games  anime  |  toys
This is a Dtoid readers's blog. For staff blogs click here. Confused? read this Create you own!  |   Members: Login now





Moral Change Because of Video Games?
DaedHead8 | 11:37 AM on 09.27.2009 13 comments



Get it?

Today I’m writing this blog post to ask Destructoid what I think is an interesting question. I’ve been pondering lately, mostly because of my Psychological and Social Effects of Games class, what, if any, moral standards do video games impose on their players? Is it even possible for video games to influence a player’s moral compass? Or do players bring their own moral backgrounds with them through the game?

Honestly, if you were to ask me, I’d say it’s a little bit of both. It is impossible and a bit silly to claim that games like Grand Theft Auto and God of War don’t require a certain moral code (or lack thereof) to see them through to completion. However, just because a lack of morality is on display doesn’t mean that the player is automatically picking up on that and is changing as a person as a result. It isn’t necessarily Grand Theft Auto teaching us that if you kill a hooker after sex you get your money back.

For example, I had my mother play Grand Theft Auto once, if only to show her that the game isn’t full of sex, blood and chaos unless you wanted it to be. Her GTA experience was rather short, she drove around for awhile, obeying all the traffic laws and quickly got bored and quit. So you see, my mother didn’t pick up the game and suddenly lose all of her god fearing, Christian values, in fact, she brought those values into the game!

This is why it is my opinion that the moral code that gamers develop for video games is made up of two parts. The first part is their morality in real life and the second part is the moral code that the video game requires for you to complete it. If at any point, the game’s required moral code conflicts too deeply with the gamer’s real life moral code, he or she will likely decide that the game is not for them.

So what are your thoughts on the issue? Can games affect your real life moral compass? Can you think of a specific game where this has happened to you? I’m interested to find out.



Attached photos:

Photo

Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

2

Those who have fapped:  TSuereth  

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

13 comments | showing # 1 to 13

prev next

BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
I believe you are right. In the sense you either have a moral compass (conscience) or you don't.

The purchase of the game is not all the time. A reflection on one's personal values or qualities, but has a lot to do with how the game plays. Or an interest to what everyone else is saying. (Hype = Peer-Pressure/Sheer Curiosity)

After the initial purchase you make your mind up as to how you fall into & out of touch. With the atmosphere, objectives, and/or gameplay itself. Justifying to one's self how it either reflects or doesn't reflect back.

Some people say a game is a game... Others swear their allegiance to said title blindly. Age, Maturity, & Fun i owuld think determine those factors. But...

There are some parts of society that would sway you into thinking. If you play this ( What they feel to them as a organization as a "[insert type here] simulator"... You get the more radically minded (Possible Psychotic) groups/individuals.

Where as they believe if you play Resident Evil 5. You are a training your hate in a racists way. Towards a selected sector of society. Unintentionally by the game developers. To train or act out in a certain way.

Same with Grand Theft Auto series. "Murder Simulator" by both Legal Activists & the Drug Induced...

In the end everyone is affected differently. Some chose to group together around common ideals though too.

/rant
TSuereth's Destructoid Blog
A player's morals don't necessarily direct his actions - I do things in GTA that I would never consider in real life, exactly for that reason: I know it's an illusion, and want to explore it. To behave exactly like you would in real life is just refusal of the concept of escapism (not that that's wrong, but it's not really right, either).

From the other direction, games can certainly reflect a player's actions back on him, although I don't think this works in many games because of how ridiculous they are. In GTA, you can see somewhat-convincing consequences of hitting pedestrians with your car. In Fable, slicing a guy up gives you glowing orbs, and makes your character "look" evil. It's less a depiction of moral consequence, than a parody of it, and is basically impossible to take seriously.
BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
I was referring to the "Review/Glorification" of RE5 by the KKK by the way.

