games  anime  |  toys
Destructoid is gaming news, community, videos, and sometimes love. Take the tour or jump in with Facebook:

 


A note to movie reviewers: Not all videogames are mindless entertainment! photo

Some might say I am a happy-go-lucky guy. I walk around the streets of Los Angeles with a noticeable spring in my step and occasionally (read: all the time) get caught humming a song from Mary Poppins as I brush my teeth in the morning. Basically, not many things get me angry.

Lately, though, something in particular has been making me a little crabby. In fact, I would go so far as to say it is really getting my goat. So what is so bad it is forcing me to bust out the old lady phrases? Well, here, take a look at this quote from the recent Entertainment Weekly movie review of Star Wars: The Clone Wars:

The animated Anakin, Obi-Wan, etc. (all with faux movie-star voices) are drones, and the repetitive combat sequences only add to the turgid videogame anonymity of it all.

After I looked up what “turgid” meant, I was outraged. These blanket statements about videogames being mindless entertainment have got to stop! Seriously. Enough is enough. I dedicate my life to an art form (yes, art form!) that, at times, can be much more emotionally satisfying and rewardingly complex than any movie I have ever seen. And, yes, that includes my beloved Showgirls!

Hit the jump for a rant/plea directed at all you movie reviewers out there. Please know that I greatly admire what you do. I would just appreciate it if that respect was returned.

First things first: I dislike The Clone Wars just as much as you. I am not mad that you hated the movie. In fact, I would probably lose respect for you if you didn't.

My problem is how you compare a specific movie lacking thought or substance to a medium as broad as videogames. The issue is simple as that. Sure, you may not think it offends anyone -- I am guessing you even think you are being accurate -- but I am here to tell you that you are wrong.

As an example, let me write a fake review for a made-up videogame using the same tactic that Mr. Gleiberman (the reviewer from Entertainment Weekly) used:

The Suns of Dragnor (my horribly uncreative made-up videogame) is an uninspired piece of filth. In particular, the set pieces -- invoking the same lack of creative thought evident in film -- do nothing to stimulate the imagination.

You see? Writing a generic comparison to something as varied as film makes me look uneducated and completely misinformed.

Now, had I said this, things would have read a lot differently:

The Suns of Dragnor is an uninspired piece of filth. In particular, the set pieces -- invoking the same lack of creative thought evident in something like The Number 23 -- do nothing to stimulate the imagination.

Instead of “videogame,” had you used something specific like Yaris, we all would have understood what you meant -- and applauded the comparison in the process!

Maybe you are right. Maybe the general public that reads your magazine doesn’t know most videogames by name. In fact, maybe you yourself don’t know the difference between the quality of F-Zero and the awfulness of Big Mutha Truckers. I am not faulting you for not being a gamer. But, if this lack of knowledge is the case, MAYBE YOU SHOULDN’T USE THE MEDIUM AS AN EXAMPLE!

It’s funny. Things like this don’t usually bother me, but I feel like my mind has been inundated with so much of it lately I can’t help but ignore it.

Here is another quote, this time from Roger Ebert’s review of Death Race:

It is an assault on all the senses, including common. Walking out, I had the impression I had just seen the video game and was still waiting for the movie.

Again, the word videogame is used to describe something obviously inferior to film. In this case, things are more specific (Roger Ebert is obviously referring to the nonexistent videogame version of Death Race), but just as silly.

Do you really think videogames are an “assault on all the senses?” I know your work, Mr. Ebert. I know how much you worshipped the (admittedly great) films Dark City and Babe: Pig in the City for their daring visual styles. Had you bothered to look, you might find something to love in videogames like Okami or the stunning Shadow of the Colossus.

The bottom line: All I ask is that you movie reviewers think about what you type before you type it. I am a gamer and proud of it. I have dedicated my career to writing about videogames -- a life I find both admirable and challenging. Your comments don’t horribly upset me, but it is tough to hear a respected journalist not only misunderstand what videogames are, but denigrate the hardworking, talented members of the gaming industry by issuing generic statements saying that videogames are basically nothing more than mindless flashing lights (whew!).

