Note: iOS 9 + Facebook users w/ trouble scrolling: #super sorry# we hope to fix it asap. In the meantime Chrome Mobile is a reach around
hot  /  reviews  /  videos  /  cblogs  /  qposts

Are games bloggers less trustworthy than 'real' journalists?

2:20 PM on 07.13.2009 // Jim Sterling

In November of last year (that's last year, not today as some outlets might lead you to believe), the Federal Trade Commission took a worrying interest in online media, singling out game bloggers in particular as outlets that need to disclose whenever they receive free items pertaining to reviews published by their site. The New York Times, (late to the party as most newspapers are), has agreed with the assessment, basically insinuating that bloggers are far less trustworthy than real journalists.

"The readers of his blog are unlikely to expect that he has received the video game system free of charge in exchange for his review of the product, and given the value of the video game system, this fact would likely materially affect the credibility they attach to his endorsement," states the FTC in one of its examples. "Accordingly, the blogger should clearly and conspicuously disclose that he received the gaming system free of charge."

The FTC seems to believe that this is only necessary for bloggers and not other forms of media, indicating that a site like Destructoid is somehow far less trustworthy than your average print rag. The New York Times goes even further, implying heavily that blogs work to please sponsors: "But unlike postings in most journalism outlets or independent review sites, most companies can be assured that there will not be a negative review: if [blogger Colleen Padilla] does not like a product, she simply does not post anything about it."

Hit the jump for my thoughts. 

This is an interesting issue that is going to see a lot of overreaction, but first of all, the major problem here is how one distinguishes bloggers and journalists. It's become a very gray area, especially since many bloggers have found themselves to be more trusted than more so-called "journalists." I'd personally take the words of any blogger over some hack writer for a dishrag tabloid like The Daily Mail or The Sun.

These days, it's both unfair and untrue to imply, as The NY Times has done, that bloggers are somehow less trustworthy than "real" journalists. After all, purveyors of aged news like the NY Times and sensationalist news stations like FOX News, often have to worry about corporate sponsorship and pleasing ad networks far more than bloggers, who are generally independent and free to express their own opinion. To say that it's bloggers who have tainted opinions, when it's "professional" news outlets that are very clearly ruled by marketing, is somewhat hypocritical. 

That's not to say that bloggers are, themselves, angels. You get a lot of liars on sites like Tumblr, who will just spit up any old crap in the name of freebies and attention. The point is that you can't really separate bloggers and journalists, and then state that one group is more truthful than the other. Both sets of media have their angels and devils. 

As far as the FTC goes, I personally find it very disturbing that a government-operated body wants to exert control over the Internet. Sadly, it's an inevitability that one day the Internet will be as regulated and restricted as television and print media, but I would hope that we still have a few years of free enterprise left online. While The NY Times would like to color our impression of blogs and imply that a lack of accountability (not that print media ever takes responsibility) could lead to corruption, I embrace the freedom that blogging gives us, the ability to say whatever we want. 

The FTC states that people have a right to know when they're being "pitched to," which I find hilarious coming from an organization that allowed those duplicitous corn syrup commercials to run. I guess lies and misinformation are okay when they're government-sponsored lies and misinformation. It's alarming to me that blogs are being painted as the untrustworthy ones. Neither the FTC nor print media have an excellent reputation.

As far as games "journalism" goes, all I can say is that, again, I'll trust the opinions of an outlet that simply gets free games than an outlet that works to get hot exclusive reviews and buys its way to the top of the food chain. The FTC and NY Times would somehow have us believe that Gamespot is more trustworthy than an enthusiast blog. simply because one is "professional." As far as I recall it was a "professional" outlet that fired one of its editors for giving a game a negative review.

I just think the FTC has this the wrong way around -- focusing on the accountability of bloggers more than big corporate outlets. It's the big boys who I'd be keeping an eye on, not the little guys who hold themselves accountable to no overbearing company, nor has a marketing department to worry about.

The FTC of course is mainly focused on personal sites written by unpaid hobbyists, but even so, it's a bit cheeky to hold these small enthusiasts more accountable than professionals. While some people are misinterpreting the FTC's guidelines and thinking all blogs are being thrown under a bus, I think the truth of the matter is even worse a little. Why should we make small hobbyists accountable? Let them do their thing. 

If the FTC did want Destructoid and other paid blogs to disclose every little thing we receive, that would be fine in and of itself, if rather invasive. However, it's the singling out of bloggers and not "real" journalists that would piss me off. We are not the ones who should be scrutinized, and besides which, I think our readers are smart enough to know that we already get review copies and the occasional bit of swag. We've never denied it, and we've often made fun articles whenever we get cool stuff. That's more than can be said for the average magazine, that rarely ever discloses a thing. 

If somebody wants to believe that review copies color our opinions, that's up to them. We can't convince them otherwise. We're not going to stop accepting review copies, because we're an indie site and until one of these morally outraged readers offers to spend the necessary several hundred bucks per month for the review team, we're not going to go out buying every single videogame under the Sun.

