hot  /  reviews  /  videos  /  cblogs  /  qposts

FRESH MEAT  
|   FROM OUR COMMUNITY BLOGS

CommanderZx2's blog


7:37 AM on 07.13.2015

Follow up on the 'Survey'

To follow up on my previous blog Surveys, lies and false naratives, Charlie, Ashly, and Rosalind have now admitted that their survey wasn't a rigorous academic survey and claim that it was never supposed to be treated as such.

 

We stated at the Game Developers Conference (GDC) and in the TIME article that this survey was exploratory or a “convenience” sample that was meant to generate conversations and encourage others in the field to continue this research in more thorough ways. We have never claimed that this is a rigorous academic survey, nor that it should be treated as such.

 Source: https://archive.is/RkVMD

 

They're still claiming that although their survey was sent via Twitter and Facebook, that it was mostly received by teachers who gave it to their pupils. I found this doubtful as surveymonkey submissions are anonymous and anyone can fill them in.

 

And now for a compliation of "Students"

http://i.imgur.com/ZU5fGrg.png 

http://i.imgur.com/Wyn0qxq.png 

http://i.imgur.com/yjsfCNQ.png 

http://i.imgur.com/kG3XzET.png 

http://i.imgur.com/M22WEL7.png 

http://i.imgur.com/OreQ1P1.png

http://i.imgur.com/8dpd5Rh.png 

  read


2:12 PM on 07.10.2015

Surveys, lies and false naratives

The most recent idiotic spree around the internet has been this trash Everything You Know About Boys and Video Games Is Wrong and every moron has been jumping to repost it without doing even the slightest investigation or questioning on it. 

1,400 middle and high school students were surveyed about gender representation in games (amongst other topics) by Rosalind Wiseman, Charlie Kuhn, and Ashly Burch -- co-star of Hey Ash Whatcha Playin'?, the show that got its start right here on Dtoid and is now being funded on Patreon. The group calls the survey exploratory and not a thorough evaluation, but believes it is an important area to study. 

Interesting claim there, how do they know they surveyed students or even how old are they are when they never even met them in person? That's right this was an online survey via www.surveymonkey.com that was only spread through Burch's and Wiseman's Twitter and Facebook feeds. How likely are you to get accurate survey result when you got a pre-existing audience who already agrees with your biases and you have no way of truly identifying those that have completed it?

Doing surveys via free websites is completely pointless and obtains nothing of use. Anyone can fill them in and put in any information they want, they're also extremely easy to exploit. Here we have people creating an easy to fill in survey and spreading it only to their friends while claiming the results represent young students.

 https://archive.is/nXrE5

https://archive.is/zRVEH

https://archive.is/faWHy

https://archive.is/5EvNG

 

  read


5:14 PM on 07.06.2013

Digital Feminism - A tale of jealousy

Jealousy is at the heart of the current trend of hatred against beautiful female characters in games.†

Men and women are genetically programmed to seek out better, healthier and younger partners and they know it. This is what makes them extremely jealous of anyone of the same sex who is physically superior or successful to them.

For example take a middle aged couple, the wife walks into a bar and sees her husband sitting next to and talking to a young female super model. What are her first thoughts?
A. That cheating bastard!
or
B. Probably just another bar patron.

Of course her immediate thought is that he is cheating on her with this girl by simply talking to her.†

An easy example for men is Justin Bieber, men are extremely jealous of his success and how women throw themselves at him regardless of his lack of musical talent. This is what has lead males to hate this guy and other popular young male singers and boy bands.

Due to the advancement of graphics game characters can look extremely realistic and beautiful. Men and women are spending more time than ever interacting with digital media rather than with each other, whether it be phones, tablets, consoles or computers. Women see that these female digital characters have far higher sex appeal than they could ever possibly hope to achieve with their unrealistic proportions and perfect skin.

Women become jealous of the digital female characters who are stealing the attention of their mates or potential mates. Finding they cannot change the hobbies of males they've pushed for sex-negative campaigns against digital female characters to try and stifle their sex appeal and hope to receive more direct attention from males in return.

The men joining the cause are simply doing so to be seen as apathetic and gain attention from the women.   read


7:14 AM on 06.06.2013

Is there such a thing as a perfect 10 game?

Today I was looking over the review scores of The Last of Us and I am extremely disappointed to find almost 30 perfect 10 scores. Now I realise that reviews and scores are subjective based on opinion, but is any game truly flawless?

In these perfect 10 reviews they all list flaws for the game such as NPCs being invisible to enemies. Destructoid attempts to excuse this away saying it is ďan acceptable anomalyĒ. This seems bizarre to me when the entire premise of the game is your mission to protect and escort this girl, but suddenly this is thrown out the window for convenience? I think that Resident Evil 4 handled it much better with Ashley, as you had to keep a constant eye on her at times putting yourself into danger while you shoot the enemies attacking her.

I see reviewers throwing out perfect 10s as them tossing away their Reviewer status and joining the fanboy/girl club. If I had to compile a top 10 list of my favourite games of all time I would not give a single one a 10, as I acknowledge that none of them are perfect.

I see that Destructoid has a caveat regarding 10s stating: Games rated 10 aren't perfect, since nothing is, but they come as close as you could get in a given genre. The new must-have game in its sector, we're talking pure ecstasy.

My response to this is that if it isnít flawless it isnít a 10, thatís what 9.9, 9.8, 9.7, etc is for.

Personally I wish weíd do away with scores entirely from the entire gaming review sector. Instead of a score the review should just be ended with a basic recommendation summary.   read


6:33 PM on 01.30.2013

Storage space and false advertising

A common trend since the event of portable media players and other such devices is that they have been rated by their total storage space. Originally this wasn't much of a problem, as barely any of that space had been consumed by system functionality.

However lately the device's operating system and applications have begun to consume so much of the storage space that the rating used to advertise the product has become misleading in how far it is off of the actual available space for the consumer.

Some examples:
Microsoft surface Pro - Advertised as 64GB - actual free space 23GB
iPad Mini - advertised as 16Gb - actual free space 13GB
Nexus 7 - advertised as 8GB - actual free space 5.9GB
iPod Touch - advertised as 8GB - actual free space 6.5GB

I feel that corporations should be forced to advertise their products based on the actual available free space on the device. That way when you advertise a device as 8GB then you should expect to a receive a device that has 8GB of free storage to use.

If we enforce such a rule industry wide this will definitely benefit consumers in the following ways:
1. When you buy an 8GB music player, you'll get 8GB of storage. i.e. you get exactly what is expected.

2. It'll discourage suppliers from installing shovelware and other junk on the device, as it'll come as a cost to them rather than take up the consumers storage space. Because they will be forced to increase the size of the storage in order to house the additional junk without taking away from the rated storage.

3. Companies will be encouraged to think smarter about how they design the systems installed on the device, to make them consume less space.


Some of you may be saying "you never get the rated size from a new computer hard drive, as you have to format to use it". That's completely different to this, as a system builder you are buying a HDD in a clean slate and know that you have to format it and install stuff to be able to use it.

In the case of these products you are buying a final product, with a rated storage, however the companies know full well ahead of time that you will never have access the amount of space they are advertising it to have.   read





Back to Top


We follow moms on   Facebook  and   Twitter
  Light Theme      Dark Theme
Pssst. Konami Code + Enter!
You may remix stuff our site under creative commons w/@
- Destructoid means family. Living the dream, since 2006 -