Also, a real prime example of how games. Not only can train a way of thinking. To those you and i would consider a little tilt. Take the 9/11 Terrorists that used Microsoft's Flight Simulator. Not only as a way to make a moral choice and kill people... But as a training "HOW TO GUIDE".
DaedHead8's Destructoid Blog
@BS3 Owner

Thankfully the people who honestly believe that GTA is a murder simulator are few and far between. They are a sort of vocal minority if you will. I think the vast majority of people understand that there is no practical weapons training in video games.

@TSuereth

I would argue that your morals are directing your actions in GTA, simply because your morals allow you to make a distinction between the real world and the digital one. That is a distinction some people fail to make. But I agree, behaving exactly as one would in real life (like my Mom did when she played GTA) is not only boring but a terrible way to live your life. I really feel bad for people who can't let go for a couple of hours and just have fun.
TSuereth's Destructoid Blog
You're right, in that I make Tommy/Carl/Niko et al. commit vehicular homicide because I try to avoid it in the real world - I mean that by itself, trying to read my morals from my in-game actions wouldn't be meaningful. How would a genuine murdering psychopath play GTA? Would it be any different? (Actually, I guess I don't know, maybe psychopaths drive on the right side of the road and stop to avoid pedestrians.)
DaedHead8's Destructoid Blog
@TSuereth

That's an interesting point. I wonder what Ed Gein or Richard Ramirez would do with a copy of GTA?
BS3 Owner's Destructoid Blog
@TSuereth
Not ALL Psychopaths are Psycho.
There is this wonderful invention... (Medication.)

@ daedhead
I'm guessing "Hot Rails" or Lines of Coke.
Elsa's Destructoid Blog
Personally I think that gaming "can" affect your moral code over an extended period of time.

I'm not thinking specifically of games, but the gaming experience. Believe it or not, but I was actually raised to be "ladylike" and rarely swore in public. When I started with online gaming I was fairly reserved and polite. The other day my husband walked by as I was shutting down the system and asked why I was giving some guy shit and apparently I said something to the effect that "oh for fuck's sake... you goddamn asshole, teamkilling is on you n00b!" Ummm... I have a hard time even typing that... yet I'm sure that I probably did say it.

When you play an offline game where the f word is liberally sprinkled through the dialogue... when you play online games and hear harsh words sprinkled through the gameplay - yes, it can gradually over time affect your own morality in terms of the words you use.


... though again, I have to bring back the killing the rat thing. I've killed countless rats in video games, but had the most difficult time killing an injured rat that my cat had mauled and that needed to be put down with a shovel (couldn't let the cat finish him off because the cat had been rat poisoned and it's an expensive vet bill!).

Apparently some moral issues are more flexible than others...
Magnalon's Destructoid Blog
@Dead
Nice blog!

I will say that GTA IV does have randoms shit happen even if you strive to do good, and just drive around. People will curse, others will rob, and murder randomly as the city goes about their daily business.
puduhead's Destructoid Blog
Young people without a strong family/social life can have their morals supplanted by entertainment media, including film, music, games..

But i assume this was directed more towards the centered and balanced individual, in which case they are most likely to take an active role in the creation of their moral code.

nature vs. nurture? as a parent, i will follow ratings and use some judgment in what is appropriate for my children as they become old enough to game. We sure have come a long way since i was entranced by Zelda 1 as a 12-yr-old.
possumwrangler's Destructoid Blog
I've never felt that there was such a thing as a moral choice in a single-player game because it's simply a cause-and-effect relationship between the users input, and the developers pre-programmed output. It's a closed-system, so there's no such thing as morale/immoral in my view.

However, in multiplayer games, I think there's a strong sense of right and wrong, because your actions affect everyone else in the game. I curse teammates out when they spawn-toob in the first round, but if the opposition does it first, I've got no problem with my teammates returning fire.

I would argue that there's no point in debating morality in video games, only fairness, just like in any other competitive activity.
walkyourpath's Destructoid Blog
Most of my thoughts on this have already been voiced, so I'll leave it at good post!
Holyetheline's Destructoid Blog
I don't bring my own moral code along with me while I play video games. I simply accept the character I am playing as and I conquer whatever it is that I need to overcome in the game with/for them. I guess you could say I'm one of those "go with the flow" type of people.


prev next


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

 about me



Whats up Destructoid?
My name is Sean McLoughlin and I've been sent from the futurepast to march with my fellow robots to victory. For Niero!

