Quantcast
Destructoid - Matthew Blake's Community Blog




About Me

Gamer Profile
3DS friend code:
Steam:
Battle:
PSN:
Mii:
Gamertag:
Following (98)
13thDragon
Aberrant Thought
AlienGuy18
angusm
Arch649
Arkhon
ArrestedDeveloper
Arttemis
Ashley Davis
Atlas
Benefactor
BFeld13
blehman
Blindfire
braulio09
Brian Szabelski
CblogRecaps
Ckarasu
Clockwork-Zombie
CodenameV
Conrad Zimmerman
Cowboy TTop
Crunshii
Dale North
Danl Haas
Das Inchworm
Dead Movie Star
Def JM
DestructoidArtisans
Detektive7
digweed13
Discarded Couch Sandwich
Electro Lemon
Elsa
flamecondor
FlonneMcNinja
garison
Genki-JAM
Geraldo Beedog
Go Man
gotdurnrite
GuitarAtomik
Hao
Jesus H Christ
Jim Sterling
Justice
king3vbo
Kyle MacGregor
lem
manasteel88
McSnow
MEE
Messer
Mike Moran
Mikey
MiOdd
mix
Moltar
Monodi
Mooks
MrSadistic
Mushman
NCHammer326
Niero
ParaParaKing
Passionate Styos
Pints of Two
PurpmaN
Reeper
Respectable Gentleman
Rifter01
riomccarthy
RonBurgandy2010
ryu89
snoogans775
Spartacus
swiftkaratechop
Takeshi
Tanukitsune
taumpytears
Teta
The Bez
The GHost
TheDreadHawk
TheWaffleKing
Tiff
topgeargorilla
Topher Cantler
Triphoppin
Tubatic
Tug Your God Out
vexed alex
welkstar
Wexx
xX SnipeR Xx
Y0j1mb0
Zombutler
The Portal Experiment (Or, My Parents Suck at Games)
Matthew Blake | 12:05 PM on 07.31.2008 16 comments


WARNING: Long-ass post is long, and hopefully not ass. No pics yet for you TL;DR types, so keep that in
mind.

I am the only gamer in my family. It is a sad truth, but one that I live with. My mother grew up on a farm
without them, and my father sold his SNES before I was born (why?!). My sister... well, she used to fight with
me for the Gameboy (the original, chunky and white) so she could play Super Mario Land and Tetris.
Somewhere along the way, she decided that games were a waste of her time- and now she's planning on a
career in broadcast journalism. God help me if she ends up at Fox News...

So, throughout my childhood and beyond, I have tried my hardest to educate my parents about the variety of
games that exist and the benefits of such. The problem was that although they would smile and nod every
time I ecstatically rambled about the latest game I had picked up, they were (and still are) reluctant to actually
play them with me.

Only a handful of times have I been able to get them to sit down and stick the controller in their hands.
Granted, my choices of games were not always the best; WarioWare, for instance. "It's only two buttons," I
told them. "You'll be fine, as long as you read the directions." Unfortunately, even at its slowest stages, the
game's text zoomed by far too quickly for them to comprehend, and as soon as they put their hands in the
proper position, the challenge was over.

"What happened? What was I supposed to do?"
"Didn't you read the directions?"
"What directions?"

Mario Party was also a disaster. Although my parents were able to move their characters around the board
(though I had to remind them which ones they had picked), the minigames once again frustrated them. The
constantly changing control scheme baffled them, and combined with their issues with their avatars ("Which
one's mine again?"), the games ended in a ludicrous fashion.

However, there is hope. My mother now knows who Jack Thompson is, although she thinks I'm making too
big of a deal out of it. I was able to spend some time with my father on Super Mario Galaxy, trying to help him
as he hopped about on the planetoids. Due to pressure from my relatives, I've been able to get my mother to
play Guitar Hero (even if it was on Easy with the No Fail cheat turned on). I felt like I was making some
genuine progress.

And then came Portal.

It was rather simple, at first; when my parents asked what I wanted for my birthday, I told them I wanted The
Orange Box. Before my parents bought my sister and I a Gameboy, the PC was the major source of our
electronic entertainment. However, we had never owned a high-end computer, leaving me to find enjoyment
in point and click adventure games, from Spy Fox in Dry Cereal all the way up to The Dig and Grim
Fandango. My cousin gave me their old Playstation when they bought a PS2, and I instantly converted to
console gaming.

Jump forward to 2007, where I hear about this new-fangled box Valve is going to release. I had heard a lot of
good things about Half-Life 2, was excited by Team Fortress 2 and its art style (colors! Dear God and
Mudkips, there are colors in this game!), and was deeply intrigued by Portal. About a week after the game
comes out, I decide I need to upgrade my PC just so I can find out what the hell is up with the cake and why
it's a lie.

