Destructoid Logo
Returning members: Login      New to Dtoid?   REGISTER NOW and join our community of gamers -- you might win these things. Its all free and takes sec.

Did you know? Destructoid is independently owned and updated by a tight group of friends, most which met online. Drop us a line and keep us busy.
 

    all updates

   pc    xbox 360     wii    ps3    ps2    psp    ds    retro    mobile    indie

top searches:
grand theft auto IV   wiiware
age of conan   metal gear 4

New Posts
Best of the week
Contests
Reviews

 

PC
 
BioWare removes 10-day validation from Mass Effect PC due to backlash
BioWare removes 10-day validation from Mass Effect PC due to backlash screenshot
Jim Sterling
\\ 05.09.2008
41 comments

A few days ago we posted an article about the PC versions of Mass Effect and Spore containing some worrying copy protection methods that would require users to validate each game online every ten days. While I expressed concern that such a move could go horribly wrong, others were more vocal -- chief among them the BioWare fans who absolutely railed against the somewhat harsh measures.

Well, BioWare has said it listened "very closely" to the fans (though really, you didn't need a hearing aid to register such fury from PC gamers) and has now opted to back away from the incredibly strict authentication methods. Mass Effect will now only require validation when you first run the game and when you download additional content. How about that, eh? Kicking your legs around and screaming actually works sometimes!

From BioWare's FAQ on the matter: 

BioWare has always listened very closely to its fans and we made this decision to ensure we are delivering the best possible experience to them. To all the fans including our many friends in the armed services and internationally who expressed concerns that they would not be able re-authenticate as often as required, EA and BioWare want you to know that your feedback is important to us.

So there you have it. One of those rare moments of victory for the consumer, and an easier validation process for any PC gamers looking to buy Mass Effect. One can only imagine that Spore will similarly back out of this verification process, but that remains to be seen.



41 COMMENTS, LATEST BY Hexen525
It's not the "dialing home" every 10 days I care about, it's the 3 install rule. What if you reformat your system? HDD crashes? New computer? Not many games in my collection that haven't been ins... -    view discussion




There are 41 comments about this post:
Mxyzptlk's Avatar
Good for them. Ball's in your court, Maxis.
brainderailment's Avatar
Yeah, that was bullcrap, though you can't blame them for trying to overcome the pirates. They should just know that it'll be cracked regardless.
Eschatos's Avatar
Hot damn. They've just earned a sale from me.
DaedHead8's Avatar
Spore had better back out. I actually plan on buying that one.
Sasquatch's Avatar
ARRRR There be Pirates.....no wait.....Shit It's all our pissed off customers......run away run away
Jetsetlemming's Avatar
I think I might just buy a copy of Mass Effect. When's it coming out again?
Wookiee's Avatar
Damn. I dug my old torch and pitchfork out for nothing...
Neonie's Avatar
I know how you feel wookie, I have my Sythe all ready to go.
ajaxender's Avatar
Wow. Now all they have to do is make the NZ price reasonable (~$70) and they may have another sale.
unangbangkay's Avatar
Maxis, being owned by EA, has also put the Spore car in reverse, they backed out and the same scheme will be executed as for Mass Effect PC, with 3 licenses, a first-time online authentication, and a re-authentication when downloading patches or DLC.It's the same as the SecuROM a lot of people have been boycotting for a while now, but at least it's a victory...of sorts.

Personally I was never going to boycott the games, but that was the whole problem with EA piggybacking this bullshit with high-profile guaranteed sellers would've established a nasty precedent. So I and a lot of folks complained as hard as we fucking could. It seems to have worked, sorta.
Jiffylube's Avatar
This is a step in the wrong direction
Boolean's Avatar
So Bioware was behind the idea? I thought EA was the ones who cooked the copy protection idea up. Maybe all the "zomg EA ruins another company" accusations were a bit early.

(side note: EA still blows)
Dagerr's Avatar
The Only install 3 times is still there though, making this a non purchase for me, since I wipe my comp clean every 3-6 months to optimize performance.
Shin Oni's Avatar
Kicking your legs around and screaming actually works sometimes!

This so reminded me of Stewie in Family Guy bitching and whining on the airplane.

WhAAAAAAA! WHAAAA!
Sam Spectre's Avatar
Predictable. I don't think ANYONE who plays PC games was too happy about this.
KaL_YoshiKa's Avatar
Crisis Averted..but for how long?
Jetsetlemming's Avatar
@Dagerr: The activations are for three SIMULTANEOUS installs. When you uninstall the game you regain an activation. If your computer dies or something so it can't be properly uninstalled, there's a program that can regain the installations, and you can get the same effect through EA customer support. Just as long as you uninstall the game before wiping your computer and reinstalling everything, you'll be absolutely fine, and won't even use more than a single activation.
RJG's Avatar
This is good news. I still have to crack the SecuROM protection, because it doesn't work with my hardware, but at least Bioware are listening.

