When I see reviews for various video game blogs, news sites, or podcasts, I invariably see comments about how funny the staff is. I don't really care about the humor level of the content, I care about the quality of coverage. I've wasted effort whining from time to time about too many dick and fart jokes, lack of basic journalism tenets, etc on numerous sites. The usual response I get is along the lines of, "Dude, this isn't a serious site. We're here to have fun. Lighten up." That seems more like a defense to me than a justification.
Why are almost all game websites full of snarky, juvenile writers? Why does every picture leached from Google images need a snarky comment attached to it? I'd like to see some serious journalism and industry press. Sometimes, I think video games suffer for breaching into the mainstream in the internet age. Most other popular media has respectable industry press. It's all but nonexistent for video games.
Now, don't get me wrong. I enjoy Destructoid. I've been a regular reader/Podtoid listener for about a year now. There are moments when I gain some real insight or learn some interesting information. But I'd hardly call it a real news site. It's more like an online community for all kinds of random crap that happens to talk about video games often. That's cool. I have no problem with that. But that only scratches one itch. Where would a serious news hound go for hard games industry journalism? Why does it always come with a large helping of sophomoric humor?
No seriously, I want to now. Where do you guys go for that kind of content? I'm not looking down my nose at Destructoid; it's fun. I am looking to compliment it, though. Giant Bomb is probably the other site I frequent the most. Those guys have some great insight into the industry and games as an evolving medium. But all too often, they're posting stupid videos of all the weird crap people send them.
Why aren't there more features like Bonus Round on Game Trailers? I LOVE that show. It's a bunch of adults taking games seriously and having earnest discussions about them without having to resort to crass humor to make sure it all goes over well. As an avid NPR listener and video game enthusiast, I have real trouble finding quality content that lines up with my interests.
Again, there's no need to come to the defense of Destructoid. What they do, they do very well. I'm just looking for something a little different. And I have to wonder, I am the only one alone in my want for serious games coverage?
|
The closest thing I've found to an online news wire for gaming was probably Gamasutra, though I'm sure someone will come in shortly and say it sucks. It really is bare bones information and figures and very little personality, if any, in the stories so if that's your cup of tea you might give it a shot.
The keyword is engaging. A writer that writes how he/she wants - and doesn't get bogged down in a rigid framework imposed by some high and mighty concept of "journalism" - is just more stimulating than some stuffy news report.
It's like the Daily Show. It's chock full of snark and sarcasm, but it's also far more sobering than fucking CNN or FOX News.
I'd rather watch Jon Stewart take the piss out of mainstream media than watch the mainstream media. As such, I'd rather read dtoid's digest of daily news with whatever take they have on it because they're gamers. It's better than a site with a marketing agenda like IGN or Gamespot.
You're not a reader on those kind of sites, you're part of a demographic. So, do you want to be a reader or a data point in a marketing spreadsheet?
This is the only gaming site I go to. Sorry. I tried some of the others, but lord do they suck. Destructoid might not be "hard-hitting" when it comes to gaming news/discussion, but I don't want that. I just don't.
I've been playing video games my entire life, and I've always played them (or talked about them) for one reason. To have FUN. It's kind of like my obsession with The Simpsons. I LOVE the show and have been a faithful viewer since it first aired as shorts on The Tracey Unlman show, but I would never take a college course on it. Shit like that just ruins all the fun.
Me being kind of immature, I prefer less serious reviews... IMO, they're easy to deal with. I kind of find it a weird picture envisioning 3 adults standing at a table, debating on games, like Sports Debaters do at games.
I think that some reviews should be slightly more serious... but after all, if you want something done right, do it yourself.
Nobody'll ever make the perfect gaming reviews for you other than yourself. It'll come close, but never perfect.
RPS + DToid are the only gaming news that I currently consume and they make one hell of a Combo.
Reviews are meant to be opinionated. The trick is finding a reviewer who's gaming habits and mindset closely mirror your own. You can't review games in a purely factual way because their a form of entertainment. It's impossible. Only the technical side can be reviewed in such a manner, the entertainment side of it cannot (or should not anyways).