on japanator

WTF is Destructoid? Read this first! Got news? email us

create an account | login

Home Buy & Sell Wii U PS Vita 360 PS3 Wii PC 3DS PSP Reviews Videos Blogs Forums Fight

Dale North's blog

RSS

Contact

About Me

edit

I AM DESTRUCTOID'S MANAGING EDITOR. I LOVE CORGIS.

Gamer Profile

edit

3DS friend code:
Steam:
Battle:
PSN:
Mii: 1909 4344 6171 2004
Gamertag: DaleNorth

Following (27)

edit

Around the community:

Bloggers Wanted: Training

Your complete guide to Destructoid

Soul Calibur IV - Xbox 360 or PS3
Dale North \| 12:01 PM on 07.29.2008	60 comments

Now, I'm not asking either system fanboy. I'm asking the fighting game fan:
Which version would you get.

My instincts tell me that the PS3 will be better for the controller, which is better for fighting games. It seems that it looks a little better, though the differences aren't easily apparent.

The 360 may have more online players. But then again, maybe not. Amazon sold more PS3 copies than Xbox 360.

So, which version are you getting?

Attached photos:

Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

Post a comment! You can also post a photo below:

Comment with Facebook

Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid

New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

52 comments | showing # 1 to 50

next 50 comments

ParaParaKing

I'm getting the PS3 version, because I have a PS3. But if I would have to choose I would pick the PS3 version, because most likely the PS3 will have more online players (because it's free) and the better joypad for fighting games.

shipero

Flip a coin. All the best decisions are made via coin flip.

Char Aznable

I'm most excited about playing this online with friends, so the Xbox 360 version is the way to go. That's my only current-gen console, though, so there wasn't much of a debate for me.

The d-pad sucks, yeah, but I've gotten accustomed to using the analog stick in Street Fighter II. I think it'll be alright. I'm totally envious of the people who got their arcade sticks for this game.

Send me a challenge if you end up going with the 360 version. GT: ShinigamiBV

Aerox

I want to get the PS3 version for the controller, but EVERYONE in IRC is getting the 360 one, so I guess I'll be getting that. I hate the 360 controller so much though.

Clint

I'm going with PS3, as it be foolish to but a game for a console I don't own.

galagabug

as a fighting game fan, it doesn't matter. neither stock controller will do the game the justice a 3rd party joystick will.

Shin Oni

I want the PS3 version but sadly...I only have an 360. Though for something like SC IV, 360 controller wins just cause of Analog nub being main controller. Makes it easier on 8-way movement.

Shin Oni

and Galagabug is right. Arcade Stick >>>>>>> Any controller.

Projectexodus

The PS3 version for the kickass boxart! Plus, I get Darth Vader in the package!

Scrixx

Get a joystick. Play it on 360. Online + Controllers work!

And besides, I hear Yoda is a better fighter than Vader even though they'll both will eventually be unlockable.

bloodylip

The game probably stinks out loud, so I'll give you an objective opinion. 360 has a superior positioning and feel in the left analog stick, IMO. Both systems have kinda shitty dpads, with the 360's being more shitty. A 3rd party arcade stick is a must, so make your decision based on which money-grubbing star wars character you like more.

covah

I got the 360 version and Yoda is fucking awesome. He's a bit hard to control sometimes but he's ridiculously hard to hit if you're on a roll.

Plus I like spamming his taunt, "Afraid are you? hmm"

ParaParaKing

On a side note: I don't think your decision will get easier after reading all the comments here.

thefil

I got the PS3 version, because I already had a Hori stick for it! That doesn't help you!

c45h

I went with the 360 version to play with friends, so take a look at your friends' setups and see which makes more sense. Your going to get a lot more out of the game if 6 months from now you can invite you bro down the street to a game on live than if they have to come over to your house and sit next to you whilst playing on a ps3.

bbrigg1

neither

*hangs self

BlindsideDork

PS3 version if I were to waste $60 on a fighter...lame.

Cowzilla3

You're all overcomplicating this. You really don't have any choice Dale. We all know you're afraid and fear leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate leads to suffering and suffering leads to the dark side. It's fate, you have to get the PS3 version because that's where you'll find vader.

Kryptinite

Dale what the fuck man?

Also I've decided to go with the 360 version. I like to talk shit to people I cut in the face.

Kryptinite

Also, I'm getting the Hori stick this weekend.

And great minds think alike.

and cheese.

king3vbo

I think the PS3 controller is more suited to Soul Calibur, but I'm getting the 360 version because most of my friends who play Soul Calibur are

Phantom Spaceman

360 - achievements ftw

Red TheHaze Veron

Im very very skepitcal about online fighting games, in a game where ever second counts, lag is your most formidable opponent. I got mine for the PS3 cause I dont really want to get a joystick just to play a game when I already have a system that has a decent D-Pad.

