Video game piracy is bad. There’s no doubt about it. But here in Australia we have the right to own mod chips legally. Why? Because we get screwed so often that's why! Have you ever stopped to consider just how ridiculously expensive games are today? At the time of writing the Australian dollar is hovering around the US$0.95 mark meaning $1 Australian should get me about US$0.95. Keeping this in mind Australian games start around AU$70 for Nintendo DS games and go up to AU$120 for PlayStation 3 games. For the purpose of this argument I’ll focus on the median price of an Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3 game which is about AU$110.
So for AU$110 (US$103) I can buy one game just one game. I know being a gamer is an expensive hobby, but honestly why does it have to cost so much? I get that games cost more to make then they used to, and that there are many people who need a slice of the game’s sale (retailers, publisher etc.), but can they honestly justify AU$100?
Currently I use my Xbox 360 the most followed by my DS and then lastly my Wii. I don’t own a PlayStation 3 yet, but will by the end of the year. I don’t own any illegal games for any of these consoles, nor are they or ever will be mod chipped. But that doesn’t mean I don’t get why people do it. Games are far too expensive.
Take for example going to the movies. Going to the movies cost AU$15, which I admit is far too expensive, but it manages to cover the cost of the cinema staff, the general upkeep of the place, the equipment used to show the film and the reels of film in the projection room. In fact my AU$15 does all that and then goes towards the films creators who then take their chunk of my money and use it to pay off the films extravagant budget and use the rest as pure profit. All that for just AU$15.
For AU$650 I got an Xbox 360 Premium Pack. To save some money the Australian version didn’t come with a headset, so Microsoft managed to bleed another AU$50 out of me. Then they charged me AU$79.95 to connect to Xbox Live Gold. Then in order for me to actually play something on my console I have to fork out another AU$110 for a game.
The price of the console I understand; I mean I think for all my Xbox 360 does it’s worth the AU$650. Even my Xbox Live Gold account has given me a lot of joy – far more than the AU$79.95 it costs me every year. The headset, which should have been free, has never-the-less proven to be a worthy investment. But honestly, AU$110 for one game? Going back to the movies comparison, I paid AU$15 to see 300, which was a great film that cost $60 million to make. But if I so choose I can put that AU$15 towards buying Lair on PlayStation 3 for AU$100.
Did Lair cost US$60 million to make? I doubt it. Are there more people involved in its creation, distribution and sale? Once again, probably not. But for whatever reason Lair costs more than five times the price of one screening of 300. When a critically panned game like Lair costs AU$100 and a brilliant film like 300 costs AU$15 to see, or AU$30 to own on DVD, you really have to step back and ask yourself if games are worth their price tag. I know games have replay value, but so do DVDs and they’re not overly expensive.
I know games have dropped in price. When I was younger I remember when Sonic The Hedgehog 3 on the Mega Drive came out at AU$140. Even by today’s standards that’s a lot. But does that mean we should just expect to pay so much for games?
My point is that the reason a lot of people pirate games isn’t because they’re bad people, it’s because they love video games and just can’t afford today’s stupid prices. I know it’s not the best justification, but do we really want video gaming to be a super-expensive hobby? Shouldn’t developers and publishers strive to make games as affordable and as accessible as possible?
Moving away from the monetary issue there is another problem with gaming that mod chips have been able to fix – region coding. Raise your hand if you’ve ever asked yourself “why am I still waiting for <insert game> that has been released in <insert foreign country>?”
This is something PAL gamers have asked themselves time and time again. Two of the most recent examples off the top of my head are Rock Band and Smash Bros Brawl. In regards to Rock Band, I get that they have to manufacture the instruments, but once it reaches a point where people in NTSC territories can go to their local game shop and pick up a copy, don’t you think it’s only fair to release a few in other places around the world. I wouldn’t be so mad if we weren’t promised the game and the release date wasn’t jerked around so much (it’s now late May). I get that it’s an expensive game to make, but come on, do I really have to wait this long?
Smash Bros Brawl is even worse. I mean what do they have to do besides change the packaging? Even though Wii consoles are region locked, a PAL Wii can still play NTSC games if the region code is correct. How much could it possibly cost to make enough Smash Bros Brawl covers and game discs for PAL gamers? The cost is in the production of the game, not the media it’s presented on. And I know the whole “oh, but Europe gets Wii Fit first,” but it’s by less than a month and it’ll probably cost more outside of the US than anywhere else in the world. My point is I got my Wii the day it launched and I have a grand total of three games for it, and one of those is Wii Sports. All I want is another game to play on it, so why won't Nintendo give them to me?
My point is that the Xbox 360 has region restrictions, which I admit aren’t enforced on every game, but the Wii is locked down like the consoles of the last generation. I paid AU$400 for my Wii on launch day and AU$650 for my Xbox 360. For that price I should at least be able to play any games I have bought legally from anywhere in the world. But I can’t.