Hopefully EA don't whip Bioware too badly for going against their master's wishes.
Velt's Avatar
Look, i live in south america, I wont get it throught legal ways anyway... maybe if its realeased on steam: then i can pay for it.
But they will crack it anyway, we all know it, they know it, so then why make the consumer experience shit? The guy who actually payed for the game should not stand that shit.
PaperBowser0's Avatar
Well, at least bioware is listening to what people are saying and trying to make it a LITTLE better, oh and Wookiee, put the torch away, you almost lit me on fire! >_<
unangbangkay's Avatar
@JiffyLube - "This is a step in the wrong direction"

How so? I understand that devs and publishers caving to community pressure may have repercussions for game design, but that's what focus groups and game testers do all the time, lol.

@Boolean - "So Bioware was behind the idea?"

Naw, it was an EA decision. It's the publisher that usually makes the decision regarding distribution and copy protection. The fact that this was extended to Spore revealed that. This is speculation, but EA likely let Derek French, Bioware's technical producer, make the announcement because they figured fans would be more likely to take it up the butt if their beloved devs trumpeted "hay guys, this is great, take our advice". Thankfully we didn't.
BlackSunEmpire's Avatar
Along with the recent 'pay for more guns' plan that EA had going, it seems they have an agenda for putting ideas into games which are going to have bad long term consequences once the precedent is set.

Also, @ajaxender, its a PC game, just import it, it will cost you less than $70 that way.
KamikazeTutor's Avatar
Very well done. If the game had a multiplayer mode, they would have a reason for such validation method.
But even that, a 10 day limit is stupid, basically do as every other online game does, validate it the minute it connects to the web.
I just hope that developers don't forget to, someday in the future, release a patch for that really old game, removing its copy protection. I mean, when most of the modern population and its technology is dissipated, if I survive, I still want to play my Steam games and BioShock for a bit.
AliasWyvernspur's Avatar
Yea, but will it still use SecuROM? If so, fuck 'em. Once or every 10 days, doesn't matter. I don't want extra software on my system and I'm not buying their shit.
Itchy's Avatar
I really hope PC gaming doesn't die because of piracy, and if this is what it takes? I'm willing to cooperate.
Wexx's Avatar
Itchy: It won't die because of piracy, much like the movie industry and the music industry haven't died because of piracy. Generally people who pirate a game had no intention to buy it in the first place, thereby not effecting the sales, and the company doesn't lose any money. The developers just don't understand that if their product is good, their hardcore fans will still buy it.
unangbangkay's Avatar
@AliasWyvernspur

Yes, it still uses SecuROM. If you're still boycotting it, don't stop yet. Or pirate, I don't care.
Timmeh's Avatar
I wish all the braindead morons that keep trying to force this DRM shit on us would die in a plane accident or something.

Honestly, anybody with access to the internet can see that, regardles of any copy protection, virtually every game is released in the warez scene either on or before the street date.

Now, someone of normal intelligence might conclude pissing off customers with ineffective anti-piracy measures to be fruitless and harmful. This in mind, why is it that people earning hundreds of thousands a year with a bunch of business degrees and shit can't see this?
solarmystic's Avatar
A rare victory for the consumer indeed... anyone remember the Bioshock debacle with Take 2 anyone?

EA better cut the crap and can the BS before the consumers engage in a mass exodus...
adultswim810's Avatar
HOOORAY!! although there copy protection did work. beyond 48 hrs past release and still no torrent. nice job Bioware!
adultswim810's Avatar
but i do wish that they released it on steam... simply because i love steam.
Timmeh's Avatar
HOOORAY!! although there copy protection did work. beyond 48 hrs" past release and still no torrent. nice job Bioware!"

Newsflash, they delayed the US version to 28 May and EU to 6 June, that is why there is nothing floating around the torrent sites.

So no, it didn't work. And it won't work, just like every other protection method ever.
Professor Pew's Avatar
Good news!

@adultswim810: it's not even in stores yet, why would it be 48 hours past release?
AlucardX24's Avatar
<3 bioware
adultswim810's Avatar
Nvm my bad i must've read an old post on the mass effect website. It said the seventh. -_-
Jiffylube's Avatar
@unangbangkay

EA/Bioware have a responsibility to their stockholders to sell as many copies of this game as they possibly can. Internet boycotting is all well and good, 'Sweet, I can send out anonymous blog messages and do my little part to change the industry.'. People who pay for Media should be crying for effective DRM. The real message the community needs to be sending is 'Piracy is insulting to the stockholder, the paying consumer, and the developing staff. I'm all for DRM, but this can't be our last option.'
Reallynotnick's Avatar
Makes perfect sense to me, install the game verify it, download additional content while and then verify it again (you are online so no big deal).
Though of course I would rather have no DRM at all so I can install it on whatever and not have to deal with this crap.
brainpower4's Avatar
Is it just me, or does spore download "new content" every day, when you get access to other people's planets. So now, rather than checking ever ten days it checks every time you boot up the game?
Timmeh's Avatar
@Jiffylube

No we shouldn't be saying "I'm all for DRM" at all. You can just fuck off with that dipshit mentality, seriously.

