Yesterday, Grim posted
an article about Black Rock Studios saying that the racing genre is dying. I don't disagree, but I can offer an idea as to one of the possible reasons behind it.
See that image above? Four different racing games, developed by three different studios. One features ATVs. One revolves around rally racing. One has more traditional street racing. One has not been released yet. The problem? I had to look up all of that information, because off the top of my head, they are all
indistinguishable from one another.
Somebody, somewhere though it'd be a good idea to give a racing game a curt, four letter title. It's short, it's uncomplicated, and it'll stick in the consumers' minds. Unless, I don't know, all the other racing games out there do the exact same thing.
What's worse is that most of them don't really imply racing, and half of them don't really make sense at all.
Fuel, I'll concede, makes some sense. It takes fuel to drive a car. Got it.
DiRT makes sense if you already know the game is about rally racing, and the box art conveys that just fine, but the title itself could easily be on an ant simulator. But
Pure?
Pure what?
Pure could mean anything.
Grid might actually be the worst of the bunch; as it conjures an image of a slow-paced strategy game, rather than the street racing actually involved.
When I think of non-
Mario Kart racing games, the two that come to mind first are
Project Gotham Racing and
Forza Motorsport. Now, I can't say much for how much sense either of those two titles make (
Project Gotham had me thinking I'd be driving the Batmobile and I don't even know what a
Forza is), but at least they let me know what I'm getting into. Racing. Motorsports. All right, got it. And more importantly, the titles can't be confused with one another, or with anything else.
So my message to racing game developers is this: please stop with the single-word four-letter titles for your games. I have already ignored these four and I lump them all together in my brain despite that they are all presumably different from one another. What about you guys, have you gotten any of these confused?
(# 0) on 04/23/2009 18:59
Dirt, Grid AND Fuel are ALL developed and published by Codemasters. So they might have tried to build up some brand identity by making the covers similar, with striking, short and easy to remember titles. Also, Grid and Dirt both sold very well. Pure was Disney interactive, and like I said, while I didn't play it, it looked fun. And as for Fuel, which is being developed by Asobo Studios, its being PUBLISHED by Codemasters, so this probably goes along with their motif in their own lineup of racing games. Sorry, and please don't be too offended by this post, but you basically just admitted to being ignorant.
Also, for the record, the British name for Grid is Race Driver: Grid, with Grid referring to the lineup of race cars in a race. Now, the racing genre isn't dying, it's just more of a niche genre. With the exception of PGR, are either simulations, or off road arcade-styled games. I wonder what the sales figures really are, and no amount of corporate/developer head speak will make me believe that the genre is dying. Im pretty sure Midnight Club: LA sold pretty well, despite the relative weak sales of Need For Speed: Undercover. Im also pretty sure Gran Turismo was just listed on the top 10 best selling games of all time. Forza 2 did great. Burnout Paradise is a great title and is constantly being lauded for it's innovations in both DLC, pricing structure and fanservice. I played Wipeout HD to death. Hell, even Mario Kart for the Wii is one of the best games on the system.
TL:DR - You didn't do your research, Codemasters is trying to build a psuedo-franchise, and your ignorance caused you to miss out on three, possibly four great games. Seriously, this could have been an interesting argument, instead, you judged a book by it's cover, and missed out on some amazing titles
(# 1) on 04/23/2009 19:50
(# 2) on 04/23/2009 19:51
What a dumb complaint "Well the racing genre is dying cause the boxes are to similar", yea I'm sure TONS of people where pissed when they bought pure and expected a 2 fast 2 furious type game.
Dirt implies rally, PURE is an odd name but the box art means its ATV's, Grid has ton of sponsors on the car in the box ergo it must be a straight racing game.
(# 3) on 04/23/2009 19:51
(# 4) on 04/23/2009 19:57
(# 5) on 04/23/2009 20:05
(# 6) on 04/23/2009 20:08
(# 7) on 04/23/2009 20:10
(# 8) on 04/23/2009 20:10
I'm not a huge racing game fan, but I do enjoy Project Gotham, Forza, and Gran Turismo now and again. I can say I'm guilty of ignoring these games because of their "budget-game" titles.
I understand that if you're really into the racing genre, you're not going to ignore a game based off of how it's marketed. If you're not, you likely will.
(# 9) on 04/23/2009 20:12
(# 10) on 04/23/2009 20:14
(# 11) on 04/23/2009 20:16
Marketing and design is very important kids.
(# 12) on 04/23/2009 20:34
I thought the same thing o_o
(# 13) on 04/23/2009 20:35
(# 14) on 04/23/2009 20:38
(# 15) on 04/23/2009 20:46
(# 16) on 04/23/2009 21:03
(# 17) on 04/23/2009 21:05
(# 18) on 04/23/2009 21:11
(# 19) on 04/23/2009 21:35
(# 20) on 04/23/2009 21:53
(# 21) on 04/23/2009 23:26
MONSTER TRUCKS PEOPLE. Also good point Dexter things need to CHANGE.
(# 22) on 04/24/2009 13:00
thanks for reminding me about that
think I'll pop it in tonight...
(# 23) on 04/24/2009 16:27
Do it.
(# 24) on 04/25/2009 13:28