Quantcast
Community Discussion: Blog by Caitlin Cooke | And now, for something completely differentDestructoid
LIGHTS:  ON | OFF
surf dtoid with arrow keys



REMOVE ALL ADS?
Guaranteed contest entry?
A new video show?
Something else?

Vote in our membership poll


Meet the destructoid Team >>   Caitlin Cooke
Caitlin Cooke's blog
★ destructoid | Contributor ★
click to hide banner header
About
Dtoid's sporadic review, preview and features writer. Co-host of Weekend Escape with Brett Zeidler on dtoid.tv, 12pm PST on Sat. "Without the looming consequence of death, is this even science?"

Cait @ 8
Player Profile
Xbox LIVE:Six is a Robot
PSN ID:Caiters
Follow me:
Twitter:@Caitbit
Google+:Link
Twitch.TV:Caitbit's Channel
Caitlin Cooke's sites
Badges
Following (61)  


Seems like the cupcake battle has an even distribution of chocolate vs vanilla lovers. Personally, I adore chocolate, but there's nothing like a warm vanilla cupcake with light, whipped chocolate frosting...pure, delicious heaven.

Aaaaanyway, as I mentioned in my previous post I'd like to give you all a blast from the past. I'm not going to talk about the best games of 2010 because I think it's pretty obvious who won (Prison Break: The Conspiracy -- duh). So instead, I'm going to share a list I've been compiling for quite some time but never really showed anyone except for a few friends.

About this time last year, a bunch of blogs and game related sites were talking about the top 10 games of the decade. I thought it'd be fun to make my own list, but not just a boring "top whatever" list. I wanted real categories (with strippers! and hookers!) to put games under, because, well -- don't they deserve it?

So without further ado, here is my completely biased list of games that I feel were the best of the decade (2000-2009):

Best Puzzle Game: Portal



What's not to love about this game? You've got a companion cube, the promise of cake, a kick-ass gun that allows you to hop through portals, and the world's most psychotic AI: GLaDOS. The levels are amusing, and I adore GLaDOS's crazy ramblings while I attempt to solve the puzzles. I personally think the credits song also deserves to win a category of its own (but then again I also think Jonathan Coulton deserves a Grammy of some variety).

Best Cinematography/Artistic Design: Shadow of the Colossus



I'm not even sure if it's possible for a game to have true "Cinematography", but if it is then Shadow of the Colossus would win. The overall atmosphere, lighting, feel...everything about this game takes my breath away. In fact, this game is so beautiful that sometimes I spend hours just exploring the world and riding around on my faithful steed, Agro. Nobody can deny how cool the giant colossi are -- and how sad you feel when you kill one.

Best Shoot-Em-Up Game: Resident Evil 4



Maybe I should have filed this under "Best Stress Relief EVER" because damn I love me some zombie shootin'. RE4 has it all for a shooter -- insane replay value, zombies, an interesting plot, and an annoying sidekick! I don't think any video game greeting has had quite the run as "'ello strangah!" has. Now if they could only do something about that inventory system...

Most Addicting Game: Peggle



This game is so addicting that I bought it twice (well, thrice if you count Peggle Nights). Shoot a ball, it clink clinkity clinks against colored pegs, and finally falls into a pit. I could do this forever. Peggle is like the Tetris of the 00's, you can't get enough and before you know it you see pegs floating around and your brain is looping Ode to Joy . The quirky levels, silly characters, and endlessly frustrating game play makes this the most addicting in my book.

Best Cult Game: Katamari Damacy (& Sequels)



Katamari Damacy...how do I even begin to praise this game and every sequel that came after it? I can't really think of anything else to say besides ROYAL RAINBOW! The soundtracks to these games are absolutely amazing. In fact, and this is going to sound ridiculous, but a third of my senior thesis in college focused on the music from this game alone. I've found that anyone who has picked this game up falls in love; even my mother even finds this game completely adorable.

Most Nostalgic Game: Neverwinter Nights



Ah, NWN...this little gem kept me up until the wee hours of the night throughout high school. For a lot of gamers it was our first in-depth exposure to the D&D world and also a great outlet for creating custom levels that you could share with other friends. The plot, character builds, and graphics were amazing for the time, and Bioware has continued using the engine for many games since (including another classic that I should have mentioned somewhere on this list: Knights of the Old Republic). I find myself crawling back to this game every couple of years or so to feed my late night RPG cravings.

Best Game Overall: Mass Effect



No contest. EDIT: Alright, here is my explanation: This game (to me) is a beautiful blend of RPG and action with a great story, lots of history, and fantastic characters. I felt like if I didn't have a controller in my hand, that I was watching some kind of epic movie. That it hit some kind of peak in my brain -- that "this is it" feeling. ME2 improved quite a bit from the original (especially the combat system) but I can't really rank that here because it came out right at the beginning of 2010.

