Quantcast
Destructoid - Jidai Geki's Community Blog



About Me
Gamer Profile
3DS friend code:
Steam:
Battle:
PSN:
Mii:
Gamertag: Jidai Geki
Following (3)
CALkulon
hbl
Stephen Beirne
Sexism in gaming
Jidai Geki | 11:05 PM on 03.14.2009 7 comments




Almost all gamers have heard of the lamentable Custer's Revenge, a title that, had the videogame industry been more high-profile at the time, and had Jack Thompson been on his little crusade, could quite possibly have singlehandedly led to the fall of the industry at the hands of society's self-proclaimed moral guardians.

I've never played it myself, but I'm familiar with the premise, as I'm sure most are: dodge arrows fired at you by those damn Red Injuns, make your way across the screen, and rape the shit out of an Indian (*ahem*, I mean "Native American") woman named, appropriately enough, 'Revenge'.

The game features the finest pixellated naked people to come out of the videogame industry in 1982, complete with grotesquely caricatured naughty parts for both the eponymous Custer and his rapee, Revenge.

Putting aside the (obviously) objectionable and tasteless issue of a game where rape is the objective, two things spring to mind about this title. Firstly, it represents a trend in gaming that continues to this day, that of objectifying women across the board and making them little more than shapely sperm receptacles, sometimes for the gamer's character (Conan and God of War spring to mind) and sometimes for the gamer himself (yes, I'm making an assumption here, but they don't put Lara Croft and Bloodrayne in games to satisfy the female demographic).

Secondly, Custer's Revenge sold 80,000 copies, twice as many as any other game released by developer Mystique. This tells us something that we already knew about the gaming industry, like many other industries; sex sells. And I'm not disputing or lamenting this, it's a fact of life.

What I am lamenting is that it's an across-the-board phenomenon for essentially the entire industry, with almost no exceptions. The movie industry as a whole has the pornography sub-industry, as well as a slew of pseudo-pornographic titles featuring the fine 'acting' talents of such women as Holly Valance and Jennifer Love Hewitt, and the music industry has Britney Spears and T.A.T.U.

But those industries also gave us Citizen Kane and The Godfather, the Beatles and Elvis Presley. There's a world of difference between Debbie Does Dallas and any of Scorsese's back-catalogue.

This is a point we haven't yet reached in the (admittedly, still fairly nascent) gaming world. Onechanabra was recently released to Western gamers, and a million teenagers are probably excitedly murdering hordes of nondescript enemies with their scantily clad 'ninja babes' right now. Tecmo's DOA franchise has gone from using its female characters' assets as a selling point to their fighting game, to simply dropping the fighting bit altogether and concentrating on the girls with the Extreme spin-off series.

I struggle to think of a woman in a videogame portrayed as anything other than a buxom/leggy vixen who's good with her fists or a sword/gun. Sometimes they're given a little character: Lara Croft occasionally imparts some wry, innuendo-laced witticism, as if her upper-crust English accent somehow lends intellectual weight to the fact that she's essentially limber eye-candy. Meryl's character development in Metal Gear Solid was excellent, what with her blushing if you stared at her breasts and needing a big strong man to rescue her during the title's endgame.

There's the odd deviation, of course. KOTOR II's Kreia was a poor man's Yoda, albeit (spoiler warning!) a bit more evil. And- gasp!- not even a little sexy. GTA IV is the bravest any developer has got, as far as I can remember, with its porky Queen-Latifah-wannabe gangster queen, Elizabeta.

Don't get me wrong- I'm not saying that we should outlaw gorgeous women from games, and I'm not saying that developers should adopt an 'ugly women' affirmative-action policy where they have to put a certain number of fat/ugly chicks in their games. Hell, I'm sure like most men that if I'm playing Tomb Raider, I'd rather be playing as Lara Croft and not Roseanne Barr.

I'm not trying to come across (and I realise that I might have done) as some sort of prudish, holier-than-thou 'deep' gamer. I enjoy the pixellated eye-candy as much as the next guy. I'm just saying that an industry that's come so far so fast should perhaps consider maturing a little insofar as its perception and portrayal of women is concerned. There should be more to the market than ninja babes and impossibly hot archaeologists.



