the villains lacked character development and so did the main characters such as Drake.

I ended up enjoying my 2nd playthrough, or random play throughs of various chapters, much more than my first time. I was just expecting something else of the game originally. UC3 is more about Nathan and Drake, while I still terribly missed Elena and Chloe [especially Chloe's ass], this game just wasn't really about them as much.

There are tons of epic moments in the game, it sounds odd, but I said "oh shit" a lot more the 2nd time I played chapters! Even though I knew what was going to happen, it was just more bad ass and awesome. haha, I think I was just disappointed in the lack of certain characters and character development. Those things I was disappointed in got me feeling negative to the whole game itself.

At one point I was saying the graphics sucked XD
I just got in a real unhappy, negative, and hateful attitude towards the game. But I started loving it once I gave it the chance.

I do love this game, I think UC2 might be better [perhaps because it was new and fresh, set extremely high standards], but UC3 is still an epic game.
I was, surprisingly, disappointed by Uncharted 3. Your comments on the gunplay are my main beef, though I also have extreme frustration with how unpolished the jumping mechanics were. There were frequent times during the first 10 chapters where Drake either wouldn't reach for a jump or would miss it for no apparent reason.

Still, nothing takes the cake like how ridiculous the AI is. There is literally no point in cover in this game because everyone bum rushes you. You might as well learn to stay alive and forget that you're playing a cover based shooter.

Still, story was excellent, music was superb and the graphics really sell the environments. I just wish the gameplay could have been polished. If anything, the ending is the best of the series. That's something.
Appreciate the comments, guys; good to know I'm not the only one who felt a little let down. I do think, as PlanetPanton pointed out, that part of it is simply because Uncharted 2 was such a new experience. Especially for me as 2 was the first one I played! :o)
Is Uncharted 3 suffering from the curse of the 3rd?
Definitely agree.
I just received Uncharted 2 and 3 as a gift from my wonderful husband... so I'm just playing through 2 now.

I'm enjoying it... though still right near the beginning. I do find all the cutscenes a bit frustrating though and am never really sure when the game is done with a cutscene and playable again. It really is like "playing" a movie.

Back to Top
DLC   |   BEST Games of 2012   |   Best PC Games   |   Best PS3 Games   |   Best Xbox 360 Games   |   Best Wii U Games   |   Best 3DS Games




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more