games  anime  |  toys
This is a Dtoid readers's blog. For staff blogs click here. Confused? read this Create you own!  |   Members: Login now





Talk to me... about controller confusion!
Elsa | 12:52 PM on 09.23.2009 34 comments




Elsa sneaks up and grabs the flag... she's running with two enemies following close on her heels firing at her. She sees the tank up ahead and runs toward it - instant cover and protection! It's only a few feet away now... she runs up to it... and squats beside it. WTF? Is she taking a pee break or something? Why the hell didn't she just get in the tank?

No... I did not mean to squat beside the tank, I pressed the button to get into a vehicle... for the wrong game! My name is Elsa and I have a problem. I play too many games and have OCD... Over-gaming Controller Dementia.

So much of gaming is automatic, once we get used to the controls we often don't even think about the buttons we are pushing to achieve the action... until we push the wrong button and instead of jumping, we throw a grenade at our feet to commit a spectacular suicide. There isn't even any standardized controller configuration... while most games use R1 to shoot, every once in awhile some game comes along and decides to use R2 just to screw with you. The other day I accidentally loaded up a game using my husband's ID... and suddenly I was in a game using switch sticks with an inverted view. I quite literally could not play the game. My lil avatar was running into walls while looking at the sky or his feet and doing pirouettes... it was like being a drunk epileptic trying to do microsurgery.

With the abilities of current gen games where we can customize our avatars with different heads, voices, outfits and even facial scars... why does every game not have ingame controller customization? Why don't more developers allow for button remapping? Resistance 1 and UT3 both had this capability, why can't every game include a comprehensive controller configuration menu? Why doesn't Sony buy this code and give it away free to every developer rather than spending money making more pick-up bar emulator locations for Home? In fact, why isn't a controller remapping widget not built directly into the console operating system? Just as we can access the XMB to change our headset volumes and configurations, why can't we access a controller remapping system that retains the configuration for each game? The very basics of gaming is the input controls... why don't console developers work to create a way for the users to create their own customized and comfortable control inputs?

Many of us are old enough that gaming controllers essentially worked like this:


Nowadays, the L2 and R2 triggers work as "alt" controls for the entire controller... essentially creating a controller like this:


When new gamers take up gaming nowadays, the learning curve is much more difficult... this is exacerbated when games don't give controller options but instead give a "standardized" configuration that the user has to adjust to. If third parties like Splitfish can create the Frag FX controller that has remappable controls, then why can't console developers create their own 1st party controller remapping systems? Why should I have to adjust each time... why can't games adjust to me? Isn't this the "next generation" of gaming?

I'll be honest, there are games I didn't buy because I hated the controls. Resident Evil 5 was one of those games. Yes, I probably would have adjusted to the controls, but in this day and age, why should I adjust to awkward controls? There are other games where I tried the demo and specifically bought the game because the controls felt natural. Bioshock was one such game. Battlefield:Bad Company was a rental... because it didn't have a southpaw control scheme for my husband, so I knew it wouldn't be a game that he would play or that we could play together online - otherwise they might have sold two copies of the game.

The basics to most any online game nowadays are the controls... and voice chat. This is another area where the PS3 seems moronically inconsistent. How does a game like Battlefield 1943 manage to pass any type of quality control process when voice chat consistently fails after a game or two? How does a game like Sacred 2 manage to be released with "4 person co-op play" when the person creating the co-op game loses voice chat the minute there are more than 2 people in the room? I think that one of the reasons for the commercial failure of UT3 was the lack of voice support. For the first several months after the game was released the developer refused to believe that voice support was even problematic despite the numerous complaints... the fix simply came too late. Again, why isn't there either standard programming for voice chat that is freely given to all PS3 developers or alternatively an operating system option for voice chat that works in all games?