I seem to have a strange sense of, well, I suppose you could call it karma when it comes to games; I end up
having to give up something else in order to receive it. When I camped out for the Wii in 2005, my cell phone
mysteriously fell out of my pocket as I stepped out of my father's car. As soon as he pulled forward, we both
heard a sickening 'crunch'. It turns out the phone was split cleanly in half by the car, with no hope of repairing
it. After skipping four or five stores jam-packed with people, we ended up at a Toys'R'Us, number twenty-
three in line. There were exactly twenty-five Wiis.

In any case, the gaming gods decided that I was not going to get my Orange Box that easily. After taking the
time out to research a graphics card (I remember you guys giving me some suggestions, back when I was
still new to the forum), we installed the card- and our monitor died. Not just died, but turned an acidic green
and pink, and then died. We've also had to replace our mouse, the speakers, and, strangely enough, our
toilets. All of them.

After much struggling, we finally have order restored to our house. I plowed through Half-Life 2 and the
episodes and tried my best as a Medic on TF2, but kept coming back to Portal. If you haven't played it
through with the Developer's Commentary, I would highly recommend doing so. Hearing the guys at Valve
talk about all of the design tricks they used to make the game work is absolutely fascinating. As I heard them
describe Portal as 'one long tutorial', I began to think to myself: Sure I found it intuitive, but what about
someone else? What about someone who had never played a first-person game before?

And so began the experiment.

The experiment was deceptively simple: Get my family to play Portal. My goal was to observe how a non-
gamer handled a relatively easy and so-called 'intuitive' video game. If Valve was as brilliant as I assumed
they were (and still do), their clever usage of shape, light, and bright yellow tip boxes would be enough to help
anyone- anyone- through one of their games.

I began the experiment with my father, a relatively tech-savvy man. It took me quite a while, though I
eventually convinced him- after all, wouldn't he want to see what he had bought all of that new equipment for?
(Before someone calls me a spoiled rotten child, please know that it was his idea to buy those things for the
family computer, not me.) At last, I managed to get him to play. The following is a rough transcript of what
followed:

"Okay now, to play the game, you need to have one hand on the mouse and one on the W,A,S, and D keys,
like this."

"Okay..." (He puts his hand on the wrong keys. I scoot them over.)

"Okay, the game's loaded up. Your mouse button doesn't do anything yet, you don't need to click."

"All right, then." (Keeps clicking. Stays in the same spot. GLaDDOS' voice comes on)

"Pay attention to her. She's important to the story...You know you can move
around, right?" (My father pushes one of the arrow keys. His character zips off sideways.) "Hey, why don't
you try looking around?"

"Why would I want to do that?"

"Well, don't you want to see where you are?" (My father turns around, looks at the bed, and starts clicking
the mouse button again.) "Dad, the mouse button doesn't do anything yet- you interact with stuff with the E
key."

(GLaDDOS' first clip is done. The portal opens up behind my dad. He doesn't notice it; he's too busy clicking
on the toilet.)

"Hey, dad, did you see that?"

"See what?"

"Well, turn around." (He slowly moves the mouse to rotate the character.) "What's that?"

"It's a portal. You can walk through it."

"Why would I want to do that?"

"...Just do it." (My father begins walking toward the portal. Through the portal, you can see yourself from
outside the containment cell you begin the game in- a neat trick Valve used to get the player to recognize
themselves.) "Hey, stop for a second. Look at that girl there."

"Oh, yeah? Who's that?"

"That's you." (I move her back and forth to prove it.)

"What?"

"That's your character in-game."

"Why do I look like that?"

"Well, you were being held in a containment cell, so-"

"Why am I a girl?"

"Because Valve wanted the player character to be a girl-"

"-I don't wanna be a girl!"

"Too bad."

(My father grumbles, and sidesteps his way into the first puzzle. In this first room, there is a cube of the non-
companion variety, a door, and a button with a big blue line running from it to the door. Another little yellow
box to remind the player that he can pick up objects with the E button. My father walks over to the door and
tries to walk through it. He starts clicking on it in frustration.)

"Dad, you can't just click on stuff. Look, see the little yellow box? You can interact with stuff like this."

"Why isn't the door opening?"


"It's a puzzle, dad. You have to figure out how to open it."

(My dad grumbles again, and notices the big red button. He walks over to it, and steps on it. He hears the
door whoosh open, and turns around. He sees the door open, and begins walking towards it. As soon as he
steps off the switch, the door naturally closes. My dad sits and thinks for a bit, then steps back on the switch.
He tries to run for the door before it closes, but alas, he's not quick enough.)