With the enormous success of the gaming industry, maybe it’s time to educate yourself on what videogames can truly offer. You might be surprised to find they can be both beautiful and -- gasp! -- thought-provoking ... just like your precious movies.


Continue: More Movies stories





prev next

47 comments | showing # 1 to 47

Etelmik's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:03
Etelmik
Maybe by "turgid videogame anonymity" he just meant video games that are turgid, not that all video games are turgid. And maybe Ebert isn't an ass--video game versions of movies aren't exactly great.

Oh, who am I kidding. They have it in for us and they don't know what the hell they're talking about.
Tubatic's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:09
Tubatic
I fully endorse this rant! You tell'em Chad.

In a world where there's some respect for the industry with regards to evaluation, Roger's comments about Death Race compared to game should have some broad validity: I made the comparison in my mind as well.

However, MY connection was in relation to bad movie tie ins, and the prsence of Jason Statham, who honest has appeared in more video game-esque movies than anyone on the planet. If you don't believe me, read the synopsis' for Crank and The Transporter and tell me it doesn't read like a quest synopsis or a fun game mechanic.
Necros's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:10
Necros
I think some of the issue is that, while there are certainly many games that display some artistic merit, and some that actually classify wholly as "art," there are even more video games that are just games. And really, there's nothing wrong with that. F-Zero is a great game, but it's also kind of impossible to compare to film, due in no small part to its complete lack of plot. To give a better comparison, the execution of plot in Halo 3, the conclusion to a trilogy some called "the Star Wars of video games" (not my words), is decidedly inferior to that of the actual Star Wars trilogy. When you hear a reviewer criticize a movie like 300 for being a video game brought to life, yes, they're obviously generalizing, but that's because the plot is like that.

Right now, the strength of video games lies in creating emotions and telling stories in different ways than film, but that doesn't mean the majority of those stories and plots are as complex or of high quality as most films. I think reviewers, with the exception of Mr. Ebert, are starting to come around to the idea that some games are culturally worthwhile to compare to their fancy-shmancy art. But right now, the medium of games is still limited in what they have done, and it's going to take more time before we see less "video gamey" game plots.

Also, Death Race the Game? That might actually be better than the movie, if they restore the concept from the original film of randomly running over non-racers for points.
Conrad Zimmerman's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:10
Conrad Zimmerman
No, Ebert's an ass. His hatred for videogames is well-documented.
wwjd4bbque's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:11
wwjd4bbque
Ignorant cognoscenti are ignorant.
Your breadth of knowledge in one medium does not give you the authority to disregard/blaspheme another. Especially one know nothing about.
Great, now I'm a crabby mofo.
wwjd4bbque's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:12
wwjd4bbque
*"one YOU know"
chanbot's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:13
chanbot
Yeah, Ebert is an ass.
Blind assassin's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:14
Blind assassin
Some video games a quite turgid. I'd say that Cho Aniki has quite a lot of turgidness to it.

Gay jokes aside, this is one of those "Rock music doesn't make you insane you religious sycophants!" into the ether rants. Anyone with a brain would agree but most people are more fond of misinformed pandering than truth.
Samit Sarkar's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:18
Samit Sarkar
Chad, you're aiming straight for my heart with this one -- but alas, I think you're just preaching to the choir here. You should e-mail this article to Ebert & Gleiberman!
kapshhh's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:21
kapshhh
You can't teach an old dog new tricks.
Maxxthepenguin's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:22
Maxxthepenguin
A bit sensitive?

So what, some people don't like the medium. Make strong examples of why they're wrong and make that a trend and they'll listen. Too bad the industry doesn't do that.
TheCleaningGuy's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:29
TheCleaningGuy
I concur. Brilliantly written article. It's a shame that videogames are short-changed simply because they're a new medium. I suppose though, that I'd assume all movies were crap if I'd only seen "Click." Hopefully these professionals will stop being so ignorant.
@Samit: Seconded! Send that article out!
Blind assassin's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:31
Blind assassin
@Maxxthepenguin