All DRM does is inconvenience the end user and infringe on consumer rights.

What we should be saying is "Make your product appear more attractive than downloading a pirated version and going through the sometimes ballsachey process of getting it to work".

If, when buying CD (remember kids, you're only paying for a license to play anyway) you were given an MP3 version along with the higher quality CD track, or when downloading from iTunes ALL music was DRM free and didn't have stupid ass restrictions on what you could do, music piracy would start to become less prevalent.

It's a fucking joke that downloading pirated MP3's is LESS hassle than getting a legit version. We should be saying "Add value to your product", telling people "add restrictions to your products" is goddamn retarded.
GunnyHath's Avatar
The fact is, no matter the protection it will still be pirated. It adds up to an annoyance to the end user, the gamer and consumer, as Timmeh pointed out.
Even the most invasive protection (ie: Starforce) was broken eventually, and this SecuROM is even easier.

The only thing they can do (and only sometimes) is prevent the pirate copies from playing online, because of cd key checking. So unless its an MMO, it's going to be pirated, they just need to think about acceptable losses when they make a game, and give up with the copy protection, aside from simple protection to keep your average joe from burning copies for his friends.

I would have bought Mass Effect with the 10 day reactivation, because they would have to make it fairly transparent anyway. But it would suck badly for those with dialup or no internet. On the other hand, if you can afford a PC that runs Mass Effect, chances are you can afford 30-40 a month for broadband.
Hexen525's Avatar
It's not the "dialing home" every 10 days I care about, it's the 3 install rule. What if you reformat your system? HDD crashes? New computer? Not many games in my collection that haven't been installed more than 3 times. Hell, I still run Diablo 1 and Deus Ex on all my machines(new computer every year, this year it was a new laptop). I don't want ot be told I am not allowed to play my game on my new computer.

You must be logged in to post a comment. Click here to login or create a user account now.

DTOID TOP 5 - May 16, 2008
Artsy fartsy Mirror's Edge artwork for your fapping delight
(49599 views, 81 comments)
3Feel Online - Multiplayer Sex Game
(33318 views, 23 comments)
The best videogame moms EVER!
(18963 views, 83 comments)
And now for your daily WTF: The realistic Pikachu
(18066 views, 83 comments)
Weekend WTF: The realistic Sonic the Hedgehog
(17712 views, 63 comments)
more top stories

Post a new community blog
This month's theme:
"If you love it, change it"
Best of the community this week
Game with us: Friday Night Fights
Meet Dtoiders near you

DTOID CONTEST ALERTS
Contest: Win a chance to play Assault Heroes 2 with the game's developers!
Big fat raffle: Win one of 100 Deca Sports demo discs for the Wii
Win a PlayStation 3 and Casino Royale on Blu-Ray by playing Bond: Top Agent
The winners of the Insecticide contest announced
Dtoid iron-on patches now available. Win ten of them right now!
MORE CONTEST ALERTS

DTOID PODCASTS
Podtoid 53: The Blogocube
No RetroforceGO! this week, you make Mikuru cry
Podcastle: Dtoid's UK video game podcast
download back episodes


LATEST GAME REVIEWS
Boom Blox
Fatal Fury: Battle Archives Volume 2
Teenage Zombies: Invasion of the Alien Brain Thingys!
R-Type Command
NBA Ballers: Chosen One
Persona 3: FES
Mario Kart Wii
Battle of the Bands
all Dtoid reviews

ORIGINAL COLUMNS
Games Time Forgot by Anthony Burch
Bargain Bin Laden by Jim Sterling
The Memory Card by Chad Concelmo
Indie Nation by Anthony Burch
Friday Night Fights by Grim
An RPG draws near by Colette Bennett
You're the man now dog by Hamza Aziz
Nerdcore Culture by Dtoid Staff
Debate to the death by Tom Fronczak
Monday mind teasers by Tom Fronczak
Miniboss Monday by Mike Ferry
Art Attack Friday by Tiffany Chow
Best of the week by Hamza Aziz
Weekend reading by Brad Rice