"Dad, you can't go that way. You'll have to try something else." (I point to the cube.) "Do you see that, over
there?"

"What, the box?"

"Yeah. You could use that for something."

(He walks over to the cube, and starts clicking on it. I sigh, and point to the helpful reminder.)

"Look!"

"...What?"

"You interact with stuff with that button!"

"...Oh."

It took him several tries, but he eventually got the cube on the switch. He completed a couple of the other
levels, but the same conversations repeated themselves over and again. Perhaps it was because he wasn't
really interested in playing the game, but good grief, it was worse than herding cats. Even so, he was able to
get the actual portal gun (but not with the orange portal) with marginally less direction from me; I was so
proud of him! It was then that he decided his lesson was done. With a great yawn, he announced he was
done, and heading off to bed. Nevertheless, I will continue nagging him to try and finish the rest of the game.
He, and my mother as well, will be getting an education on this new art from, whether they like it or not.



Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

0



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

13 comments | showing # 1 to 13
prev next

Usedtabe's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 12:44
Usedtabe
Nice write up. Over the holidays last year, my parents loved Rock Band. Suprisingly, they thought the Wii was stupid. I tried to get my mom to play Portal, as she loves puzzle games, but it confused the hell out of her. Unfortunately, I live far away from them, so I won't be able to educate them like you willl your parents.
ryu89's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 12:53
ryu89
I laughed at your father's reluctance to play as a girl. I hope you intend to continue these write ups as your experiment progresses, i enjoyed reading it. It's always good to see someone trying to get an older generation into video games. I'd love to try to get my parents to play a game like portal, but i can barely explain attachine files to an email to my mother, so I know it would just be an excercise in frustration for me. Anyways, hope to see more soon.
blehman's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 12:55
blehman
HAHAH. Nice. Yeah, even getting some of my game knowledgable friends to play Portal took some effort. Or through portal more likely. My non-gamer friend saw me playing it and won't play it now because just watching me confused the shit out of him.
pendelton21's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 12:57
pendelton21
Hearding cats is easy, as long as you have the right tuna.
vexed alex's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 13:04
vexed alex
Hahahaha!

This is amazing. Great post, man.
Pixel Blue's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 13:24
Pixel Blue
I've found that non-gamers tend to have a really, really hard time navigating in a first person 3D view for some reason. you'd think it would be easiest that way, but give them a top-down 2D game and they'll get into it way faster.
TrailerParkJesus's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 14:11
TrailerParkJesus
Funny stuff. Your dad sounds like he might be better off in point n click adventures though. (If you mentioned that, I'm sorry I skimmed lol)
Excel-2011's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 14:34
Excel-2011
I cannot wait to see what he does when he finally gets to the furnace.
bilobatedtimmo's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 14:50
bilobatedtimmo
I never have the patience to try to teach my parents to play games. Me and my dad tried playing Halo 2 a few times and he just kept asking where I was, and couldn't find his way around. And I would always go back and walk him through, and tell him to look at the radar to see where I was and such, but I just so frustrated and stopped trying.
adultswim810's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 15:10
adultswim810
when i first got the wii i played my dad in redsteel multiplayer. We practically cried laughing at how inept he was at the game! I would just hit him with the stun sword then run and he'd yell and spin in circles while shooting everywhere! needless to say it was freakin awesome.
Timmeh's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 18:07
Timmeh
My dad has his own 360 and lets me borrow his games. Sux2byou. When I look back at games I got as presents for older systems I also realise that a)they used to be things he was interested in and b) they were open or I didn't see them for a while after receiving it. Lol.

Unfortunately, if someone isn't interested no amount of instruction is going to help. If people don't want to play games there is absolutely nothing you can do except let them sit and watch if they want to, and have curiosity eventually get the better of them.

It's very much living proof of the saying "You can take a horse to water, but you can't make it drink".
Brian Szabelski's Avatar - Comment posted on 07/31/2008 19:12
Brian Szabelski
This is only proff that actually getting those new gamers to latch on to deep, substantive gaming is going to be really, really hard.
Darren Nakamura's Avatar - Comment posted on 08/03/2008 19:15
Darren Nakamura
I think the main issue is one I've had previously trying to teach a non-gamer girl to play Counter-Strike. Gamers take it for granted, but the standard FPS move-with-one-hand-and-look-with-the-other control scheme is difficult to learn for somebody completely new to it.

And as demonstrated in your story, gamers are used to E being the "use" key, whereas non-gamers are more used to only ever using the mouse buttons. Perhaps you could rearrange his control setup so clicking is the use button, but I would imagine once he gets time with the Portal gun, he'll understand why the mouse buttons are set the way they are by default.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!