Josh Tolentino

I'm getting the PS3 version mainly because I don't have a 360, but yeah, I prefer the PS3 controller, and I like Vader more than Yoda. I've heard that Yoda's cheaper, though.

JACK of No Trades

Krytinite

You asshole!!!!! You never play with the PS3 crowd.... ;(

Kryptinite

@Jack

LoL. I'm sorry dude I gotta go where the people are. I can't play MGS4 co-op or I'd be all over it. We'll play some Resistance 2, Little Big Planet, and Fat Princess together. I promise!

JACK of No Trades

LOL, ok dude I will hold you to it!!! I have a 360 too, but I know more people on PSN, so Darth Vader here I come.

Ha-Puken

@Kryptinite
I'm with Jack on this one, asshole. Can't even show up for a couple hands of poker and a chance to win SC IV for FREE!? Sonuvabitch! lol

ghets

I think im getting both :(

BS3 Owner

PS3 because that's all I have... : (

& that's what my friends have too!

Shalashaska161

PS3 because I don't own a 360. The controller is better though anyways.

Bob Muir

I'm getting the 360 version. If I need better controls, I'll get an arcade stick.

Elitechief27

360 because my PS3 is shit because it can't read my discs for some apparent reason ever since I got an update for MGO.

CronosBlade

360 since

1) I've got an arcade stick
2) Everyone in IRC is doing it
3) Vader looks like he'll be there anyway.

braulio09

Harvey Dent would flip a coin.

zombiekiller13

The left one. The right one is a little droopy...and I'm using my left and right...

Oh, you asked which system I would choose.

360...since it's the only one of the two I've got...

...

...

...

...seriously, look at them...the things are the size of her head...I'm surprised both aren't dropping a bit.

mix

Why not make your own path and be hardcore!? Get it on the Wii....

Too Much Coffee Man

I'm waiting to find out the resolution/AA/AF/Framerate/upscaling of both versions before i decide.

I dont care about controls because I'll be building an arcade stick anyway.

Crunshii

yoda sucks, Vader rules.

BS3 baby =)

kawitchate

bought the PS3 SCIV Hori Arcade Stick for the game so... i'm getting it on PS3. oh, and i bought the stick for PS3 because i've got more fighters for PS2/3 than i do my 360. ARCANA HEART FTW!

Phantom Spaceman

so... you'll walk towards it?

mix

@Heretic

360 degrees is a full circle so if your looking at the 360 a 360 degree turn would mean your looking at it again.....

I <3 PS3

ceark

I just bought the ps3 version.

Takeshi

I'll get the PS3 version. I've got a full friendslist with people who are playing it except for Kryptinite who I don't know anymore.

Dale, I would go for the PS3 if I were you, I would always go for better controls. Besides there will be more than enough players online.

DarkTravesty

ps3 only because i already have a hori fighting stick 3 for it. if i had one for my 360 then i would get it for that system.

vexed alex

"Now, I'm not asking either system fanboy."

You're pitting two consoles against eachother. There's no way to get what you just requested.

ScottyG

Don't have a PS3, but then again aren't planning to get the game either. :P

norm9

Whichever controller you're more comfortable with.

Personally, I wish it came out for the ps2 so I could use my SF2 anniversary controllers with it.

Lightthrower

With the PS3, you can install data on your hardrive so that load times are shortened by about 50%, that's pretty neat.

naib

360

+I have more ppl on my FL
+better FL/MM
+Microsoft invading my living room
+ummm?

-Yoda (y'all can keep him. he's immune to throws & most high attacks)
-loud as hell.
-did I mention it's loud as hell

PS3

+better d-pad
+quiet operation
+shorter load times
+did I mention it's quieter?

-Vader (y'all can keep him. it's just silly)
-dumb friends management
-no rumble? (haven't noticed)
-fewer people on my friends list

------------------------

I've got both systems. The 360 has HD installs on the way, and I'm sure the newer chipset(s) are quieter. I've got more friends on my 360 FL but only a handful are fighter fans. I'll also admit I'm always looking for reasons to get the PS3 version, but that doesn't mean I'm not reaonable.

I'm a SC noob and I'm loving it. Shura is my favorite so far. Maybe because I'm a noob?

Anyway, awesome game. You should be happy w/ either version.

prev	next 50 comments

Comment with Facebook

Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid

New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

All editorial content, including blogs, comments, and forums written by our community, are protected by a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Destructoid aka ModernMethod is an independently-run company forged by our childhood love of video games and adulthood hatred mainstream video game press.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006