Quantcast
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim - Destructoid

DestructoidJapanatorTomopopFlixist



Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim


4:20 PM on 09.18.2009
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo



It's good news/bad news time again. Bad news first: for the next few weeks, I'll be borrowing Art Attack Friday from the infinitely more sexy and attractive Hamza"CTZ" Aziz. The good news: I come bearing gifts -- namely, an exclusive look at some original artwork for Braid, by none other than indie darling Edmund McMillen.

Edmund did all the near-final character design and art for for Braid except for the game's first boss. At some point, Jonathan Blow (Braid's creator) hired the game's other fantastic, amazing artist, David Hellman, to paint over or otherwise alter nearly all of Edmund's work so that they would match the games backgrounds.

Personally, I like Edmund's style a lot more. David's version of Tim was (and still is) a big turn-off to me. He's realistically rendered enough to give me that "uncanny valley" feeling, while remaining baby-proportioned and pseudo-cute in a way that comes off as generic. Worse still, his blank, permanently optimistic expression actually gives me the creeps.

In contrast, Edmund's designs for Tim are clean, expressive, and far from generic (by videogame standards, anyway). His Tim is clearly an adult, not a doll, yet he remains "cute" and easy to relate with. Not only does it look like I could draw Edmund's version of Tim, but I sense that I know how this Tim really feels. Where Hellman's Tim is Chucky, Edmund's Tim is Charlie Brown.

That's my opinion, anyway. What do you think? Which Tim do you like the most? Also, hit the jump for an exclusive look at Edmund's version of Tim in motion, and tune in next week for more exclusive, never-before-seen Braid art from McMillen. 

Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo
Art Attack Friday: The Braid that almost was part 1: Tim photo





Comments not appearing? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this.
Easy fix: Add   [*].disqus.com   to your software's white list. Tada! Happy comments time again.

Did you know? You can now get daily or weekly email notifications when humans reply to your comments.







Win your choice of console from Destructoid! in Destructoid's Hangs on LockerDome

Platform games

5:30 PM on 08.19.2014
Vagante is a tough, promising 2D action-platformer

Nuke Nine has launched a Kickstarter for its action-platformer with RPG elements Vagante and the best part about the pitch -- well, besides several attention-grabbing .gifs -- is the included demo. Vagante has permanent deat...more



1:45 PM on 08.18.2014
The best version of Guacamelee! hits Steam on Thursday

Now that the console releases are out of the way, DrinkBox Studios is bringing Guacamelee! Super Turbo Championship Edition to Steam on Thursday. This expanded version of the hit action-platformer offers new areas, abilities...more



4:30 PM on 08.15.2014
The latest Sonic Boom trailer is rife with quips and a movie announcer dude

Are you tired of Sonic Boom yet? Oh, you are? Well, I guess you won't want to check out this new trailer, then. See if I care. The latest trailer details some of the enemies and villains Sonic will face up against,...more



View all Platform games






Back to Top




All content is yours to recycle through our Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing requiring attribution. Our communities are obsessed with videoGames, movies, anime, and toys.

Living the dream since March 16, 2006

Advertising on destructoid is available: Please contact them to learn more