Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by JenSev | JenSev's ProfileDestructoid
JenSev's Profile - Destructoid

DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist





About
Dutch guy. Gamer (obviously duh). Philosophy, History and arts student. 33 years old. Avid reader. Highly intelligent and completely insane.
Headbanger!



I am. I am, I exist, I think, therefore I am; I am because I think, why do I think? I don't want to think any more, I am because I think that I don't want to be, I think that I . . . because . . . ugh! Jean-Paul Sartre - Nausea

Take a trip inside, take a trip inside
To my precious lunatic asylum
Welcome, enter the house of hell
My precious lunatic asylum
You can get anything you need
At the precious lunatic asylum
Hang on as we take the ride
Into the precious lunatic asylum

Annihilator - My Precious Lunatic Asylum
Player Profile
Xbox LIVE:Gen7even
Steam ID:undertowstudios
Follow me:
Twitter:@Jen_Seven
Facebook:Link
JenSev's sites
Badges
Following (5)  


Hello again everyone.
Yes, again with a downer and again with the XboxOne.

As we all know the XboxOne did a 180 on their DRM policies, however some things are pretty vague and missing from the announcement.

Let me start with things that are clear.
Region locking is gone.
The fact that the XboxOne shuts down the console part of being a game console after not getting on the internet for more than 24 hours is gone.

That's all clear, now lets see what things are strange.

"An internet connection will not be required to play offline Xbox One games"
The problem with this is what exactly Microsoft considers "offline games". Titanfall is a pure multiplayer game, so that is certainly not an offline game.
But what about games with online components, such as competitive multiplayer? Even if you don't want to play the multiplayer part of the game it could be that that game will not be considered an offline game. This could mean that more and more games will have crappy tacked on multiplayer so that Microsoft can force us online.

Also that brings up another part of the problem here.
When Microsoft announced they would use the "infinite power of the cloud" to enhance the gaming experience, what could that mean?
Now that the mandatory internet is cut off, would that mean that the cloud was just a load of hot air since the games obviously didn't need it?
Or is the cloud power now being used to brand single player games as needing an online component to "access the cloud" and again making them not offline games again?

Second point:
No mention was made of Xbox Live. Would signing onto Xbox Live do something? Would that make the new Xbox into the mandatory online Xbox again? What limitations does connection to Xbox Live have?
There was no mention of this, so we don't know. Although we can probably assume the worst.

Third point:
Second hand games will work as they do today.
Today second hand games work with Online Passes in most cases.
Does Microsoft mean this? I wouldn't put it past them to pull this old joke again under a different name.

So yeah, it may not be the outcome you expected.
I hope I am wrong, but I kinda expect I will be proven right.
Thanks for reading.

Edit, got into an argument with Stephen Toulouse just now.
Here are the results:
Photo








As we all have been following the news surrounding this massive failure there is a part that I haven't heard and it's a nightmare scenario.

Let's examine the facts.

1. The XboxOne needs to phone home once every 24 hours.
This in itself is already pretty bad.
2. If it can't phone home it will shut down the whole game part of being a game console and just be a blue ray player with a motion controlled remote.
3. Behind all this are Microsoft authentication servers, who will verify the phone home and allow it to continue to be a game console.
4. A new Xbox is already planned.


Let's combine all this into the worst case scenario.
When Microsoft releases their next console what will happen to all of those authentication servers?
Will Microsoft simply shut them all down when the new Xbox launches, forcing people who want to continue to play games to buy that new console (or understandably buy one from a different maker). Within 24 hours after Microsoft pulls that plug every single XboxOne will become nothing more than a Blue Ray player.

While this seems far fetched and completely idiotic, we need to remember that the XboxOne can only function when it has had that authentication signal with a server.
It's also completely conceivable and understandable that Microsoft isn't going to continue running those servers.
So they will choose the optimal time to pull the plug on them, and this will mean that people will never again be able to use their XboxOne as anything other than a blue ray player.

This is very sad and very frightening.
What if they choose to do it when a good amount of people are still using it and Microsoft considers that to not be a problem?
Can we entrust people like that to dictate what we do with our own property?
Is the console itself the "service" Microsoft is talking about.
Is the game console functioning as a game console a "service"?

I'll just leave you with those thoughts.
I hope you didn't preorder one.

EDIT:
An even worse part occurred to me.
What if maintenance or hacking brought down the authentication servers for a few days. If those are brought down, the authentication cannot happen and the XboxOne will shut down.
If this could last for more than 24 hours, every single XboxOne on the planet will be unusable.
This then truly means that the console itself is a service, gaming is done by the grace of Microsoft and their ability to keep their servers running and don't anger any hackers.
This is a very scary idea and for this reason alone the XboxOne should be avoided if not legally scrutinised.