My favorite games can be numerous (as I'm sure is true of most here at Dtoid), but my all time favorites are Final Fantasy VI, Diablo II, Bioshock and Metal Gear Solid. I never rent games and I rarely trade in or sell the games I buy so I have a pretty massive game collection. For the sake of space I'll just list the consoles and portables that I own: NES, SNES, Genesis, Game Gear, Game Boy Pocket, Game Boy Advance, Playstation, N64, Playstation 2, Dreamcast, Gamecube, Xbox, Neo Geo Pocket, Nintendo DS, Nintendo DSi, PSP 2000, Xbox 360, Nintendo Wii and a Playstation 3.

When I'm not in school or gaming you can probably find me reading a science fiction/fantasy novel or an issue of Wired or some such. My favorite authors are George RR Martin, Terry Brooks, Garth Nix and Terry Goodkind. I'm also a big fan of movies, my favorites right now are The Departed, Smoking Aces and Crank, although my all time favorite movie/director is Reservoir Dogs/Tarantino. I don't watch much TV and if I do its usually Discovery channel or Science Channel. My favorite band is obviously The Grateful Dead although my musical tastes are quite varied. I listen to everything from T.I. to Metallica to Toby Keith. Also, MC Chris FTMFW!

Bored? Try my game out and tell me what you think.

Other places you can find me on the interwebz:

AIM: DaedHead8
Gamer Limit
Giant Bomb
Steam
360 Voice
GameTap
MySpace
Facebook
Stickam
Twitter

MacGyver gets Lazy:


What Diglett really looks like:


How's your vision?


Coolest Cake Ever!


Truth:

