Earlier today, we ran a front page story regarding a rumored "Xbox 360 name change." The source was a forum posting on the excellent Cheap Ass Gamer forums. As it turns out, the post was part of a contest, one put in place to prove one thing: Gaming blogs (and other outlets) are quick to hop on rumors, and could easily be duped.
We were.
The post was removed in short order, but not with my consent (I am, from what they tell me, the "boss" around here when it comes to editorial). Had I been awake (no, I'm not a robot), I would have suggested the post be updated to clarify the situation. But what's done is done; not a big deal. We jumped on a story fast, and we're not the only ones (see also: Engadget, Kotaku, etc.).
So here's the point: Destructoid is a videogaming blog. All day long we posts news, screenshots, reviews, opinions, and original gaming related features. Being a blog, we operate a bit differently than other types publications, and I'd like think (most of) our readers expect that from us. Our tone is different, our content is different, and -- for the most part -- our readers are different. With that in mind, we also post rumors from various sources. We will always label "rumors" as such, and when applicable, we will follow up with the parties involved to verify or deny said rumor.
The folks at CAG set out to make a point, and they did so in a rather funny way, if I must say. Does this mean that we'll stop posting rumors, or that we won't deliver speculative information without first following up with and exhausting every last resource? No, but when we do post rumors keep something in mind: they are to be taken with a grain of salt. We will never knowingly mislead our readers (i.e. fabricate a rumor for hits or controversy); it's only our intention to deliver gaming-related information to our readers that we feel they'd be interested in hearing about.
So ... how has your morning been?
|
*hugs*
I love you
I like zombies.
My morning's been all right, started out with 5 pieces of French toast :D
I made a funny.
I didn't get a receipt and the clerk but the money in his pocket, but I'm still good right?
What they did is like, treason, or something.
But then, anybody who believed the XBox 360 would change its name is just daft.
but I accept your apology. make up secks plz?
It's early evening here and I just ate an under cooked pizza.
What they did was hilarious. It proves that anyone can make up some random ass rumor and get the attention they're craving. It's pretty sad in my opinion. I mean, the guy did what? Print out a sheet of paper with some words on it and posted some pictures of a few Elites? More research should be done. It's all I'm saying...
<3
Sometimes it bothers me the level of shit that can be summoned over small things online sometimes...
I thought it was quite hilarious how the big K reacted when they found out it was a made-up rumor to teach video game blogs a lesson. It must be lonely up on that hill where the K-Towers are.
I'm going to BAN YOU FROM THE INTERNET!
It's like giving the finger to your advertisers just to make a point because you think they need to learn a lesson. Sure, they might learn the lesson. And now you look like a dumbass that nobody wants to spend time with. Everything has a cost.
As you say I think it is best to come clean and just update the stories rather than bury them and pretend it never happened.
"It appears that this rumor story could be CAG throwing their credibility out the window as part of a contest. In the past CAG has proven to be a reliable site, having broken a number of stories through apt reporting. It appears that may no longer be the case."
I can sum that up as wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
The post was part of a contest which was essentially, "Who can make up some bullshit and have a blog pick up on it first?"
I don't see what the big deal is with posting rumors. I mean, I don't think blogs should just post ANY rumor they hear. But I want to hear rumors, if there's a chance they might be valid. I, however, don't condone Brian Crecente's whiny rebuttal.
These are the people who cry when the weather man says there's rain (SPOILERS) then it doesn't happen (OMG) rumors are just that, rumors.
On the latest CAGCast one of the cohosts (wombat I think?) was talking about how some sites seem to post stuff purely for hits. Then he came up with the contest that CheapyD officially didn't endorse, even though he was supplying the prize (a free game of the winner's choosing that is $60 or less). I almost forgot about it until now. :)
I'll have to go through the CAG forums, to see how many other baiting attempts were made and what they said.
I also love this line from Brian Crecente:
I don't have the time, or the inclination to listen to all of their podcasts to make sure that the stories that run on the site are valid.
Then again, I've been to the site like once and was so repelled by the layout that I never looked at anything other than the front page deals. So my bad in assuming that this had something to do with CAG staff.
You never failing god rock of rock band.
It's not their day at the Kotaku Tower.
My morning and afternoon has been pretty good ^_^
I don't see what's so unbelievable about that rumor. Some prank.
The rumor was that they were renaming the Xbox 360, unless I'm mistaken. That's pretty damn ludicrous.
The rumor was that they were renaming the Xbox 360, unless I'm mistaken. That's pretty damn ludicrous.
I don't feel like D-toid's ever led me astray. News-wise anyway.
I personally think it's pretty funny.
I think you should apologize to Blehman though, that was his internets. He looks pretty torn up over it, his avatar won't stop eating now.
I always take the rumors with a giant chunk of salt, I just hope everyone else has the sense to do so as well.