games  anime  |  toys
This is a Destructoid readers's blog. For staff blogs click here. Confused? read this Create you own Dtoid blog, it's free!  |   Returning members: Login now


[ Cowzilla3's blog ]



A Few Thoughts on Videogame Journalism
Cowzilla3 | 11:30 AM on 10.10.2007 23 comments




A bit back there was a Zero punctuation review of Halo 3 in which the guy with the crazy accent admitted that he hadn't played any of the other Halo games but that he was now going to review this one. I realize that his reviews are more of a funny joke but it speaks to a greater problem within the world of gaming journalism and the attitude people take towards it. There seems to be a prevailing idea that gaming journalists need not be educated in their field, its history, and the influences that games have.

How could you possible review any game, let alone Halo 3, if you didn't know the background and experience the history of one of the most influential games in gaming history? Far too often you see the caveat at the beginning of the review that a reviewer hasn't played the first game or a writer will clearly miss the influences of one game on another simply because he hasn't played it. As a gaming journalist shouldn't you know where games came from not just where they are going?

It is absolutely ridiculous that any gaming writer wouldn't play a game that is highly influential to the medium. “It's not my type of game” is not an excuse if it is your job to be able to critique and comment on a game. A writer should know all styles of games and have played the ones that really matter. I am not saying that a gaming critic needs to play every game ever released but there are certain games that anyone who is seriously in this business must play no matter what. It is in fact their job to play these games and be able to apply their ideas and influences to current games.

I'm a film critic. If I told you I hadn't seen "Citizen Kane" and didn't understand the major impact it had on filmmaking you'd laugh me to the next block and disregard my opinion. Or lets say I am reviewing a zombie movie but I've never seen "Night of the Living Dead" (I have). I would argue that that pretty much invalidates or at least weakens any opinion I have on any zombie movie. It should be the same for games. These are extreme examples but stuff like this happens all the time in game reviews all over the place, even at the big boys like IGN, where it is nothing but they're job to be educated in gaming. If someone reviews Metroid Corruption and they have never played Super Metroid they don't know exactly where the game is coming from. Not having played any of the Primes would be even more of a crime and yet I’ve read reviews at legitimate websites where the critic hadn’t played the either of them.

I understand that games take time to play through, and much like a film or art you can't see all the movies or all the paintings, but a journalist needs to make sure they have the classics played and that they know their shit. If you're playing a sequel it is your job to play the original, to have played at least a few games that may have influenced it. To know where that game is coming from is just as important as knowing how it plays now.

The point is that gaming journalism is a job, it is a profession and yet the overwhelming feeling from many sites is that it’s OK to treat it like something you can kick off on the side, that an education in games isn't as important as being able to make a witty joke and discuss how pretty the graphics are. Then the industry turns around and screams about not being respected as legitimate journalist or artists. The onus isn't just on the rest of the world to accept gaming as a serious business, it’s on the people who write about it to treat it that way too. I am not saying gaming journalism and critique needs to be high and mighty and lack fun but we must respect the history, the business and the art all at once when discussing games not just think that we as a community can go about treating gaming like it is still in its infancy.



Is this post awesome? Vote it up!

0


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

23 comments | showing # 1 to 23

prev next

topgeargorilla's Destructoid Blog
hmmmm, makes sense, but I do have to say that it is a bit based on what you're focused on. I want to do games journalism. I am going to be doing games journalism. Do I want to review? not really, news and features are more my game. Does that mean I have to play Halo. I don't think so. Does that mean I have to understand the importance of Halo?

Oh yes, yes I do.
JACK of No Trades's Destructoid Blog
I agree 100%. Journalist shouldn't be bias fanboys.
vexed alex's Destructoid Blog
But, you shouldn't have to play the first game to understand it or to have more fun with it. A game, despite whichever one you're playing, should be fun regardless.

Halo 3 didn't have any explanation as to what the hell was going on. You were just dropped in there. Remember, a reviewer has to keep everyone in mind and that includes the newbies.
DanGale's Destructoid Blog
Who said anything about fanboys?
BlindsideDork's Destructoid Blog
I played Halos...I played Halo 3. I disappointed.

Free is free.
MaxVest's Destructoid Blog
I think there are multiple audiences for game reviews, just as there are for games.