The PS3 is an amazing piece of electronics... you can watch blu-ray movies, you can download movies, you can watch movies from a flash drive, you can voice/video chat, you can play music, do a slide show, you can game online for free and can even opt to inhabit the second-life world of Home... but it seems that the actual function of gaming is not as fully supported as other aspects. Why can't every game have reliable voice chat and customizable controls?

These two fairly minor issues... but they continue to piss me off! :(



Attached photos:

Photo Photo Photo

  related blogs:
 

Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

11

Those who have fapped:  Anonymouse  

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

33 comments | showing # 1 to 33

prev next

SilverDragon1979's Destructoid Blog
Elsa, I'm gonna get flack for saying this from a lot of people, but if you owned an XBOX 360 you wouldn't have these types of problems with voice chat being inconsistant from game to game. While you might have to pay for Microsoft's overpriced online network, at least you get good quality from certain features, and voice chat is one of those high quality features. Some people will argue that it doesn't matter, because on XBOX Live you have to listen to a bunch of whiny teenagers act like assholes, but I'll argue all day that you hear the same shit on the PSN now as well.

As for the controller issue, it does unfortunately suck that a lot of games don't allow you to remap the controller buttons. I agree that it makes switching from one game to the next very difficult. To get around this I try to stick to only playing one game at a time, and when I'm done I move onto the next. The other way to get around this is to play PC games, where 99% of the games allow you to remap the controls.

I guess you just can't win can you Elsa? Since you know that, get to making me a sandwich woman!
kauza's Destructoid Blog
Yeah, I feel like there should be some sort of standardized control scheme for FPS games, which would make adjusting to a game's particular button mapping a non-issue. Of course, this is a problem with games that have different functions unique to the game, so we'll probably never see this. But dammit people, some of the button choices are just silly, and it's made a lot worse when you don't give us options to change it.
Elsa's Destructoid Blog
Silverdragon... no flak from me! Sony is busy copying many of the 360's innovations but this should have been one of the very first things they should have looked at. I still don't understand how they can't resolve this issue... if they can insist that every game now have trophy support, why can't they insist that voice chat works!! I don't as much care about cross game chat (though would be nice)... just working voice chat in games that have voice chat (and EVERY online game should have voice chat!)

Kauza... I still don't understand why they can't give the code away to every game for remapping the controls. Surely it can't be so difficult? Even something simple as the R2 button for voice chat in Fat Princess drives me crazy because for me voice chat is L3. :(
Elsa's Destructoid Blog
Oh... and I thought we determined that Takeshi was in charge of food?? Where is he? I'm hungry too! :)
AgentMOO's Destructoid Blog
Simple is better, like this controller I designed for Jim!



I never got the hang of the symbols on the playstation controllers, but the layout and colors on the XBOX 360 one are just right. Also L1 and L2 always give me dyslexia, but calling one a button and one a trigger makes a huge difference.
BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
Bungie Employee about to play Uncharted 2... (Pic 1/2)


Bungie Employee going to be posting on Elsa's Blog... (Pic 2/2)


C Wut I did Thur?
BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
Sorry about the Size/Double Post... *PHAIL*
bodybreak's Destructoid Blog
lol, "x does wat?".
Holyetheline's Destructoid Blog
Yep! I know exactly where you're coming from here. I do it all the time.
king kong five's Destructoid Blog
Too true, especially with the PS3's horrible marshmallow L2 and R2 buttons, which I oftentimes accidentally press with my legs or knees (I play in the fetal position a lot, don't judge me!). It's one thing when bad button mapping makes me accidentally crouch or switch weapons, but when it makes me accidentally shoot (or worse, throw a grenadeMERCENARIES2I'MLOOKINGSTRAIGHATYOU) it really makes the game frustrating to play.
I will say though, that the only thing worse than playing a game with no button mapping options is playing a game with button "schemes." You know those games, in the options menu they let you choose between a Type A, a Type B and a Type C scheme for your controller. Those I actually find more frustrating, because it feel like the developers are rubbing it in my face that they aren't letting me choose for myself.