I know a lot of people who don't support mod chips think that pirates hide behind the “we just like to import games” arguement, but if you live in a PAL territory the whole importing thing isn't just an excuse, it's a damn good reason to own a mod chip and in my opinion makes having one entirely justified. Moving beyond my own little world, why on Earth can’t an American gamer import a Japanese game for their Wii? Developers can hide behind the “it’s not optimised for PAL TVs”, which is a bullshit argument these days anyway, but what about other countries like the US that already have NTSC TVs? Huh, smart guy?
Mod chips open your console up to a whole new world of gaming, free from region locking and shitty PAL conversions. Microsoft and Nintendo need to stop being afraid of importing and get with the times, much like Sony. I know that Nintendo are the worst offenders, but big games like the US version of Rock Band are region locked as well as pretty much every Japanese Xbox 360 game, which I know isn’t a huge deal but it’s still pretty stupid.
I should say that I don’t want anyone to think that I’m pro-piracy. I love being a gamer and I want my hobby to survive, but I think the current model is broken. When you pay for a console, say like the PlayStation 3 which launched here in Australia for AU$999 (US$1000+), you shouldn’t then have to pay in excess of AU$100 (US$95) to play one game. If games were significantly cheaper, say AU$50 (US$23), don’t you think they would sell more? Give away the razors and sell them blades.
Imagine if something like BioShock or Saints Row came out at that price don’t you think they would have sold more? I know they were popular games, but at a lower price I believe a heck of a lot more people who may have overlooked these games would have given them a chance.
I know I’m just ranting, and nothing I write can change how much we pay for games. I guess I just wanted to get this off my chest and hear what everyone else thinks. I really do love being a gamer, I mean I just spent the last few hours writing this blog because of my love for games, but I don’t want to keep getting screwed over by game companies and not say anything.
Anyway, if you’ve managed to read my entire 1,300+ words post I’m very grateful and would love to hear your thoughts.
UPDATE: Firstly, thanks to everyone who has responded to my post (even the ones I don't agree with!). And secondly, I should point out that as I stated earlier I'm not "pro-piracy", I just think that gamers (especially PAL gamers) deserve to be treated better by publishers. Keep on truckin' everybody!
I completely agree with you, firstly, as someone from the EU/AU/Anywhere not US or JP, I am constantly screwed over by these game companies, in terms of how much we pay for games, and release dates. To be honest I find it ridiculous. I feel completely justified pirating DS games, since I already have 16 real carts and I only pirate games not released here or coming soon mainly. As for the Wii I think it's good that the freeloader was released beacuse now I don't have to wait months to play Smash Bros, I'll have it in less than a week.
If companies respected out territories then I would respect them, but after 16 years of this it's getting ridiculous IMO.
I wrote something to this effect a few days back. Us Aussies and PAL regions in general get ass raped continually by the games industry. I try and buy second hand where possible and ebay helps. The good thing about the PS3 is it has no region locks for games.
Thanks for the input guys.
@Justice - I don't pirate now, but I had a chipped PS2 which let me experience games I woudldn't have played otherwise... and give Nintendo time, they'll patch the Wii and block Freeloader, fucking us all over again
Wait wait wait wait wait. You support mod chips yet half way through say you don't support them? Confusing argument. I get the point but if you remember the UK pays around the same for game £50 is ~$100US. Don't think your getting especially shafted because it appears to be a high price. However Nintendo are being really stupid with smash bros brawl and most of their other games as per usual. It hasn't changed for 20 odd years why would it change now? You know all the Wii fans are gonna buy it in their millions when it does come out. Until we start boycotting this practise nothing will change.
I like modchips
they let you import games
I live in NZ, so we're in the same boat. Theres few games that my friends and i will buy straight out (being pc gamers, though, its easier to NOT get our hands on games to NOT see if theyre actually worth the money).
Of course, if a developer makes great games and sells them at a fair price (like Valve games, and most stuff on Steam) then we buy them. Generally at least one of us will buy games we enjoy, like Crysis. Heck, i bought Halo 2, it was only $70.
On the other hand, theres Activision. We DONT already have CoD 4, and i really, really want to play it online. However, it costs $88.50 american on steam, for aus/nz only (i think), which is more than we pay retail. Thats $38.50 for being from aus/nz. So fuck Activision. I'll NOT pirate their games until they stop discriminating.
I thought that the UK was bad for the overpricing of games related stuff...
I used to have a HDD for the PS2, where I'd rent games and copy them to it then take the games back....was great.
