Weird Theory: Has Mario been lying to all of us? - Destructoid

Game database:   #ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ         ALL     Xbox One     PS4     360     PS3     WiiU     Wii     PC     3DS     DS     PS Vita     PSP     iOS     Android

click to hide banner header

My name is William Peacock. I'm a long-term gamer, and a full-time teacher. I've been blogging since January '14. If I'm not writing about my experiences as a gamer-teacher, I'm probably over-thinking games for the fun of it.

You can find me writing in the Community area here, or at I hope no one ever asks me to decide which community I love more. I'm also on WordPress.

If you're feeling really adventurous, you can follow me on Twitter or like my Facebook Page.

Player Profile
Xbox LIVE:RedHeadPeak
Steam ID:RedHeadPeak
Follow me:
Following (9)  

I don’t own a Wii U, and I have only recently become the owner of a 3DS. This means that my knowledge of more recent Super Mario games is limited. Last week, I discovered a startling fact about Super Mario 3D World – this time Bowser does not kidnap Princess Peach. Now this may not have made waves with you, but I... well I was appalled.

How could this happen? How could Bowser do this to Peach? After all they have been through? And after everything that Mario has done for him?

What, I hear the voices in my head asking, am I talking about? Well, if my long standing theory holds true, then Bowser’s change in behaviour means that he has broken Peach’s heart, and betrayed 30 years of friendship with Mario.

It just can't be true.

(If you hadn’t realised be now, this is a fairly random post. It aims to provoke thought, to an extent, but beyond that it is practically pointless. Just so you know.)

Even before the first Super Mario Bros outing, Bowser and Peach have been in love with each other. Both know that this relationship would never be accepted. For the good of the Kingdom, they hid their true feelings. This love, however, only grew stronger the more they were apart. The only other person, who knew this secret, was Bowser’s best friend Mario.

Then a plan hatched like a baby Yoshi. Bowser would ‘kidnap’ Peach. Retreating to the sanctuary of Bowser’s castle, the lovers could be honest and open with each other. Meanwhile, the faithful Mario would step forward, declaring that he ‘would journey to rescue the Princess’.

The humble plumber would put on a good show, appearing to battle Koopas and leap daringly down pipes. At the end of his journey he and his ‘nemesis’ would do battle. With Bowser 'defeated', Peach and Mario return home triumphantly. Peace is restored until the two lovers yearn to meet once more and another ‘abduction’ takes place, allowing the duo to once again meet in private.

Mario is therefore Bowser’s best friend, secret keeper and possibly the best wingman in history.


1) Mario and Bowser are still alive.
It’s been nearly 30 years since this story began. To my knowledge, Peach has been ‘kidnapped’ at least a dozen times. It seems to me that if either side was looking for an end to this debacle, it would have ended with the death of either combatant. Bowser is bigger and stronger than Mario. He can breathe fire! Instead, the Italian plumber roughs him up and bit, maybe spinning him around by his tail for good measure, before throwing the big bad guy off screen. The theatrics don’t fool me.
2) Bowser’s minions are in on it (and they’re not very good actors)
They might waddle back and forth, give Mario the old evil-eye, but Bowser’s entourage aren't really putting up much of a fight. Sometimes they might stumble into Mario, but what happens then? Mario trots out an act worthy of pantomime; leaping into the air, eyes wide, fainting. Then, brushing off his overalls, he sets off again. 

Let's make this look good.

The man puts in a decent effort, don’t get me wrong. He throws the occasional pyrotechnic fireball, and he’s got that snazzy trick with the stars, but it’s clear to me that Mario is pulling his punches.

3) “ another castle.”
Bowser has a castle. Just the one and it’s pretty distinctive. Yet, Mario bumbles round the Mushroom Kingdom, jumping and searching. “Oh she’s not in this one either? Sigh. I best keep looking”. Mario knows what he’s doing – giving the love-birds as much time together as possible before the eventual ‘final battle’.

4) Peach is a princess.

In the Mushroom Kingdom, Princess Peach is the ruling Monarch. Unfortunately for our two lovers, monarchies must follow strict rules. When Peach marries, she will be the ruling Queen, but she will share power with her King. This is the fact which holds Peach and Bowser apart. How could the people of the Mushroom Kingdom truly accept Bowser as there King? They have always feared and hated him! Even daring to spend time with Peach could cause a dangerous political situation. The ‘abductions’ became the ideal solution.

5) They have so much fun together.
This theory puts all Mario games into perspective. Bowser, Peach and Mario freely meet with each other once the whole ‘kidnapping’ thing dies down. The Go-Karting, the wrestling matches, the sporting events. How could any of this be possibly happen any other way?

No hard feelings about jumping on you head, right?

6) Peach and Bowser have a son.

I'm not the first person to realise this, nor am I the first to address the subject. In Super Mario Sunshine Baby Bowser let’s slip that Peach is his mother (he has often referred to her as “Mama Peach”). Of course, since then all parties have asserted that Baby Bowser was mistaken... but that should not be enough to fool you.

The conclusion:

So why does the lack of Peach-kidnap in the new instalment appal me? Because of what it means for Peach and Mario! Think of all Mario has done for Bowser! The lengths he went through to keep their love secret!  And poor Peach! After 30 years of private romancing, Bowser is chasing after another woman. Nay, eight other women, if what I have heard is to be believed! I can only hope there is a rational explanation.

What do you think?

Feel free to find fault in my theory, or add any evidence I have overlooked. Does this make you think of the characters differently? Or did you already know this to be true?

Either way, I promise to blog more sensibly in the future...most of the time.
Photo Photo Photo

Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!

Those who have come:

Comments not appearing? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this.
Easy fix: Add   [*]   to your software's white list. Tada! Happy comments time again.

Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Back to Top

All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more