In conclusion, rabble rabble!
Stevil's Destructoid Blog


Pee. Ess. Free Controllers. TALK TO ME.

You might not get this joke if you've never seen Fonejacker...so here's a helpful clip.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Ua-7YpUtPA

My girlfriend hates any controllers byond the DS. She broke down and cried tried to play Kane & Lynch: Dead Men with me. Ha!
walkyourpath's Destructoid Blog
Elsa -- this was a fantastic post!

Why player-customizable control mapping isn't standard in every current generation game is absolutely beyond me. It's like non-pausable cutscenes, there's no reason for a developer to leave them out. The function can only add to the value of the game.
RonBurgandy2010's Destructoid Blog
I've never really had much trouble with using a shitload of buttons at one time. Then again, my first console was the N64.
confusionbomb's Destructoid Blog
When I played CoD:W@W with some friends at work on the PS3 we had to actually call each other on the phone to arrange to play, then potentially call again if we accepted an invite and it failed to connect. What a POS. I was absolutly stunned by Live when I got my 360. The fact you could talk outside a lobby and when the game was loading. I'm not going back there if I can avoid it.
Anonymouse's Destructoid Blog
Great post Elsa!

Customizable control mapping really is important in today's games. I wouldn't be half as good at Brawl if I didn't have my own control scheme. :)
Palidi's Destructoid Blog
I never really have this problem with controls. Though I might just be a quickk learn in that respect.

I have a much greater issue when they map a whole bunch of commands to the same buttons but with the pressure being different or something. Notable offender here is Metal Gear Online. "I WANTED YOU TO ROLL, NOT LIE DOWN ON THE GROUND!!! NO, THROW OVERHAND, NOT UNDERHAND!!!"
Elsa's Destructoid Blog
LMAO AgentMoo!!! I like that controller!!

@BS3owner... I can see the full pic by right click "view" option! :)

@bodybreak...yeah, it's not unusual for me to yell out in a game "how do I throw a grenade?"... now that I think about it, I must sound like a n00b!! LOL!

@KingKongfive... my cat rubs likes to sit on my lap while I'm gaming and often rubs up against the triggers... my cat once teamkilled a friend of mine! :(

@Stevil... my husband gets frustrated... he's thrown a controller or two in his time (though crying would be cheaper than buying a new controller).

@Walkyourpath... yeah, it's an old idea, but it is just incomprehensible that they can spend their time creating these new "body motion" technologies with their R&D budgets... but still can't resolve something as simple as controller mapping for every game!

@Ron, yeah, I tend to adjust ok... but not when playing multiple games. Also new gamers (especially older new gamers) must have a hell of a time learning the controls for every game.

Confusionbomb... yeah, if they had to copy one thing from the 360 I don't know why they didn't copy this... on day 1 - with release of the console!

Anonymouse! Yeah, I LOVE remappable controls... my UT3 set up is exactly right for me!

Palidi... LMAO... yeah... I'm running along wondering why my guy isn't running... only to find out I'm crouch-running! Oh... and I hate it when I push to hard on L3 and start melee-ing while I'm shooting... so embarrasing! :)
Frohike's Destructoid Blog
I almost think the Wii was going the right direction with control (simplifying), but then took it to such an extreme (waggle everything) that they missed the point of what they were doing.

The control interface should not be a focus when designing the typical game. This is why I think QTEs still suck, despite some people's newfound appreciation for them (part of which I think is just the need to have a contrary & seemingly original/independent opinion all the time, but I digress).

QTEs rip you out of the game and ask you to remember where the "A" or "X" or "Z" button is. I don't process in that way. As I'm playing, I'm not consciously telling myself I'm mashing the B button to swing my sword. It's the "sword button" in my muscle-memory. The minute some jarring on-screen instruction tells me to "push B now!", I have to process and map that instruction and get disconnected.