Honorable Mention: Indigo Prophecy (Fahrenheit)




Indigo Prophecy, created by French developer Quantic Dream, is truly one of a kind. This is the first video game I played that actually made me think hard about the decisions I made, about how they would affect the other characters and what the end results would be. This definitely would have been at the top of my list if it weren't for the rushed release date, resulting in one of those horrible "what the fresh hell just happened" endings..

So, now that you've had a full year to reflect on your own personal list, are your winners still the same? Do you have any categories of your own?

And if you're yearning for some "real" top 10 lists, here are a few:

Techland
Bit Rebels
AV Club
SF Gate



Is this blog awesome? Vote it up!




Those who have come:



Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.

Legacy Comments (will be imported soon)


Could you explain WHY Mass Effect is no contest? With all of the other ones, I can see why you picked them, but what is really the most important one has nothing backing it up.
If you mention Katamari one more time I might be tempted to marry you.

Just so you know.
@rexwolf2 - Have you played them? It seems obvious to fans of the series.

@Caiters - You had me slowly raising a fist in victory with your Resident Evil 4 shout out, but I quickly reeled it back in when I read "Peggle is like the Tetris of the 00's". Heavens no. Peggle is like the Beanie Babies of the 00's.
@rexwolf2

Great story, memorable characters, deep character development and interaction, unique settings and weapons, exploring the galaxy and stuff, meaningful decisions that affect said developments, even in the sequels...I could go on.
You're right -- it does deserve an explanation. I was just being lazy. It's up there now.

Turtle dude -- Peggle is like my crack (although Plants vs Zombies is slowly taking its place). Maybe I'm over exaggerating by comparing it to Tetris -- but what would you say is more addicting in terms of a simple puzzle game?
I almost withdrew my fap when you called out Peggle. If there were a noticeable amount of skill involved with playing that game, I'd probably feel some of the draw, but as it stands... nope.

Good call on Indigo Prophecy, though. I was really impressed by it, though it seems few others were.
@rexwolf2: I have to echo the others sentiments here. Just a brilliant series that, while having some hiccups, is just fucking brilliant with the story and characters.

@Corduroy_Turtle: HAHA! I have to agree but I think we are showing our age and curmudgeonly ways a bit.

@Caiters: Nice list. Lotta fun, memorable games up there. Tried Peggle but it bored me. Diff'n Strokes.
If you don't think Peggle involves any amount of skill, I do recommend you try the insane challenges -- I've cleared mostly all of the challenges minus these ones (last ball is the only one I could manage to get). The main game is a piece of cake, though, I will admit.
Neverwinter Nights... yeah, it still stands out as an awesome game! (though I liked Baldur's Gate: Shadows of Amn a little bit more).
@Everybody telling me why Mass Effect is so awesome (mostly Corduroy Turtle): Well, in case you were wondering, I wasn't diminishing Mass Effect in any way. I have not played a single second of either game, but nearly everything that I've heard about it has sounded fantastic. If I ever get a 360, PS3, or gaming computer, Mass Effect will be one of the first series that I check out.
Portal is a Puzzle game? Damn and this whole time I thought it was a reflection of society as a whole, forever yearning for that piece of cake that will never be. The companion cube representing that one friend you don't like.
....how could you not like the companion cube?
@SephirothX

you kill it, you kill it dead. Only the best of friends stick it out, so clearly there had been a rift brewing between The 'cube and Chell.
I'm glad your Games of the Decade list managed to fit in Portal and Shadow of the Colossus, because for all my best efforts I couldn't squeeze them into mine without losing anything even more vital! Can't agree with Resi 4 though, I found it got quite repetitive once leaving the village and substituted much of the classic RE atmosphere and tension for more generic shooting. Good game, but far from mindblowing in my opinion.
Indigo Prophecy is the bro
Portal?? I really wish I could have liked that game as much as everyone else did....
You guys don't like PEGGLE????
How do you not feel awesome every time you finish a level? Also, yeah it get hard.
Nice list.
What is this Peggle everyone seems so flustered about?
You know, I'd laugh at the Prison Break joke, but inevitably I will end up playing that game because I like TV[//url] [url=http://www.destructoid.com/blogs/Stevil/the-forgotten-a-gamer-obscura-special-the-x-files-fmv-game-148572.phtml]tie-ins.

*shakes head*
Crap let me try that again.
Best puzzle game ever? Tetris Attack (not Tetris, as I'm sure you're aware). I need to blog about that one.

Back to Top
DLC   |   BEST Games of 2012   |   Best PC Games   |   Best PS3 Games   |   Best Xbox 360 Games   |   Best Wii U Games   |   Best 3DS Games




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more