Remember when game started coming out on Cd's and they said they will be cheaper than Carts? Well we still pay 3 figures per game!! this 20 years later!! I bought Mike Tyson's Punch Out for $100 when I was like 6, and now I buy some other boxing game for the same price! I import any good 360 game that isn't region locked, however Nintendo, whom i love with a passion, always have, always will, can go fuck themselves with their bullshit release dates. I will probably buy the next Nintendo and the one after that, like all the ones before, (i own them all) but i will never play my Wii again. worst $400 i ever spent! And i was at the midnight launch at EB Games. What a waste! BUT, if i mod that bitch, then i just might play that whore again. The point is, Pandabear is absolutely right; Mod chips are go time baby. We should all mod and rape the game companies as much as they rape us. Import for cheaper and cut the profits. Australian gamers have been fucked long enough. Oh and EU gamers? STFU with your "But us too!!" yeah, ok, we get it, you get shafted too, but we hear about it 38 times a fucking day, so give it a rest.
@OP
"My point is that the reason a lot of people pirate games isn’t because they’re bad people, it’s because they love video games and just can’t afford today’s stupid prices. I know it’s not the best justification, but do we really want video gaming to be a super-expensive hobby? Shouldn’t developers and publishers strive to make games as affordable and as accessible as possible?"
If you can't afford your hobby get a new hobby. I love drag racing and Auto-x, but when my car breaks I don't go out and steal cars to get the parts I need.
Developers and publishers have one motivation...Make money. If you're a sucker that drops hundreds of dollars a month on new games then the marketing demons have done their job well.
Don't even get me started on the jackasses that think downloading arcade/console ROMs is "ok".
LOL @ Heretic
I'm from The Netherlands. We have to pay around €67 for a PS3 game. I don't mind. It isn't that much if you look at COD4. I'm still playing it almost every day. I do agree that we get screwed all the time. I'm still waiting for Rock Band for instance. You mod away guys. I'll pay for my games. It feels much better.
@JamnOnTheOne
And what the fuck is wrong with downloading arcade games? It's not like they're still getting a lot of revenue out that one. And there is no way that the company is still getting money for a $50+ copy of Chrono Trigger. Yes, people need money. Yes, pirating is wrong. But christ! It's software! We're in the day and age where that information is just easily accessible. You can't even compare it to other things. I know it doesn't make it anymore right, but the video game market is just way different than the things you compared it to.
Gamers have almost a market of their own, with trading in more and more games. One person buys a new game. That money goes to the company. They sell it to a store for a fraction of the price and another person buys it for a higher price. That money isn't going to the company. That copy was useful to the company moneywise only once. From there on, someone could literally burn that copy (fire, not copying), use it as a decorative device, pass it around to more people for free, sell it for ridiculous profit on eBay, but no matter what you do with it, it no longer matters to the company.
Pirating is not "okay", but it's certainly not the bane of the game industry. If anything, it allows people play things that are extinct marketwise. You go out there and find me a fucking copy of Chrono Trigger for it's original retail price in the fucking box and then we can bitch about ROMs.
STFUAJPG!
Sorry about all that... >_>
I couldn't agree more with Mr. Bear and MissHinasaki. If you mod your system to play imports, there is nothing wrong with that. You are still buying the game, in this case at a price that is actually fair.
@ JamOnTheOne: Stop being such a fucking troll. Just like how the preachers that bitch the most about pr0n and prostitutes are usually the ones in sex scandals, the kids who bitch about emulation are probably the ones with all the ROMs.
Plus ROMs are awesome, they give me the chance to play old games that I never would be able to play otherwise.
I thought that the UK was bad for the overpricing of games related stuff...
I used to have a HDD for the PS2, where I'd rent games and copy them to it then take the games back....was great.
*Ahem*
I checked out our currencies and fount out that 600 NOK (the price Norwegians pay for games) is equal to around 125 AUD.
Think YOU pay alot of money for games?!
600 NOK also equals around 60 GBP and 115 USD.
Also I live on an island town with very few people, so games sold here can cost as much as 700 NOK!
I still have my PS1 which I got chipped many years ago, and it still works like a dream. I have never regretted getting it chipped and if I felt the need, I'd do so again too.
Why? Because I like import games that we never get officially and also because I like to stick it to the console man. Nintendo, Sony etc make a poor excuses for us to not import games.
When things got really fucked up for import gamers, was you when the line between out right piracy and imported games was blurred, and mod chips etc started to let you run burned copies of games. That's when the big crack down came.
Now luckily with the likes of Swap Magic, Freeloader etc, there's less need for mod chips. With this in mind and knowing import gamers are a niche crowd, I believe Sony, Nintendo and even MS, turn a blind eye these days, as its better to get an official sale than a bootleg dvd burn or net downloaded iso.
Now you know why Nintendo don't mind us using Freeloader so much and why they don't mind us importing GC/Wii games.