It takes the internalized interface, remaps it to the instruction manual, and throws that in the foreground, right in your face. I don't like that.

I say bring back simpler controllers, leave the 6 buttons to fighters, and stop... just stop with the QTE stuff. Don't fetishize the controller and make games more playable.

They can still be hard as hell: S'plosion Man. But the difficulty shouldn't be based on the complexity of button presses.
Zodiac Eclipse's Destructoid Blog
PC gaming FTW! Okay, don't shoot I'm just kidding, but they do let you pick pretty much whatever control scheme you want. Although as I'm still crap at FPS I usually just use the standard controls and hope for the best. If I can't remember what button makes me crouch, well I guess I didn't really need to crouch all that badly. Basically I can run and fire a weapon in most games and anything more complicated than that is beyond me. I know this doesn't help you, or really even add anything to your blog, but the pictures made me smile so I felt compelled to comment.
Yehat's Destructoid Blog
I particularly don't like it when certain button combination have important uses such as trying to crouch in Goldeneye and the majority of the Metal Gear Solids*. Just combination buttons seem so irrelevant and a total pain such as you pointed out in the newer Resident Evils, I mean why do I have to 'aim' to reload my gun?

I grew up around simulations so I guess I was never intimidated by having too many buttons and instead I always felt like context sensitive buttons were somehow cheapening the thrill even if they sometimes solved redundancy.

Nothing says "A whole damn buttload of buttons!" like the Tesla IV BattleTech pods. Heck even the training guy says "50% of the buttons you shouldn't touch on your first day, such as detach gunpod, dump ammo [type], eject and puncture reactor" but heck once you learned it you'd find a situation for every which one!

http://www.mechcorps.com/00art/pod_interior.jpg


*No seriously having R3 sensitive bound to execute and interrogate is the most stupid control combination ever.
Deathofthedead's Destructoid Blog
Seriously, well said. Re-mappable control configurations are an absolute necessity for any game, any genre, and there's literally no excuse if a developer is too lazy to implement them. If I want to shoot with X and duck with the left trigger, let me, damn it!
Elsa's Destructoid Blog
Frohike... wow, wish I'd thought of that example to include in the blog!! That's a PERFECT example. I too hate QTE's exactly because of that reason. I too have no idea where the square button is... yet if it's reload in a game, I'm constantly using it unconsciously!

LMAO Takeshi... that seriously made me laugh out loud!! (and you have excellent taste in sandwiches!!!)

Zodiac... speaking of PC gaming, I'll reiterate that I don't understand why more devs don't allow for mouse/kb input on PS3 games. The capability is there and for offline games (or even some online games) it makes little difference except as a more comfortable input for many people (in fact comfortable enough that some could switch over to consoles from the PC)

Yehat... Wow! That battlepod is something else! I guess it would be fine if you learned the controls for one game.... but what if the controls changed every time? That's the problem with console gaming. :(

Deathofthedead... I agree, no excuses!
ikiryou's Destructoid Blog
That last pic of the gazillion-buttoned Dualshock makes my hands achhe<_>

Armored Core 4A seems to have the absolute worst(est!) controller scheme imaginable. Then again, I switch between games during the week so much it's a wonder I've finished any due to forgetting which button does what.

I've a pet peeve with the lack of custom soundtracks in many PS3 games. Warhawk and Killzone 2 inexplicably have the ability for custom soundtracks during gameplay (um, team communication > Metallica?). Heck, custom XMB soundtracks are Sacred 2's saving grace! Sony can't legally* include it (ingame-XMB music for all games, that is), but developers can put in a few lines of code which would allow XMB-based playlists to be played during gameplay...if they wanted to XD


*Microsoft patented the "mechanism" for custom soundtracks via console during gameplay...
JACK of No Trades's Destructoid Blog
It seems like you are lacking the ability to adjust to different control schemes. Or, you just like to complain. All it takes is about 5 minutes to adjust to different controls. There is no need to whine because the shooting button is "R2" instead of "R1". Or because the jump button is "O" instead of "X". Is it really that hard to adjust?
Mushman's Destructoid Blog
Never had a problem, my brain is coo like that! I know the PS controller like the back of my hand since i was six. 14 years on, I have no trouble adjusting to any control scheme at all. Also, I really like QTE's and never really found them to be a problem, great blog. :)
Cadtalfryn's Destructoid Blog
I know exactly what you mean.