Some people just want a numerical buy/play recommendation. Others (like many Dtoiders) want a deeper review that traces game lineages and evolution and places them in the proper framework.
vexed alex's Destructoid Blog
I like EGM's reviews because there are multiple people reviewing one game. Game Informer does something like this, but on a smaller scale. They have one massive review and one small side review by someone else. EGM splits 'em even between three people.
king3vbo's Destructoid Blog
/agree
Snaileb 's Destructoid Blog
Awesome Cowzilla, and any real gamer will agree with you. My thoughts are only ignorant people take ignorant opinions from ignorant journalists.

Just like you know your credentials and background for the filming industy, since you review films, it should be the same, or even better it should be enforced, that gaming journalists aren't just posing to be something they're not.
Cowzilla3's Destructoid Blog
@topgear
Yes you should have to have played all three Halos to write about gaming. They are massively influential and playing them is part of understanding why and forming your own opinion which will come into play no matter what you are writing about.

@vexed alex
I agree that you should be able to get into a game no matter what, but the average person is not a journalist. A journalist needs to be able to talk to both sides of the gaming market, noobs and hardcore alike. It is their job to be able to discuss to both these crowds and have the knowledge to be able to do so well.
VWGTI's Destructoid Blog
@Cowzilla3

Great write up and I agree with you 100%
Variable Gear's Destructoid Blog
I know what you are saying here, Cowzilla3, but consider this: People get into games at different depths at different times in their lives. Some people might not have kept up with all of the Next-Gen bullshit like we have, but they simply wanted to see what Halo 3 was all about. Why shouldn't game reviewers who have kept the same distance from the Halo series write reviews or be allowed to criticize parts of the game? Wouldn't such perspectives fit in perfectly with what these newer Halo player's needs?

It is just something to think about...
Cowzilla3's Destructoid Blog
@Variable
That is a good point but I personally feel that if you are a good writer and know your stuff you can understand how a game would feel even if you were just jumping in even if you've been with it the whole time. On the flipside it is impossible for you to judge any game as well if you don't know where it is coming from, it makes your review better and more informed no matter what how you are trying to approach it.
At least this is what I've gained from writing film and game reviews myself. An experienced, educated person can look at a game or film from almost any angle including that of a noob if they're a good writer, some one who is not only has that one viewpoint. Does this invalidate their opinion in general? No, everyone has opinions, but it does make them less valid to a wider audience and a game reviewer or journalist should hope to be speaking to everyone not just hardcore or new player.
Snaileb 's Destructoid Blog
CONFLICT!
Variable Gear's Destructoid Blog
@ Cowzilla3:

I agree, journalists should be able to simultaneously interest and educate the hardcore and the casual. That does not usually happen, especially not in mainstream news media.
MaxVest's Destructoid Blog
I'm not sure that a reviewer should attempt to speak to everyone. There's merit in knowing your audience and tailoring a message for them. For everyone else, the reviewer provides a score so the review offers some use, if not insight.
MaxVest's Destructoid Blog
That wasn't in response to Variable Gear, but it looks like I'm alone in this sentiment.

All I mean to say is that any reviewer should expect a substantial portion of their audience to stop reading fairly early on, depending on the tone the reviewer sets. Even if a reviewer switches gears later on, the people who would have been interested in that perspective are long gone.
Cowzilla3's Destructoid Blog
@MaxVest
Thats true, always write for you audience if you know who they will be. That doesn't mean that you have to be uneducated or not knowlegable even if your audience is. It came out a little wrong, I was trying to say a writer who is well versed in games can speak to both crowds as well, while a writer who isn't can only speak to one, and even then not as well.

Thanks for the counter points guys, love the discussion.
Necros's Destructoid Blog
At the same time, this kind of mentality keeps me from playing many new games. Like, I could run out and play Metroid Prime 3. But I haven't played my copy of Metroid Prime 1 yet, so how can I understand where it's coming from? The same applies to many games. My friend told me he loved Jak 3, so what do I do? I buy Jak 1. Sometimes, it takes a lot of effort just to play one current game.
Cowzilla3's Destructoid Blog
Yea but its also not your job (I don't think) to play games Necros. If it was, like it is for a gaming journalist then you'd have time I would hope.
Necros's Destructoid Blog
Yeah, I know I'm not a journalist, but I really do care about my knowledge of video games, so I do follow that line of thinking that requires you to play the older games first. For instance, I'm playing Deus Ex right now (and at least attempted to play System Shock 1, though old technology screwed that up) in preparation for when I get a 360 to play Bioshock.
topgeargorilla's Destructoid Blog
Cowzilla, I can see your point, and I do agree that one day I should play Halo. At this point, (barely a junior in college) I have more important things to do than invest hundreds of hours making up on missed games. I mean, it's a whole lot easier to catch up on five ground breaking movies than five ground breaking games. And the cost is more, with anywhere from 3 or more very expensive consoles and a state of the art computer.