Something as sweeping as an entire MEDIUM of entertainment shouldn't have to go out of its way to justify its existence to ignoramuses.
Colette Bennett's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:31
Colette Bennett
I love you, Chad.
Professor Pew's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:32
Professor Pew
I thought Clone Wars was enjoyable from my couch :(

When Ebert says "it felt like the videogame", he doesn't mean that there is a videogame of it, but that it felt like all the explosions and action were pointless etc. Which is in line with most videogames and why the mainstream critics still doesn't accept them. Then again, looking at top sellers across the board, who can blame them? :P
Brian Keljore's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:38
Brian Keljore
Gotta love the passion you put into this. I am of the opinion that movie reviewers are threatened by video games, because if the majority view it as a form of art, they might be asked to review a piece of media that involves more than being a snide little prick who sits on his ass with a bucket of popcorn or other some snack and maybe a drink to (usually) write a small review on a movie that will often talk more about the people behind the movie and the respect (or lack there of) they have for everyone involved than actually reviewing the goddamn movie.

Secondly, there is a video game called Death Race, but I don't think it counts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_Race
Reeper's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:46
Reeper
What do you mean there's no Death Race videogame? It's called Twisted Metal.
droobies's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 17:59
droobies
Maybe we can get Superflossy to hit that EW reviewer in the back of the head for us. VIDEOGAME VIOLENCE!
Capn Birdseye's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:01
Capn Birdseye
I agree with your sentiments, but I guess the main difference here is that I don't really need any validation from the industry that whelped tripe like "Epic Movie".
Chad Concelmo's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:04
Chad Concelmo
@Capn Birdseye,
Nicely said. :)
Poopface Morty's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:07
Poopface Morty
Entertainment Weekly is so full of itself that sometimes I think they are trying to be Pitchfork, but at the same time they laud completely laughable garbage.

Damn fine article, I would just like to see something a little longer and more fleshed out (sans flesh), and is actually sent to these culture critics.
DanlHaas's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:11
DanlHaas
Thank God for you, Chad Concelmo.

I agree with Samit, though, this message definitely needs to reach beyond the Dtoid army.
Dexter345's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:12
Dexter345
Now, all we have to do is send this article to the proper people...
Pixel Blue's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:29
Pixel Blue
Any drooling idiot can be plopped down in front of a movie. You just have to get him to sit still long enough to watch it.

A video game takes participation. Really enjoying a good movie does, too -- but a game *requires* it.

When it comes down to it, you can watch a movie where one character takes another's hand, and if it's well done you feel the connection yourself, but in ICO, I reached out and I took Yorda's hand, and it made a difference.
Kinji's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:31
Kinji
Great article Chad. In my local papers review for the movie they said that the upcoming game The Force Unleashed looked like it would be much better than the Clone Wars, in terms of both visuals and story. Reading that made me feel happy that a movie reviewer actually knew what he was talking about when it came to video games.
Murumasa123's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 18:51
Murumasa123
I was recently watching a TV show in which the presentor said that games arnt meant to be able to give you stories or be anything more than simplistic and pathetically mindless piece of entertainment. Its just bollacks as games have given me enough times to fell emtionally attached as films or TV has and its an annoying level of snobbery that keeps them below other forms of media.
danthemagnum's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 19:05
danthemagnum
Ebert plays games. He says it all the time (in not so many words). His problem isn't with video games, he's just a stickler for proper translation and "technicalities". He says that while games are fun, and imaginative, and beautiful they aren't art because they can be changed. The fact that you have choices and interactivity changes them from being a "direct intention of mood or idea" to more of a set of tools given to a person that allow them to do things their way. This takes away the "art" aspect as in it being someone's vision.

There are different interpretations of what art really is though, hell other critics argue with him.
wydren's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 19:09
wydren
You've got to admit though, most games aren't that great as art. Granted, most movies aren't either, but it's pretty rare you get a video game with as brilliant a narrative as Bioshock.