XBOX 360 NEWS
Xbox 360 Spring Showcase: Hands-on with Too Human
Developer game notes: Top Spin 3
2K Sports reveals Rick Nash to be NHL 2K9 cover athlete
Too Human demo in the works? You better believe it
Xbox 360 Spring Showcase: Taking a stroll through Gears of War 2 with CliffyB
New Madden 09 trailer is painful to watch...because it's all about tackles
Xbox 360 Spring Showcase: Hands-on with Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
Kid steals dad's credit card, buys videogames, hookers, and blow
more Xbox 360 games, news and reviews


NINTENDO WII NEWS
MadWorld: The most awesomely violent Wii experience yet
Taiko no Tatsujin coming to the Wii, I take off my pants
Nintendo ordered to pay $21 million for patent infringement
Fun for the whole family: Cornholing comes to the Wii
Lil' Sims returning to Wii and DS with MySims Kingdom
WiiWare first impressions: LostWinds (double time!)
WiiWare first impressions: My Life as a King
Destructoid review: Boom Blox
more Wii games, news and reviews


PLAYSTATION 3 NEWS
Developer game notes: Top Spin 3
2K Sports reveals Rick Nash to be NHL 2K9 cover athlete
New Madden 09 trailer is painful to watch...because it's all about tackles
Sony adds YouTube support for developers
PS3 owners, go download system software v2.35
Overdue: Hot Shots Golf gets new characters
Way to go, advertising geniuses....meet 'Thumbcock'
Believe: Assassin's Solid is real
more PS3 games, news and reviews


PC NEWS
WoW expansion coming this year...polar bear mounts included?
Velvet Assassin slated for release this fall on Xbox 360, PC
She hasn't put clothes on yet: New X-Blades screenshots
BioWare removes 10-day validation from Mass Effect PC due to backlash
Friday Night Fights: What would Destructoid be without FNF edition
Pandemic and EA reveal Lord of the Rings: Conquest
NVIDIA wants to make its products more 'consumer friendly'
Doom 4 rears its Hellish head, looking for fresh souls to bring it to life
more PC games, news, and reviews


DS NEWS
Konami Gamer's Night '08: Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia details and screens
Lil' Sims returning to Wii and DS with MySims Kingdom
Let me show you Pokemans Platinum: My Pokemans Platinum, let me show it to you
THQ announces Viva Piņata: Pocket Paradise for Nintendo DS
EA announces that you will Skate whatever 'it' is on the DS, Wii
Learn how to run a convenience store with your DS!
Nintendo eats the Big Mushroom, nearly doubles revenue
Tecmo Bowl: Kickoff coming to DS
more nintendo ds news and reviews


PSP NEWS
Captain Obvious: Sony admits PSP needs more games
Mario Kart Wii and Monster Hunter 2nd: Japan's top sellers for three weeks
Talk nerdy into Sony's new PSP headset
Covers and screenshots shown for PS2 and PSP versions of NCAA Football 09
Destructoid Review: R-Type Command
Secret Agent Clank gets date and snazzy bow tie
Word: SouthPeak Games officially announces B-Boy for North American release
Developer D2C calls PSP 'a sleeping giant'
more psp news and reviews

RETRO GAMING NEWS
No Balls, No Glory: Super Dodge Ball soundtrack remixed
The Little Convention That Could: A look back at TooManyGames 6
Activision preps Pitfall Harry's 'big adventure' for the Wii (Update)
No RetroforceGO! this week, you make Mikuru cry
Run like a raptor! Pixeljam Games' Dino Run released
RetroforceGO! Episode 48: The retro renaissance?
RetroforceGO! recording episode 48 tonight: Upcoming retro revivals
The Great Retro Quiz! .30: Super Mario Kart
more retro gaming news

tokidoki anime


Japanator - Anime Blog  | Tomopop - Vinyl Toys Blog  |  Poprox - Pop culture blog  |  MiamiNights - Miami Blog
Be Famous! Sort of. Submit a news tip to Dtoid  | Advertising  |  Privacy Policy  |  Powered by Elephant


NOT THE SURGEON GENERAL'S WARNING: The stuff overheard on Destructoid's community blogs do not yet quite personify the sound of wounded dolphins mating nor reflect the opinions of Destructoid LLC, the Webby-honorated group of promiscuously jolly associate editors that update our home page daily. Read our manifesto and see what we're all about. Participating in Destructoid contests gives us permission to impregnate with your wives and horses, drink all of your beer, and eat all of your nacho dip. Anything submitted becomes the property of the public Internet under creative commons and may end up on some emo kid's arm. Some rights reserved, etc, keep your filthy lawyers tucked away in their sad oak-furnished offices saying things like WHEREAS in all caps and as far away from us as possible or we may hurt them and their vulnerable pets. Please tell a friend about DTOID and contribute: help us keep it fresh, higly accurate and relevant, fun, honest, never too stuffy, and always independent. Also, cocks.