Quantcast
Battlefield 3: Impressive game, questionable experience - Destructoid

DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist



Battlefield 3  



Battlefield 3: Impressive game, questionable experience


12:00 PM on 09.28.2011
Battlefield 3: Impressive game, questionable experience photo



Battlefield 3 went into beta yesterday, and despite some controversy with people not getting their codes when promised, things have kicked off relatively smoothly. I got to spend time with the PC version of the game, and I've come away mostly impressed. 

With Battlefield 3, my one major worry was that so much time had been spent on the graphics, the actual important stuff would feel lacking in energy. Having finally tested out the "Rush" mode presented in the demo, my fears have taken a dramatic downturn and my hopes have conversely boosted.

Mostly ...

Before we kick off, I can't help but do the obvious thing and gush about the visuals. Those graphics are something else. As I said, I'm testing the PC version of the game, on a new rig that Nvidia helped set up for me specifically for instances such as this. I'm using an Intel i7-2600k @3.40 GHz, with 8GB of RAM, and the GPU is one of those new-fangled GeForce GTX 580 deals in SLI.

On that little setup, Battlefield 3 is easily one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen. In fact, real life looks like shit in comparison. I could nitpick about how the water effects need a little more work (it doesn't look too convincing when players are swimming in it) or the occasional physics glitch, but this is a beta, and the overall product is simply stunning. 

Fortunately, the gameplay seems to be holding up its end of the bargain as well. It's certainly nothing innovative -- this is a military shooter with classes, experience points, and unlockable equipment, after all -- but in terms of sheer refinement, BF3 makes for a surprisingly silky affair. Rush Mode has one team pressing the attack against bases that move across a huge map, which could easily be three maps, and the natural sense of flow that one gets is incredibly pleasant. 

Battlefield 3 is a fast game. You spawn fast, you kill fast, and if you lose concentration for a second, you'll die fast. It's a faster game than any other military shooter on the market, to the point where victory in combat is all about who spots who first. Some may dislike that, especially fans of heavier, Halo-esque multiplayer, but I personally dig the focus on quick reflexes and good positioning over attrition and strafing. 

My first impressions of the game are quite positive overall, and I've come away with a lot more than I was expecting. We're so close to the review that I don't want to get into too much detail, but I'll say I'm looking forward to the full game far more than I was before I tried the beta. 

However ...

This browser-based Battlelog stuff? That is a crap setup, and I cannot emphasize that enough. Having to open Origin to open a tab in my browser to access a very limited menu isn't my idea of entertainment, and runs counter to the gorgeous fluidity of the in-game experience. One can't even fine tune the game's video and controller settings within the browser. If you want to make those kind of alterations, you have to start a match, wait to spawn, and then tinker with them while you ought to be playing the game. You can't access the menu between respawns, or during the post-game lobby. It's absolutely ludicrous. 

This very silly implementation most certainly detracts from what is shaping up to be an otherwise impeccable game. I cannot wait to drink in the spectacle of the full product, and I've never been more excited for the PC version of a title especially. However, Battlefield 3 is suffering through lack of a proper menu system, and the mandatory nature of Battlelog places proprietary services over and above usability or player convenience. 

Such an attitude is about as ugly as Battlefield 3 is beautiful.








Comments not appearing? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this.
Easy fix: Add   [*].disqus.com   to your software's white list. Tada! Happy comments time again.

Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.





timeline following:
Battlefield 3



8:00 AM on 10.17.2013
Death from above in Battlefield 3 - Challenge Scot

This week's challenge is in Battlefield 3 in which I attempt to run over an enemy player whilst piloting an air vehicle. With so many other players ready to blow me out of the sky combined with my lack of piloting skills, this might be just beyond my grasp! If you've got any ideas for future challenges you'd like me to have a go at, feel free to leave them in the comments!more



6:15 PM on 10.03.2013
DICE: 'We should be slapped' for Battlefield 3 unlocks

Remember when Battlefield 3 came out and all everyone was doing was impotently running helicopters into the ground? DICE wasn't happy with the its flying learning curve, according to Battlefield 4 creative director Lars Gust...more



11:45 AM on 04.26.2013
'Who the f*ck gives a sh*t about f*cking Xbox 360?'

It's an innocuous enough little blog post -- an article on Battlelog aiming to help Xbox 360 users save space on their hard-drives by deleting obsolete Battlefield 3 update files. Fair enough, right? Wrong!  The otherwis...more



4:30 PM on 03.07.2013
Pterodactyls are invading Battlefield 3's End Game!

DICE really loves dinosaurs. It's no more apparent than with their final downloadable content pack for Battlefield 3, End Game. Users have already found a number of Easter Eggs, such as the pterodactyl that's flying around o...more



11:00 AM on 03.05.2013
Get pumped with the Battlefield 3 End Game launch trailer

End Game, the final downloadable content pack for Battlefield 3, is out today first to those that have Premium membership on the PlayStation 3. There's four new maps, a bunch of new vehicles, new modes, a new weapon, and mor...more



12:00 PM on 03.04.2013
Battlefield 3's End Game DLC starts rolling out this week

Battlefield 3's End Game downloadable content is almost here! Battlefield 3 Premium members on the PlayStation 3 get the content first this week on March 5. Then Premium users on PC and Xbox 360 get it on March 12. Non-premiu...more



8:30 AM on 02.28.2013
Battlefield 3 players create 2.3B explosions per day

If you've ever played Battlefield 3, rest assured that EA has tracked everything you've done online and turned you into a statistic -- a pretty cool statistic at that. According to a report from VentureBeat, every day EA coll...more



8:30 PM on 02.15.2013
A closer look at the maps in Battlefield 3: End Game

Building on what we recently saw of the End Game expansion for Battlefield 3, DICE has another batch of screenshots, this time focusing on the four new maps. "Size-wise, they are comparable to Caspian Border and Operation Fi...more



9:30 PM on 02.08.2013
Three whole Battlefield 3: End Game screenshots

With the latest Battlefield 3 expansion pack dropping next month, DICE has a few screenshots to tide us over in the meantime. End Game, as you'll probably remember, is the one that introduces the Capture the Flag and Air Supe...more



2:30 PM on 01.31.2013
Latest Battlefield 3 trailer shows off CTF in 'End Game'

The fifth and final expansion for Battlefield 3 will be End Game. How appropriately titled. EA was kind enough to give us a good look at what we're getting come March. The two big points for this trailer are Captur...more




First-person shooter

4:18 PM on 04.12.2014
Titanfall's first DLC is Expedition, comes out in May

During Respawn's PAX East panel on the development of Titanfall the team announced its first new DLC, Expedition, which takes place after the story (it had one) of Titanfall. Shown off in the above screen is Swampland, where ...more



1:40 PM on 04.12.2014
Evolve has changed to allow for more customization

The very core of Turtle Rock's Evolve revolves around the four versus one premise, and even though it's only been two months since we last saw it, the "one" side of things has since undergone some changes. The developers...more



2:00 PM on 04.11.2014
EA working to move BF2, Bad Company 2, and 2142 away from GameSpy

GameSpy Technology is shutting down on May 31, 2014 and that's real bad news for the many games that rely on the service for online functionality such as multiplayer matchmaking and leaderboards. It's largely unclear what wil...more



View all First-person shooter






Back to Top




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more