Most recently, playing Mirror's Edge was made really difficult any time I wanted to shoot an enemy. I would press R1 and accidentally about face, then get shot in the back by my enemies and die. I did this many, many, many times throughout the game. It's so incredibly frustrating that I cannot help but wonder why there aren't options to remap controls.

Perhaps, I am just spoiled after playing the Conduit though.
TripleZer0's Destructoid Blog
I agree completely. Remappable controls are a must. What's funny is that you mentioned Bioshock as one of the games where the controls felt natural. Ha. I got so confused trying to play Bioshock because I was coming off a Killzone binge. I kept hitting R1 trying to shoot enemies and I'd end up cycling through my weapons instead.

It took me a little bit to get used to the new scheme, but once I did, I was fine. But if I had the option of remapping the controls, I would have done it.

Watching Cad play Mirror's Edge after Killzone was pretty hilarious though.
Elsa's Destructoid Blog
ikiryou... I wonder if the problems with cross game chat (or OS based chat) or even an OS based controller config system is possibly the stupid patent system... if not I'll be sure and run out and patent the concept right away! LOL!

@Jack... yeah, it's my blog and I'll whine if I want to! :)
Jack and Mushman.... I've been playing the MAG beta, then Warhawk, then Sacred and also some Killzone and R2 this week... and keep making stupid controller related mistakes. Maybe I'm playing too many games... maybe I'm just getting old... but yeah, I can't seem to adjust as quickly anymore. :(

Hey Cad and Triple! LMAO... so R1 is an about face?? OMG, I can't even imagine how awful that would be!!
... and triple, you're right... Bioshock had no customization. Now that I remember back... I had a hell of a time with the intial controls... but was only playing the one game... mostly late at night because my dog was quite sick at the time. Bad example... but the movement felt good, but the controls... yeah, they were pretty messed up from the "norm".
Monodi's Destructoid Blog
the double triggers are the only thing that bothers me of PlayStation controls. I sometimes confuse square with circle, but that one is easier to get with.
CelicaCrazed's Destructoid Blog
Going from MAG to Killzone 2 in the same night makes me want to snap my controller in half. R2 is switch weapons in one game than grenade in another!? Blah!! Though to be fair, I still have no clue what the hell half the buttons do in MAG haha. I feel that Resistance 2's control scheme feels the most comfortable to me. I think.

Anyways great write up. I'm not sure if there is any truth to it but I heard that Sony has universal cross-game voice chat and in-game music ready to go for all games but EA is the reason why they haven't released it yet. Something about how some of their games' codes aren't up to Sony's minimal standards so these features wouldn't work with them. And since they don't want people to know about their shoddy work, they're threatening Sony with pulling support if they do release it. Sounds farfetched but you never know....
FatherChesz's Destructoid Blog
I've played so many different games across so many platforms it's not really an issue. The only time I make a controller mistake is when going from Battlefield or Call of Duty to Halo. I want to reload with the X Button! Is that so wrong?
wanderingpixel's Destructoid Blog
My favorite controler of this generation has been the Wiimote. Too bad there are no good games.