@ Pixel Blue & anybody really, do you really feel as if you are the main character when you play video games? I've never played one where I didn't feel like I was controlling someone else, just like in movies I always feel like I'm watching someone else. Granted, the control aspect is what separates video games and added that great narrative twist to Bioshock.
The Amazing Shenazin's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 19:48
The Amazing Shenazin
most movie critics are just too old to understand
MechaMonkey's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 20:05
MechaMonkey
These fellas should be dying soon. And then all will be well.
Big Z's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 20:32
Big Z
I liked The Number 23 :(
SWE3tMadness's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 22:24
SWE3tMadness
Preacher: meet Choir.

But yeah, great writeup. The mainstream press sort of regards video games as a curious, compartmentalized fad right now, but as gamers themselves continue to grow up and replace the older generations, that mindset will start to change.

Very few video games actually fit underneath "art" (in my opinion) though. So you can't really fault them for drawing conclusions based on Madden and Wii Sports. When an art game like Ico is called "revolutionary" for its own medium, then you know that that level of aesthetic is the exception, not the norm.
ace of knaves's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/09/2008 22:41
ace of knaves
Oh God I was going to say something relevant but Birdseye reminded me about the existence of Disaster Movie, and now I can't stop shaking with rage. Seriously, ugh.
Wedge's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 00:44
Wedge
I SAW The Number 23... in theatres... oh good lord....
Demtor's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 08:14
Demtor
Yes! Go angry Chad, go! Ohhh, the nerd rage inside of me!

GRRRRR!

Film Critics = people without enough talent to actually create, so instead they hate for a living.

Hey movie critics, I like insightful views on movies as much as the next guy, but know your fucking role and STFU.

Hey Roger Ebert, I'm sorry you were too good for Death Race. Your right, movies shouldn't be fun. Enjoy your miserable exsistence as a pretentious ass. Enjoy.

*breathes deep*
welkstar's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 08:56
welkstar
I totally agree with you Chad. Well done!

Btw-Death Race the arcade game.
Brilliam's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 12:45
Brilliam
@Demtor don't knock Ebert for thinking movies shouldn't be fun. He's a constant champion for GOOD, fun movies. Death Race was probably actually shit, if he didn't like it.

I can't fault the guy for being out of his element on games. He old. He's also dedicated his life to another medium which he thinks totally fucking rules more than anything! In fact, he's one of the most important people to film; no wonder he feels threatened by games, which ARE invading movies stylistically, and for the worse (and stealing new viewers away). I mean maybe he needs to turn it down a notch but Ebert's ok by me.
SyntaxError's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 12:54
SyntaxError
Brilliam, you reminded me of the "ZOMG GTA4 WILL RUIN IRON MAN'S PREMIER" debacle. Or was that really Iron Man? I seem to have forgotten, memory's a little fuzzy at 2 in the morning.
Ronsauce's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 15:39
Ronsauce
Where the hell did this idea come from that games(for the most part) aren't art if they don't have compelling, emotional story lines despite having great character design, level design, animation, etc... If I'm more emotionally moved by a shitty comedy that's shot and acted poorly than by some incredibly boring indie flick with great camera work, does that mean the latter isn't art? Art for me is something visual or auditory; being able to bullshit some personalized, deep meaning out of a game doesn't mean it should be considered art more than a game with a unique visual style. Gah...pretentious bullshit!
John B's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/10/2008 19:45
John B
Six out of five dolphins for you, Chad! (The extra dolphin is for the Okami pic.) :)
Ravana's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/12/2008 02:55
Ravana
Somebody PLEASE give angry Chad a cookie before he explodes. Don't forget to give him his stuffed dolphin when you put him down for his nap.

All genres have their waste, and their esoteric. Videogames are no different, and just because someone calls us out on it (regardless of how inaccurate or just plain horrible as it might be) doesn't mean we need to get huffy. No avoiding bad press, especially when some of the games we love create it to fulfill a certain niche we desire.
Knives's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/12/2008 02:56
Knives
I don't see why the Auteur Theory can't be applied to games as it is applied to films.
arcadias's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/12/2008 08:13
arcadias
I know I'm late to the party but amen, Chad. Amen.
moot button's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/15/2008 13:33
moot button
What does my breakfast have to do with Okami?
slapme7times's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/15/2008 17:40
slapme7times
Ebert is an old man, he wasn't born in the digital age, and thus, he can't fully grasp the medium.