The situation with handhelds in an interesting one with regards to imports. DS and PSP sales are high, even though both are mod friendly, allowing you to download games illegally.
Even though this happens with them, there's still an arguement that they stimulate sales, the case with Ouendan on DS being a good one.
...I did not know you guys had to pay over $100 for one fucking video game. That's just ridiculous.
Wow, Aussies get raped in the ass with video games prices, considering they pay 70 ASD dollars for a 360 game, and I think 60 bucks USD is wayy to mcuh for a game.
I would totally move to the UK if it weren't for the disturbing game prices.
Thank you for your responses guys. I've read all of them so far and it seems that the majority of people agree that something has to change in gaming.
--
@Projectexodus: Wow, $125 for a game! I feel bad for you... PAL gamers FTL >_<
@JamnOnTheOne: Your comparison is flawed. Drag racing is expensive because manufacturing drag racing parts requires someone to buy expensive materials, produce the parts (which adds labour costs), then ship them and sell at a profit through a retail outlet. On the other hand a game comes on a plastic disc in a cheap case and sells to a much larger audience than drag racing car parts. I don't think you should STEAL games if you can't afford them like stealing car parts you want, but I do think the current prices encourage stealing. Drag racing parts may be expensive but I'm willing to bet you get your money's worth out of them, but the same can't be said for most games on the market. Regarding your arcade ROMS comment -- how are you supposed to play them otherwise? Buy an original cabinet? Look at MissHinaski's comment -- if you've EVER bought a second hand game your hands are as dirty as anyone who downloads a ROM.
@MissHinasaki: I concur. Tracking down a copy of Chrono Trigger in Australia is next to impossible. And even if you can it would cost an insane amount of money. Also I agree that the second hand market is basically pirating - gamers buying games off each other with the creators not seeing a dime. I support it however as it means cheaper games for everyone, but its days are numbered.
(continued below)
(continued from above)
@mgmgarcia01: I don't agree with everything you've said, but I strongly agree about the Wii comment. Mine has been collecting dust for ages. Zelda was disappointing and Wii Sports only comes out at Christmas (but it is incredibly fun)... I think I'd rather a PS3 to a Wii at this point.
--
Another point: Remember when Animal Crossing on the GameCube had over 15 NES game built-in? There's no chance they'd ever be that generous again. How many times do you have to buy Super Mario Bros before it's okay to own a ROM of the original NES game?
I want to make it clear that I don't support piracy and I think that game developers deserve to be paid for their work. But I'm also over getting ripped off by them. I wish a publisher would take a chance and halve the price of a triple-A title and see what happens. They won’t though as these are the same guys who are fighting to take away our right to buy second hand games just so they can screw us even more. Do you really think games will get any cheaper when the only way to obtain them is by downloading them? And you can forget import gaming when that occurs.
I need a drink of cold water and a lie down now.
@
"if you've EVER bought a second hand game your hands are as dirty as anyone who downloads a ROM. "
Not quite...By owning a hard copy of the game (regardless of how I accquired it), I'm licensed to have a rom under the fair use law.
"Regarding your arcade ROMS comment -- how are you supposed to play them otherwise? Buy an original cabinet? "
Yes...I wanted Star Wars: Arcade, so I bought Star Wars arcade. I wanted Final Fight, so I bought a Jamma Cab and a bunch of boards.
@Miss
"If anything, it allows people play things that are extinct marketwise. You go out there and find me a fucking copy of Chrono Trigger for it's original retail price in the fucking box and then we can bitch about ROMs.
STFUAJPG!
Sorry about all that... >_>"
Wrong...It's not extinct, you can still find a hard copy of most everything. Which then entitles you to a ROM under the fair use law.
Why would you expect to pay retail 1990's prices for a highly collectible game that's that old? Video game collecting (which you're talking about since you want the box too) is something that has a high cost of entry.
I'll sell you my copy of Chrono Trigger, mint in box with all instructions and ads for $300 :).
100 dollars... You could buy an african baby with that kind of money. or 3.
Out of curiosity, how bad is a hundred australian relative to the general purchasing power of the populace?
I'm wondering because piracy is a problem in the Philippines, where people definitely pirate games because they don't want to spend as much.
@victor stillwater: It's hard to say... for me though finding a spare $100 can be kinda tricky. I'm a student and a cadet at my part-time job. For some people it's not a lot, but nobody would claim games are cheap here...
@JamnOnTheOne: You're wrong. First your comment about Chrono Trigger's inflated price is baffling - are you saying even though you can still buy it it's legal to download it in ROM form because it's essentially abandonware? Also, ROM sites love to claim fair use, but they are infact illegal and are not subject to the strict definition of fair use. Do some research.