I think our track record speaks for itself, however. Just check out Metacritic and see how our scores stack up to those of more "trusted" outlets. You can't ever say that a free review copy guarantees a high score from Destructoid. Just check out the Resistance: Retribution review or the Warriors Orochi 2 review. Both of those games were given to me. 

I'll continue to trust bloggers more than "real" journalists, and I'll continue to call myself a blogger. The word "journalist" is a word I'm ashamed of, and it's thanks to just how untrustworthy journos have become. People ought to perhaps consider that the next time they put bloggers under a microscope.

Jim Sterling, Former Reviews Editor
 Follow Blog + disclosure JimSterling Tips
Destructoid reviews editor, responsible for running and maintaining the cutting edge videogame critique that people ignore because all they want to see are the scores at the end. Also a regular f... more   |   staff directory

 Setup email comments

Unsavory comments? Please report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our community fisters, and flag the user (we will ban users dishing bad karma). Can't see comments? Apps like Avast or browser extensions can cause it. You can fix it by adding * to your whitelists.

Status updates from C-bloggers

SeymourDuncan17 avatarSeymourDuncan17
I wish the Squid Girl outfit was still a dress for boys. I want to live through my Inkling boy and be a cute girly-man, dammit. [img][/img]
Zer0t0nin avatarZer0t0nin
Goshdarnit...just stood in front of the camera to record an intro for the advent calender thingy and actually got stage fright >.>
KnickKnackMyWack avatarKnickKnackMyWack
Well, it seemed like for two seconds people were finally going to give Star Fox a fair shake, but nope! GameXplain's YouTube audience seem pretty insistent that it's just a Star Fox 64 clone down to the graphics. Sometimes I just don't understand peopl
Dr Mel avatarDr Mel
I don't think it will happen, but if the NX is turns out to be a VR device, I will be the saddest boy in the milky way.
Mike Martin avatarMike Martin
There's something so fucking delicious about a toasted Hawaiian roll, smoked ham, Swiss, some spinach and a dollop of mustard. #FatKidPosts
Still in work clothes.
Gamemaniac3434 avatarGamemaniac3434
Welp, wrote up a blog for that there bloggers wanted. Its me bitching about Bioshock Infinite! Again! Yay!!!!!!
Sr Churros avatarSr Churros
Just finished watching The Phantom Menace. Yeah, Jar Jar is as bad as people say. Baby Vader is so cute and also kicks some serious ass. One of the best lightsaber battles of the series, if not the best one. It was pretty neat!
Roxas1359 avatarRoxas1359
Can't decide where I should upload my latest project. Either on my YouTube Channel or on Game Anyone. On the one hand YouTube gets more exposure, but Game Anyone is where some of my more popular walkthroughs are. The game is 3D Land if anyone is wondering
Fuzunga avatarFuzunga
Thanksgiving dinner for days!
OverlordZetta avatarOverlordZetta
Anyone know if the Bethesda games on sale on Amazon for a certain amount of time, or through Monday?
TysonOfTime avatarTysonOfTime
In light of the fact that Xenoblade Chronicles X is fast approaching, I suggest we start planning out a Destructoid Squad! NNID is TysonOfTime. From what I've heard, it doesn't appear Squads are region locked (except for Japan), so everyone's welcome!
Jed Whitaker avatarJed Whitaker
Typing of the Dead > all other typing games.
Lawman avatarLawman
Listening to this on a Tall Oaks level of RE: Revelations 2's Raid Mode is entrancing, for some reason.
EdgyDude avatarEdgyDude
Need a reason to support Indivisible? Shantae is in it!. Back it or spread the word, every bit of help counts.
KeithTheGeek avatarKeithTheGeek
Sometimes I miss how hilariously janky Brawl was, and I still have a lot of fun playing it. Not sure if I could ever take it seriously as a competitive game, but I want to enter at least one Brawl tournament in the future. You know, if I can find one.
KnickKnackMyWack avatarKnickKnackMyWack
I love how on a slow news day I can always turn to Qposts for something else to read and think about. Keep up the mojo fellas!
Rad Party God avatarRad Party God
I finally caved in to those sweet deals, got Shantae and The Pirate's Curse, Downwell and Super House of Dead Ninjas :)
CoilWhine avatarCoilWhine
I hope that Prototype runs better on my dad's old laptop than it does on my AMD gaming rig. Some badly coded games run like ass on AMD cards.
LinkSlayer64 avatarLinkSlayer64
Please spare me from issues in the process of publishing my blog! Especially since I modified CSS to unnecessarily pseudo-crop an image, and make it so some images float next to text, and make it look decent on mobile. I'm a frickin' nerd, love it.
more quickposts



Invert site colors

  Dark Theme
  Light Theme

Destructoid means family.
Living the dream, since 2006

Pssst. konami code + enter

modernmethod logo

Back to Top

We follow moms on   Facebook  and   Twitter
  Light Theme      Dark Theme
Pssst. Konami Code + Enter!
You may remix stuff our site under creative commons w/@
- Destructoid means family. Living the dream, since 2006 -