Here's how I see it: I want to be a games journalist. I specialize in News and Features. Not reviews. If I start reviewing (which brings its own set of moral qualms that I have with myself), and I review a FPS, then I better play Halo. Without a doubt.

I see your point, and I agree, but the industry isn't quite locked into reviews. There is more to it than that.
Bus's Destructoid Blog
The difficulty in this being a reality is the sheer length of games. It's perfectly reasonable to watch every film Alfred Hitchcock ever made in a week or so. The same could not be said for the oeuvre of Shigeru Miyamoto or the like.

Also, a reviewer acknowledging their lack of knowledge of previous games is just like Roger Ebert panning "I Know What You Did Last Summer" because he despises Dead Teenager Movies. Everyone approaches media in a different way but, as long as the reviewer is honest about what condition they approach a piece in, it's still honest criticism.


prev next


Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

 about me

Hi,
Names Matt Razak and I'm just a gamer with a Wii and a 360. I'm also really, really, really, ridiculously good looking and a ninja...and humble. If you haven't noticed from my selfless self promoting or my Monday reviews I'm a film critic for a living at a local newspaper in Northern Virginia. I write at That VideoGame Blog but my heart will always belong to D-toid.

Right now I'm working on these games:
Mario Kart Wii


Things I've Done or Am Doing

Front Paged
Music In Gaming
What is a Hero?: Sonic
Good Idea, Bad Idea: Casual Gaming
What No More Heroes Really Means
Social Activism in Gaming
Educate Yourself - Castlevania
Start of the Affair
What is a Hero?: Lara Croft
Wii Fit Review

Recognizing Your Gaming Journalist
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3

Drinks Ron Workman Can't Handle
Metroid Mojito
Mario Mudslide, The Super Punch Out, Princess Peach Schnapps
Pikachu Punch, Triforce Triple
DK Daquiri, Yoshi Jager, Mother Brain Drain (MBD)
Rocks on the Scotch, Bowser Bad Ass

Interviews With Famous People
Nick Frost, Simon Pegg, Edgar Wright
Richard Shepard
Michael Davis
Jason Schwartzman

What Happened?
The First
My Favorite One
To be continued...?
Obviously there are tons more, but I'm not linking them all.

Interesting Walls of Text
Gaming Journalsim
How do we discuss games as art?
MAGFest
My Great Concern



What is a Hero?
Introduction
Link
Solid Snake
Mario
Samus
Master Chief

Educate Yourself
Kid Icarus
Kid Icarus Final Impressions
Splatterhouse
Splatterhouse Final Impressions
Fall Out