prev next


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

 about me

Warning: 47 year old female gamer.
I'm just here to play the game - No, I'm not gaming because my husband forced me to. No, I won't talk dirty to you (you can call the 1-900 number and pay for it like everyone else). No, I'm not fat or ugly. No I don't belong in the kitchen cooking... I'm a lousy cook. No I don't play Nintendogs and don't own a DS, Wii or that Paris Hilton cell phone game. No, I'm not going to make room for you on my buddy list cause you really, really, really want a grrl gamer on your list ( though a certified cheque might change my mind). No, I really am a girl. Just because I have a low voice and sometimes swear does not make me a guy.... and saying "prove it" it not smart unless you really, really want a discussion on menstrual cramps! :)

Playstation Gamer Advisory Panel Member (GAP)

Currently Playing:
Warhawk
Killzone 2
Sacred 2
Battlefield 1943
Resistance 2 co-op
Borderlands
MAG Beta (totally addicted!)

Recent Favorites:
UT3
Portal
Bioshock
Oblivion
Fallout 3
Resistance series

Can't wait for:
MAG
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
Battlefield BC: 2
Dragon Age: Origins
Bioshock 2
... and STARHAWK!!!


Some blogs I wrote that I like:
Girls with Guns
Guess the Gender
A Girl's Guide to FPS Gaming
Nice Puppy! Stay!
Undies and a Knife (promoted Monthly Musing blog)

Some blogs by other people that I really like:
Shmups: Gaming's Equal-Opportunity Employer (a comprehensive look at playable female characters in Shmups by BulletMagnet)

Email: exrecruiter@msn. com

 friends' updates
Cadtalfryn's Profile Cadtalfryn
The Forgotten: Sega Genesis' Great Bygone Bullet Hell Shmup
CblogRecaps's Profile CblogRecaps
Cblogs of 11/27/09 + Mousisms
CelicaCrazed's Profile CelicaCrazed
Xbox 360: I apparently now have one.
DaedHead8's Profile DaedHead8
The Future of Mobile Gaming
Doomsday Forte's Profile Doomsday Forte
Countercounterpoint: Assassin's Creed 2
Hamza CTZ Aziz's Profile Hamza CTZ Aziz
Weekend Destructainment: Jesus cheats at Modern Warfare 2
Jack Maverick's Profile Jack Maverick
Various goings-on + get out of my dreams, Topher
kauza's Profile kauza
A warning: Regrets from a former life and experiences yet unlived
kjohnson1585's Profile kjohnson1585
More of the Same: Gaming is for chil'ren
Magnalon's Profile Magnalon
The New Kid in Town: An Aion FAQ
mistic's Profile mistic
Overcoming the 4th wall, the future of gaming...
Niero's Profile Niero
Join Destructoid at the University of Miami's Launchpad
SilverDragon1979's Profile SilverDragon1979
I celebrated my 30th birthday with beer, DJ Hero, and 600 balloons
SpeedNut's Profile SpeedNut
Fails at blogging.
Takeshi's Profile Takeshi
Fare thee well my big black darling. I'll miss you.
TonicBH's Profile TonicBH
Call of Duty: Modern Reluctancy 2
Tronjoy's Profile Tronjoy
Destructoid Anagrams (NVGR) (Update!)
twotrees517's Profile twotrees517
Everything is your fault: or how I learned to love games that nag.
walkyourpath's Profile walkyourpath
Thanks, You Guys! (Header Image Unrelated)
Xzyliac's Profile Xzyliac
100 Artist Rock Band Needs: Part 1 of 10
Y0j1mb0's Profile Y0j1mb0
PS3 Friday Night Fights: I CAN'T MOVE EDITION
Zippyduda's Profile Zippyduda
So, MGS: Risings' release date. [Shortblog]
Zodiac Eclipse's Profile Zodiac Eclipse
The Forgotten: The Save'n
Zyrshnikashnu's Profile Zyrshnikashnu
SOCOM: Confrontation DLC Detailed


 

 
  get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
contribute a news tip
suggest a feature
be a guest editor
support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?
keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meetup+play online
seriously

about Destructoid
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap
our network

Tomopop
Japanator
Despingation?




Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
living the dream since March 16, 2006