 xbox 360 gamertag
 friends' updates
ace of knaves's Profile ace of knaves
Arkham Asylum is INSANEly Fun
Anthony Burch's Profile Anthony Burch
Hell is other demons: Solium Infernum released
Anus Mcphanus's Profile Anus Mcphanus
So Sony had a launch party for their Video Delivery Service last night...
atheistium's Profile atheistium
I'm in Canada for a Ubisoft Montreal Event
BahamutZero's Profile BahamutZero
TITAN QUEST IS AMAZING - aka - BUY THE THQ PACK ON STEAM BEFORE MONDAY
BFeld13's Profile BFeld13
GTA IV: The Lost and Damned - Thoughts represented in pictures with words
blehman's Profile blehman
Dear Diary, I've Met Someone Else
BlindsideDork's Profile BlindsideDork
Leaked Transformers: RotF trailer #2 = YES PLEASE!
Boolean's Profile Boolean
Time for honesty
Butmac's Profile Butmac
Live with Butmac makes it's return
casualweaponry's Profile casualweaponry
Shortblog! TF2 Mass AI video
ceark's Profile ceark
I can't figure some things out and it's driving me nuts.
Conrad Zimmerman's Profile Conrad Zimmerman
Dale North psyched about Fallout 3 360 Avatar items
DaedHead8's Profile DaedHead8
The Future of Mobile Gaming
Dale North's Profile Dale North
New Shiren the Wanderer trailer looks awesome
dephect's Profile dephect
The Conduit... I ruined what was already ruined.
DtoidNewYork's Profile DtoidNewYork
The Dtoid NY Secret Santa at Blipfest and a Podcast?
Electro Lemon's Profile Electro Lemon
CAPTION CONTEST: Jim Sterling in Miami!
Elsa's Profile Elsa
MAG Beta Impressions - For the Hardcore or Weekend Warrior?
EternalDeathSlayer's Profile EternalDeathSlayer
Happy Thanksgiving Destructoid, I'm thankful for you and some other stuff.
Excremento's Profile Excremento
A Weird Kid's Top 10 -- NES Games That You Had To Leave on All-Night To Beat
Fronz's Profile Fronz
Game Debate to the Death! Super Mario series Part 2
Gameboi's Profile Gameboi
Talk about surreal!
Hamza CTZ Aziz's Profile Hamza CTZ Aziz
Weekend Destructainment: Jesus cheats at Modern Warfare 2
Jim Sterling's Profile Jim Sterling
Raskulls still looks adorable in these new screens
Joe Burling's Profile Joe Burling
Meatspin Calculator Gymnastics: March 2009
Jordan Devore's Profile Jordan Devore
Exploring the daunting tunnels of 2010 IGF entrant 'Cave'
Justice's Profile Justice
A new addition to the household (shortblog)
king3vbo's Profile king3vbo
Why I Love Destructoid
LarkOhiya's Profile LarkOhiya
I hugged Pikachu's beach
Lavallee017's Profile Lavallee017
Gaming’s Guilty Pleasures: Friendly Fire
Magnalon's Profile Magnalon
The New Kid in Town: An Aion FAQ
manley's Profile manley
re:dear mr workman: regarding my destructoid editor position
Mave's Profile Mave
A Christian Gamer
MaxVest's Profile MaxVest
My New Job As A Chicken Sexer -- Not What I Thought It Would Be
MrSadistic's Profile MrSadistic
Hey Destructoid, Happy Thxgiving.
Necros's Profile Necros
Dtoid's 2009 Completed Games List: August/September/October
Niero's Profile Niero
Join Destructoid at the University of Miami's Launchpad
NihonTiger90's Profile NihonTiger90
What'd You Get? - Thanksgiving Edition
nilcam's Profile nilcam
An update approaches
Ocified-Xboxer's Profile Ocified-Xboxer
Dtoid Forza 3 Camaro
pixelpunx's Profile pixelpunx
Hey Portland! Chiptune Show tonight!
Professor Pew's Profile Professor Pew
Pew Review: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (360) (spoilerfree no less)
Qalamari's Profile Qalamari
PAX 2009: The do's and do NOT do's
razerangel's Profile razerangel
Are Games Becoming Homogenous?
Redzie's Profile Redzie
Blatant Shameless Plug Shortblog post: Halo Animu edition
Rifter01's Profile Rifter01
Tekken 6 Soul Calibur 4 Tourney & Magic XBLA Update
Riser Glen's Profile Riser Glen
Thanks for being my Neighbor, DToid
Samit Sarkar's Profile Samit Sarkar
Steam sale, day 3: Borderlands, Ghostbusters, Trine, more
ScottyG's Profile ScottyG
Your wallet will thank you: Steam sales
ShadokatRegn's Profile ShadokatRegn
My Recovered Gaming Rig, Let Me Show It To You
Snaileb 's Profile Snaileb
I've been having a blast, but miss you too, Dtoid!
Steel Squirrel's Profile Steel Squirrel
Semi-easy money in Tekken 6
Surf314's Profile Surf314
TFNF(2) Or How I Learned to Love the Fortress
Team Fortress 2's Profile Team Fortress 2
Community Team Fortress 2 FNF: The Dark Knight Deserves Your Attention Edition
Too Much Coffee Man's Profile Too Much Coffee Man
13 month xbox Live card $30 @WM: update
Topher Cantler's Profile Topher Cantler
READY TO FRIDAY
Tubatic's Profile Tubatic
My Cat Found A Game He Likes On The Wii
vexed alex's Profile vexed alex
Beneath the Pixels: Wind Waker Part One
wardrox's Profile wardrox
A Short Film By Wardrox
Y0j1mb0's Profile Y0j1mb0
PS3 Friday Night Fights: I CAN'T MOVE EDITION


 

 
  get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
contribute a news tip
suggest a feature
be a guest editor
support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?
keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meetup+play online
seriously

about Destructoid
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap
our network

Tomopop
Japanator
Despingation?




Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
living the dream since March 16, 2006