I totally agree,everyone is supposed to be happy our decisions meant nothing and the ending explained nothing?
I don't see complaining about that as being unreasonable.
I don't see complaining about that as being unreasonable.
It makes a lot more sense when you dedicate a blog to it. My suggestion to take it out of the comment box was not a plea for silence; you addressed your points much better this way, and actually, you do make a good point.
Still didn't really jive with the food analogy because they are so distant from one another as far as products go, and I don't agree the game should be retroactively changed in the same way that you might return a steak, but after thinking about it more, I think some kind of "directors cut" DLC offering an alternate take on the ending might be an appropriate move, and one that would benefit both the end user and Bioware.
Of course, the problem with that as you have said is the amount of money many have invested in the series. I can at least empathize with how bummed out it can make you when something you had high expectations for doesn't live up to them.
Good blog all around.
Still didn't really jive with the food analogy because they are so distant from one another as far as products go, and I don't agree the game should be retroactively changed in the same way that you might return a steak, but after thinking about it more, I think some kind of "directors cut" DLC offering an alternate take on the ending might be an appropriate move, and one that would benefit both the end user and Bioware.
Of course, the problem with that as you have said is the amount of money many have invested in the series. I can at least empathize with how bummed out it can make you when something you had high expectations for doesn't live up to them.
Good blog all around.
Thanks Manchild, my apologies from my previous comments, I was majorly stressed from some personal issues.
Meh no worries, I didn't take it personal, and I offer you the same apology. By the end I just kind of thought we were jerking eachother around.
Hope nothing to serious is going on, take care.
Hope nothing to serious is going on, take care.
Nope. I still don't think people are owed a new ending. There's a very good Forbes article on why BioWare screwed up from a business perspective by pissing off fans. It just doesn't make good business sense to create things people hate, especially in this climate of DLC packs dropping left and right. Your analogy of the restaurant makes sense in that regard. I also totally agree fans are within their right to bitch and complain to their hearts' content. I even agree that it's ok to let BioWare know you're pissed because feedback could improve future games. However, "I paid for it so fix it" just doesn't work. The Retake Mass Effect supporters are in no position to demand someone change something that he/she created. These things cost millions to produce. It's not a steak you can just send back and have the chef whip you up a new one in 15 minutes. It wasn't made to your order in the first place. Games are a product, not a service, and when artistic decisions don't jell with your expectations you can't just say "give me one I like more." This sorta reminds me of those people who went to see The Artist and sued because it was a silent B&W movie.
As far as the paying thing I think that's just bad for the industry. DLC is already out of hand (especially with this game in particular) and fans screaming that they'll pay for a new ending sends the wrong message to EA and BioWare. What if they do it, make a killing and start a nasty trend?
As far as the paying thing I think that's just bad for the industry. DLC is already out of hand (especially with this game in particular) and fans screaming that they'll pay for a new ending sends the wrong message to EA and BioWare. What if they do it, make a killing and start a nasty trend?
It's been a while since you've written a blog man - nice work! I mostly agree actually. I think that complaints are always good, even if sometimes they get a bit annoying. Valid complaints (which, when referring to the massive plotholes with ME3's ending) are what drives the industry forward - and I agree complacency is a bad thing.
@Kidplus
I believe The Artist was sued for false advertising because the trailer made it seem like a "talkie" (haha that's so weird to type). Just like Drive was sued because the trailer made it seem like a driving movie instead of an art-house action film.
I don't agree with it, but it's similar to the really old Call of Duty adds that showed no gameplay, but people were pissed that it didn't look like the FMV.
@Kidplus
I believe The Artist was sued for false advertising because the trailer made it seem like a "talkie" (haha that's so weird to type). Just like Drive was sued because the trailer made it seem like a driving movie instead of an art-house action film.
I don't agree with it, but it's similar to the really old Call of Duty adds that showed no gameplay, but people were pissed that it didn't look like the FMV.
Nicely written blog (and not as cranky as some of your comments were lately... though the personal issues explains a lot... we all go through days like that!)
I haven't played Mass Effect 3 but I'd like to know - is the ending genuinely bad, or do people want a more fairy tale ending? cos there's a difference between a good ending and a happy ending, likewise sad endings are not always bad endings. Heck, even ambiguous endings can be good. They say nothing gets explained and the choices are meaningless but arguably any choices you make at the end of Mass Effect 3 will be meaningless in comparison to earlier choices because you won't have another game afterwards to see the choices play out, and also because if shepherd dies (which I guess he does) then that also ends the player's direct involvement with the universe, so you can't have say hours of cutscenes afterwards metal gear solid style.
Also I find it a little strange that the homogenisation of the gaming industry is so constantly bemoaned by fans, yet they want to change the ending of a game to suit a popular consensus.
Also I find it a little strange that the homogenisation of the gaming industry is so constantly bemoaned by fans, yet they want to change the ending of a game to suit a popular consensus.

surf dtoid with 

Rising (10+)
People you follow


send message
follow
followers