I think that if he played bioshock, or watched someone playing it, that he could appreciate the visuals, writing and voiceacting...

It's simply that the gameplay doesn't make sense to him... It is really difficult for people who have never gamed before to grasp using a controller...

Ebert isn't an asshole, he's just an aging relic of a time with drastically different technology.
AXE A DENTIST's Avatar - Comment posted on 09/15/2008 23:56
AXE A DENTIST
I figured Death Race was just Twisted Metal: The Movie.. (without Sweettooth)
4knuckleshuffle's Avatar - Comment posted on 02/26/2009 13:55
4knuckleshuffle
Ebert is fat, and fatties are always wrong. Jim Sterling doesn't count, cause he's not fat.
prev next

Comment with Facebook





Click connect and comment instantly!

Comment with Dtoid





New? SIGN UP - it takes 5 seconds

Comments policy

Destructoid is an open discussion community. You don't need to "audition" to post a comment - just speak your mind. We respect differing opinions on the site, so have at it. Be smart, funny, insightful, clueless, or cute -- but back it up with substance. Keep your cool, keep it fun. We only ask that you act respectfully and above all: don't be a troll and ruin it for everyone else. Don't bring down gamers or we'll, you know, gently shoot you in the face and stuff you into a flaming mailbox. Each comment is your opportuntity to make this community awesomer. Is that even a word?

Avoiding the banhammer only requires common sense: spamming, trolling, racism, NSFW stuff, and other forms of sucking will not be tolerated. If anyone is griefing please report abuse. Be good. Don't suck!

 
New on Destructoid.TV play all videos

Loading
Loading Destructoid Videos


    Win this!
    Dive in! meetup+play for a chance to win a PC

    Dtoid Twitter    Got news?   tips@destructoid.com

    Reviews & Previews
    Assassin's Creed 2 review
    Crossfire Remote Pistol review
    Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles review
    Left 4 Dead 2 review
    Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Reflex review
    more reviews
    Driver
    Avatar
    GT Racing Motor Academy
    Bad Company 2 beta dishes out meaningful experiences
    Legend of Zelda Spirit Tracks
    more previews


    - The Dtoid Army is 51027 strong -

    Showing Cblogs with 3+ faps   show all

    Call for entries: do the wrong thing

    New to Dtoid? Read the survival guide




     Originals
    Chad Concelmo: The tragic history of the videogame turkey





















    More Destructoid Originals




     Popular now more






















    Team Destructoid   tips@destructoid.com
    Nick Chester
    Editor-in-Chief
    Niero
    Founder, publisher
    Jim Sterling
    Reviews Editor
    Hamza Aziz
    Community Manager
    Dale North
    News Editor
    Rey Gutierrez
    Video editor & director
    Anthony Burch
    Features Editor
    Colette Bennett
    Tom Fronczak Brad Nicholson
    Ashley Davis Ben Perlee
    Conrad
    Zimmerman
    Chad Concelmo
    Jonathan Holmes Jonathan Ross
    Brad Rice Jordan Devore
    Will Maddock Matthew Razak
    Dyson Joseph Leray
    Topher Cantler Samit Sarkar
         
      Dexter
    Adam Dork
    Daniel Lingen
    Hollie Bennett
    Joe Burling
    Mikey
    Stella Wong

    Josh Tolentino




     

     
      get involved

    register or login
    post a blog
    post a forum
    enter a contest
    contribute a news tip
    suggest a feature
    be a guest editor
    support

    new member's guide
    login assistance
    tech support
    report abuse
    email our editors
    read our dev blog
    nuclear crisis?
    keep in touch

    RSS feed
    Twitter
    Facebook
    Myspace
    Flickr
    Game nights
    Meetup+play online
    seriously

    about Destructoid
    advertising
    terms of use
    privacy policy
    jobs at MM
    buy our crap
    our network

    Tomopop
    Japanator
    Despingation?




    Destructoid is an independently-run publication forged by our love of video games and the gaming community's need of accountable enthusiast press
    living the dream since March 16, 2006