Attached photos:

Photo

Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

0



Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

6 comments | showing # 1 to 6
prev next

HydroTonix's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/15/2009 00:50
HydroTonix
I like sexx.
Tubatic's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/15/2009 01:09
Tubatic
Word.

I would like to see more just average female roles in games. Lucca in Chrono Trigger comes to mind. The game isn't about sexuality, but Lucca is afford both character design and story that remove her from the burden of being objectified, I feel.

I like that you mentioned Elizabeta. They fleshed out her character a bit in The Lost and The Damned. She spends a little more intimate, (conversational, not sexual) time with Johnny than she did with Nico. She now exists in my mind, as less of a shallow "bad ass bitch" type character than standard IV would have you think she is.

Also, I think create-a-character female characters are playing a good part with regards to this also. Females implanted as your narrative protagonist have the potential to present a more functional female role than that of AAA title female roles.
Infinitestrike's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/15/2009 04:21
Infinitestrike
I thought Chelle in Portal was a good female character as well, with bed hair and an orange jumpsuit that wasn't there to show her curves off. She was pretty "normal", just someone in the wrong place at the wrong time-(I'm thinking of the take your daughters to work day theory.)- and wants to get the heck out of that facility.
masterninja's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/15/2009 08:23
masterninja
I think they do put lara croft in it also for the female demographic...

I'm not saying they forgot about us guys but a strong female character tends to draw in female gamers as well as us guys.They also give girl gamers a connection they would never feel with videogames otherwise.

The point of only females in games being seen only as sex objects is invalid by many reasons like The Duke or any other male character that walks around with the average body building appearance.

Did they put those characters in for us guys yess because we would all wanna be the action hero...Doesn't make the appearance less or more wrong then that of lara croft.

Isn't It a subconscious form of sexism that you actually feel you need to protect the female gender from their videogame status as being eyecandy for us guys?

Nobody feels the need to do that for us guys by the portrayal of male characters, why because we would all laugh and say who cares.The fact one could feel women in games are portrayed the wrong way is sexism by itself because you would also have to bring up male characters seeing as they are no different.

Latest example of my point Chris Redfield the dude looks so pumped full of steroids and basically has the depth of an 80's action hero..
Do we as the male gender all suddenly feel the injustice of it all because we don't look like that and we have more depth in our personality?

I think I'm gonna end my rant cause I'm really tired of people bringing up sexism in games and focusing their point completely on female characters...
If your gonna bring It up do It right and don't discriminate because if you do then your basically doing more harm then good for your argument.
Jidai Geki's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/16/2009 02:00
Jidai Geki
I was actually considering talking about male roles in gaming too, but this article was already overly long and frankly, it isn't as valid a point.

Yes, you've got your stereotypical men like Chris Redfield and Duke Nukem in games, but you've also got Niko Bellic, Ethan Thomas, and Kane & Lynch. The industry treats men with far more depth and variety than it does women.

If you read what I wrote, you'll see that my problem is not that sexy women exist in gaming, but that ONLY sexy women exist. Of course there are stereotypical beefcakes; there are stereotypes in every industry. There's a reason stereotypes exist.

My point, and I think you completely missed it, is not that women need 'protecting' (I honestly don't give a shit if women are offended by it or not) but that the industry should be emotionally and creatively mature enough by now not to be portraying women simply as sex objects. It's not about anyone getting offended, it's about gaming as a medium becoming something that can rival the movie industry. And it will never do that as long as it comes across as being a haven for horny fifteen year-olds jerking off because ZOMG U CAN SEE CHUN LIS PANTIES!!11
masterninja's Avatar - Comment posted on 03/16/2009 07:55
masterninja
Oww ok now I understand your point a little more but still there is alot more diversity In females these days it has definitely come a long way.
I think we are allways gonna have sexy ladies in gaming the thing that might be wrong is when they lack depth. But not all studios have the talent behind them to give their characters the depth of say solid snake.

I would say lara croft walks a good line though sexy enough to attract the teen guy audience but deep enough for the rest to enjoy her stories being told.

But for the record any 15 year old jerking off to chun li is doing it wrong...cause isn't that what cammy is for...
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!