 xbox 360 gamertag
 mii friend code:
4283 6222 8765 8660

 friends' updates
A New Challenger's Profile A New Challenger
Life Meter: Video game comic anthology accepting submissions
BahamutZero's Profile BahamutZero
Pachter's dumber than a bag of rocks, buy Borderlands.
BlindsideDork's Profile BlindsideDork
Leaked Transformers: RotF trailer #2 = YES PLEASE!
Butmac's Profile Butmac
Live with Butmac makes it's return
Char Aznable's Profile Char Aznable
Niero Whupped Superman's Ass
Coonskin05's Profile Coonskin05
Improving game communites: No Apparent Reason Parties
Count Grishnack's Profile Count Grishnack
Duels of the Planeswalkers trial impressions (from a former MTG junkie)
Cowzilla3's Profile Cowzilla3
Monday Review: Drag Me to Hell
CronosBlade's Profile CronosBlade
360 Paradise Wednesday Week 2 - 10PM EST
DanGale's Profile DanGale
Dtoid Discusses: UK Dtoiders visit Capcom
dgenerate's Profile dgenerate
ATTN Toronto Area: Free VGL Show Saturday!!
DtoidBaltimoreDC's Profile DtoidBaltimoreDC
Ready to get your FEST ON?
DynamicSheep's Profile DynamicSheep
Fails at blogging.
Excremento's Profile Excremento
A Weird Kid's Top 10 -- NES Games That You Had To Leave on All-Night To Beat
FAILCAST's Profile FAILCAST
Failcast episode 52 records tonight; A wild Abra appears!
flameon4444's Profile flameon4444
PROTON CANNON! HD Iron Man trailer now firing repulsor rays of awesome in your general direction.
Hamza CTZ Aziz's Profile Hamza CTZ Aziz
Winners of the Magnacarta 2 contest!
HarassmentPanda's Profile HarassmentPanda
Review: Magic the Gathering - Duels of the Planeswalkers
Hitogoroshi's Profile Hitogoroshi
Catching up on Bru-Ray Releases.
Jim Sterling's Profile Jim Sterling
Now you can buy an official BioShock EVE Hypo
Johnny Blaze's Profile Johnny Blaze
Happy Birthday,Graduation and Departure from D-Toid
Jonathan Holmes's Profile Jonathan Holmes
New game from Hatsworth devs brings cookies and violence
king3vbo's Profile king3vbo
Why I Love Destructoid
kwaselow's Profile kwaselow
Faptoid 1. Why ask for directions when we can just use Google Faps?
LethalHairdo's Profile LethalHairdo
Manliness, Video Games, and You -- Lv. 6: The Contra Duo
LordRegulus's Profile LordRegulus
Professionalism: Dead or Comatose?
Morrius's Profile Morrius
Littlebigplanet hilariously delayed in Europe
Mxyzptlk's Profile Mxyzptlk
Castle Crashers Outtakes [Throw a Bale Temper Tantrum Contest Entry]
Necros's Profile Necros
Cheesy Double Down (fixed!)
Nick Chester's Profile Nick Chester
Creator talks ten years of Asheron's Call, future of MMOs
Niero's Profile Niero
Have a microphone? Want to participate in a Destructoid video?
NihonTiger90's Profile NihonTiger90
What'd You Get? - Little Bikes Edition
power-glove's Profile power-glove
The PAX moment I will never live down
Riser Glen's Profile Riser Glen
Thanks for being my Neighbor, DToid
Rockvillian's Profile Rockvillian
I Suck at Games: Negative Reinforcement Negatively Reinforces Everything
russiaisHERE's Profile russiaisHERE
GiA: What is a Game?
shipero's Profile shipero
PS3 Friday Night Fights: Here Ya Go
Snaileb 's Profile Snaileb
I've been having a blast, but miss you too, Dtoid!
soul3150's Profile soul3150
Just because I could run screaming into the street waving my genitals about doesn't mean I will.
tazarthayoot's Profile tazarthayoot
Top 10 reasons it's Samit's birthday
the GAMEGOBLIN's Profile the GAMEGOBLIN
My bestest buddy, UnstoppableJuggernaut
The GHost's Profile The GHost
Why I Love Destructoid
Tiff's Profile Tiff
Post-PAX Love & Farewell to Destructoid (for now)
Topher Cantler's Profile Topher Cantler
Trailer for SSFIV's new modes, now in English
Tristero's Profile Tristero
BREAKING: New Punch-Out character leaked
Tron Knotts's Profile Tron Knotts
Rumortoid: Play as Shooting Star Mega Man in next Monday's DLC
Upgrayedd's Profile Upgrayedd
Packing for PAX
VWGTI's Profile VWGTI
Go out and buy Borderlands. Right now.
ZombiePlatypus's Profile ZombiePlatypus
Why I love Destructoid...


 

 
  get involved

register or login
post a blog
post a forum
enter a contest
contribute a news tip
suggest a feature
be a guest editor
support

new member's guide
login assistance
tech support
report abuse
email our editors
read our dev blog
nuclear crisis?
keep in touch

RSS feed
Twitter
Facebook
Myspace
Flickr
Game nights
Meetup+play online
seriously

about Destructoid
advertising
terms of use
privacy policy
jobs at MM
buy our crap
our network

Tomopop
Japanator
Despingation?




Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
living the dream since March 16, 2006